Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Game Builder: Create 3D games with friends, no experience required

blog.google

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–20 of 142 posts

Re: Game Builder: Create 3D games with friends, no experience required

#11

Post by kevingadd »

megaremote wrote: post #10

Why do I need steam for this? Seems very odd.

Steam provides a CDN, updater, friends list/social infrastructure, really terrible but functional user generated content sharing infrastructure, and cloud saves to game developers, so it's pretty appealing even if you're a team inside Google since the alternative is building your own installer and updater - Google has no competitor to Steam on Windows or any other platform of note other than Android.

Also, Gamers actively get angry with developers now if a game releases on something other than Steam, so it's probably better for PR and adoption rates to just target Steam and be done with it.

Re: Game Builder: Create 3D games with friends, no experience required

#12

Post by munchbunny »

elil17 wrote: post #2

It’s a shame that making simple games doesn’t require coding like it used to. For myself, and a lot of others I’m sure, games were a huge motivator to teach myself programming. Now kids won’t be as motivated to do that

I would have killed to have tools like Unity when I got into game programming. All of my hobby time was eaten up trying to wrangle OpenGL and C++ and crappy open source engines, and cobbling together a shitty physics engine, so I never got around to the actual game part. When I went back years later to prototype ideas in Unity, it was a breath of fresh air.

However, in my struggles to get off the ground, I did learn a lot more about font rendering than I ever wanted to, and it has come up unexpectedly useful.

Re: Game Builder: Create 3D games with friends, no experience required

#14

Post by dorkwood »

elil17 wrote: post #2

It’s a shame that making simple games doesn’t require coding like it used to. For myself, and a lot of others I’m sure, games were a huge motivator to teach myself programming. Now kids won’t be as motivated to do that

Looking at the site, it seems like they also allow for custom scripts if you want functionality that their templates don’t provide.

Re: Game Builder: Create 3D games with friends, no experience required

#16

Post by ggggtez »

soup10 wrote: post #15

Not sure who the audience for this is. Kids I guess? Game developers want engines and tools that make development easier without losing power or flexibility. Players want new interesting gaming experiences.

Yes it looks like it's for kids. Basically everything a kid would want from Minecraft, minus the licensed characters I guess.

Re: Game Builder: Create 3D games with friends, no experience required

#17

Post by ggggtez »

yangikan wrote: post #13

No tutorials on how to get started and the product could possibly be purged in another 3 years. Start with something like Gamemaker if you really want something that will be around for sometime.

based on the article, I think you missed the point. This is a competitor with Minecraft. Not a competitor to Unity.

Re: Game Builder: Create 3D games with friends, no experience required

#18

Post by arshbot »

soup10 wrote: post #15

Not sure who the audience for this is. Kids I guess? Game developers want engines and tools that make development easier without losing power or flexibility. Players want new interesting gaming experiences.

I'm not sure, I could see myself playing this with friends.

I enjoy playing games with friends that involve challenges,.but often that just translates to outmaneuvering some enemy in some game.

This seems like a great experience where we can really experience each other's creations. Sort of like Minecraft, but imo it's hard to embrace something that "belongs" to someone else, as things tend to be in minecraft.

Re: Game Builder: Create 3D games with friends, no experience required

#19

Post by cwyers »

elil17 wrote: post #2

It’s a shame that making simple games doesn’t require coding like it used to. For myself, and a lot of others I’m sure, games were a huge motivator to teach myself programming. Now kids won’t be as motivated to do that

Looking at the examples in there -- what exactly in that is simple to you? It's fully 3D, which is hard as fuck.

I learned a lot of skills doing Doom WADs that were less close to real coding than what this lets you do (full Javascript API).

Re: Game Builder: Create 3D games with friends, no experience required

#20

Post by soup10 »

ggggtez wrote: post #16
soup10 wrote: post #15

Not sure who the audience for this is. Kids I guess? Game developers want engines and tools that make development easier without losing power or flexibility. Players want new interesting gaming experiences.

Yes it looks like it's for kids. Basically everything a kid would want from Minecraft, minus the licensed characters I guess.

i dunno i think the survival/mining/crafting aspect of minecraft is a big part of what makes it popular. also i think the "card programming model" and every variation of that sort of thing is such a bad idea. either support real programming or don't, don't make users deal with some junky programming emulation system
Post reply on HN