Live data from Hacker News

GitHub removes 5 years of One Hour One Life designer's work

twitter.com

21–30 of 141 posts

Re: GitHub removes 5 years of One Hour One Life designer's work

#21
https://www.softwareheritage.org/

"We collect and preserve software in source code form, because software embodies our technical and scientific knowledge and humanity cannot afford the risk of losing it.

Software is a precious part of our cultural heritage. We curate and make accessible all the software we collect, because only by sharing it we can guarantee its preservation in the very long term. "

Re: GitHub removes 5 years of One Hour One Life designer's work

#22
post #11

Jason Rohrer [1] is the author of Passage [2]. His latest game, "One Hour One Life" [3], is a massively multiplayer online game where your character has only one hour of life. You start off as a baby and are dependent on others for shelter and heat before you're able to be autonomous. Eventually you die of old age but your impact on the world/server persists. I recommend anyone interested to purchase the game [4] or…

[deleted]

Re: GitHub removes 5 years of One Hour One Life designer's work

#24

Seems it’s been a busy week for these reminders not to trust centralized services. I think the the “Fediverse” will become more popular over the next few years.

There are in fact people who are already trying to "federate" code collaboration https://nth.io/notice/7652

Re: GitHub removes 5 years of One Hour One Life designer's work

#25
post #10

We need to hear 2 sides of a story. Github does not just 'delete' files. Author should contact them first and resolve any issues there is. And if github refuse that, than you can cry a river.

I don’t think it’s unreasonable for the author to be provided an explanation when the repo was taken down.

Re: GitHub removes 5 years of One Hour One Life designer's work

#26
post #14

That is terrible and a good reminder that using the "cloud" means that you don't really control your destiny. A quick googling around reveal a couple of options for backing up everything from github (but I'm not sure what you'd do with a backup if you got kicked out like the OP).

It's also a good reminder of why data portability is important. For the git part, you can just git push to another service, even a selfhosted one, and be up and running in no time, and GitHub does keep pages and wikis in git... but all the tickets, that's a problem, and why I don't trust GitHub to be a canonical source for development.

Gitlab has a feature to copy an entire Github repo including issues and issue threads, etc.

You can also enable options for it to act as a mirror or to make GitHub act as the mirror for Gitlab. I'm not sure whether there is a mode to keep the issue threads synced as well without manual intervention. That'd be full data portability.

Re: GitHub removes 5 years of One Hour One Life designer's work

#28
post #11

Jason Rohrer [1] is the author of Passage [2]. His latest game, "One Hour One Life" [3], is a massively multiplayer online game where your character has only one hour of life. You start off as a baby and are dependent on others for shelter and heat before you're able to be autonomous. Eventually you die of old age but your impact on the world/server persists. I recommend anyone interested to purchase the game [4] or…

He's also idiosyncratic in the approach to the rest of his life. When he practiced ‘simple living,’ in his front yard he had (or still has?) a small wild garden with uncut grass, where he of course walked barefoot and his children played naked (iirc). He was taken to the court by neighbors on the issue of grass, and appeared there with a tome of paper citing local laws and research that says cut grass exudes harmful substances. Whereupon he was left to do as he pleases.

The article on Rohrer, which included this anecdote, theorized that his court appearance proved his gardening choices to be a matter of principle and not just negligence, thus changing the perception of him by the neighbors.

Meanwhile, his ‘Passage’ is in MOMA's initial videogame collection, and he's had a solo exhibition at The Davis Museum.

Re: GitHub removes 5 years of One Hour One Life designer's work

#29

FWIW, https://github.com/jasonrohrer/OneLife appears to be there at the moment (20190605T0812+0100) (along with 22 other repositories.)

Yeah, seems to be back up. That link (along with https://github.com/jasonrohrer) was 404ing when this was submitted.

Re: GitHub removes 5 years of One Hour One Life designer's work

#30

From being on the other side of this kind of "big company screws little guy for no reason"... In ~80% of cases, there is more to the story than meets the eye. For example maybe a legal complaint came in, or someone was DoS attacking that repo and it put the whole GitHub service at risk.

I a legal complaint came in I would have figured that you start a far more transparent, cohesive process where the one accused has some information of what's going on and feels some agency.

If there's a DoS, inform the party about it.

Post reply on HN