Live data from Hacker News

GitHub removes 5 years of One Hour One Life designer's work

twitter.com

31–40 of 141 posts

Re: GitHub removes 5 years of One Hour One Life designer's work

#31

Seems it’s been a busy week for these reminders not to trust centralized services. I think the the “Fediverse” will become more popular over the next few years.

There are in fact people who are already trying to "federate" code collaboration https://nth.io/notice/7652

That's interesting. IIRC Linus Torvalds even came up with a tool to make "distributed/federated" code collaboration quite easy, avoiding any reliance on a single centralized host. Maybe we should start making use of it.

Re: GitHub removes 5 years of One Hour One Life designer's work

#32

From being on the other side of this kind of "big company screws little guy for no reason"... In ~80% of cases, there is more to the story than meets the eye. For example maybe a legal complaint came in, or someone was DoS attacking that repo and it put the whole GitHub service at risk.

It could be a BS/extortionate copyright strike, as it is becoming ever more common recently

Re: GitHub removes 5 years of One Hour One Life designer's work

#33
post #28
post #11

Jason Rohrer [1] is the author of Passage [2]. His latest game, "One Hour One Life" [3], is a massively multiplayer online game where your character has only one hour of life. You start off as a baby and are dependent on others for shelter and heat before you're able to be autonomous. Eventually you die of old age but your impact on the world/server persists. I recommend anyone interested to purchase the game [4] or…

He's also idiosyncratic in the approach to the rest of his life. When he practiced ‘simple living,’ in his front yard he had (or still has?) a small wild garden with uncut grass, where he of course walked barefoot and his children played naked (iirc). He was taken to the court by neighbors on the issue of grass, and appeared there with a tome of paper citing local laws and research that says cut grass exudes harmful…

It would seem that he has some idiosyncratic neighbors, then. But they are not alone, a certain amount of people are strangely obsessed by the grass of their neighbors. My kids loved the dandelions of my grass and I let them grow, but then I received regular bullying by the old lady next to our place, who had a "perfect" french style garden, and looked at us as if we were some kind of savages. I actually found this bevavior rather funny.

Re: GitHub removes 5 years of One Hour One Life designer's work

#34
post #13
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's always two sides to a story. That being said, it seems like every other week now there's a story of a cloud service or provider shutting something down or removing something, without our with very little notice, and the only recourse for somebody who cannot afford an army of lawyers is calling them out on Twitter and hoping for the best. This is an alarming trend, and highlights how decentralization and, at t…

> This is an alarming trend This has always been the case, ever since BBS operators. Data on other people's machines is data on other people's machines.

This is true. The only difference is that now there's more money (and people's livelihood) on the table. Or even just bigger numbers.

Re: GitHub removes 5 years of One Hour One Life designer's work

#38

From being on the other side of this kind of "big company screws little guy for no reason"... In ~80% of cases, there is more to the story than meets the eye. For example maybe a legal complaint came in, or someone was DoS attacking that repo and it put the whole GitHub service at risk.

so in 20% of the cases it really is a big company just screwing a little guy for no reason?

Or there are more than 2 options I suppose

Re: GitHub removes 5 years of One Hour One Life designer's work

#39

Setting up your own git remote takes minutes. Github is just a pretty interface with bells and whistles. I think more people should go self hosted. It's cheaper, and none of the features are truly needed.

> Github is just a pretty interface with bells and whistles. I think more people should go self hosted. It's cheaper, and none of the features are truly needed.

Maybe none of the Github features are useful to you in how you use it, but I find Github the most productive way to work with a distributed dev team that I've ever found by a large margin. It's an amazing system for productivity of large dev teams and a dream to work with if it fits your use case.

The biggest feature for me is the whole Pull Request flow with integration between filing the original issue, the code changes to fix it with inline code reviews and tracking everything through to a release all with a few clicks. And all of it is in a format you can link to in an email or drop into a chat, even referencing the specific lines of the diff you care about. It's really an amazing system that most of us take for granted.

Different people have different needs. And for a lot of people, git itself is just the (excellent) engine but really they want a whole car.

Post reply on HN