Live data from Hacker News

Apple Pro Display XDR

techcrunch.com

91–100 of 160 posts

Re: Apple Pro Display XDR

#92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yep, it doesn't matter if reference displays cost $40k+, if most people who thought they'd want to buy an Apple display are comparing against displays that cost $1k ± $500. I think they'll end up selling the new displays to two market segments: (1) people who actually use the high-end features in their work, and (2) people who have deep/corporate pockets and want to show off that they can afford the most expensive te…

> Yep, it doesn't matter if reference displays cost $40k+, if most people who thought they'd want to buy an Apple display are comparing against displays that cost $1k ± $500. This display is for a completely different audience. For the audience you're talking about, Apple sells pretty great LG UltraFine 4K and 5K displays already.

The 4k appears to be in stock, but the 5k is not. There have been rumors for quite some time about Apple replacing them because they have been in short supply.

Re: Apple Pro Display XDR

#94

Complaining only signals that you are not the market they’re targeting. This is for Hollywood media makers, high end studios, etc. This was never to be a mass market item.

Cooperate and developers is a mass market, and I sure am the target segment. But 1k stand is for sure taking a piss on us. You can't just deflect valid criticism...

Re: Apple Pro Display XDR

#95
post #83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

By up-market, they're pushing themselves out of my market. $999 for a stand? No thanks, I can think of plenty of better things to spend $999 on.

You probably weren't their target market then. Most likely it will be companies buying this for their employees, not consumers for themselves. Whether releasing this without an upgraded consumer/prosumer level display was a good idea is another question.

> Most likely it will be companies buying this for their employees, not consumers for themselves.

I understand the whole "money is no object for real professionals" line of thinking, but:

a) it's unlikely that the $1000 stand improves productivity in any appreciable way over a regular stand and

b) if you had 10 employees and you found a way to significantly cut down on that $1000 stand price (say, with that $200 VESA mount, what a steal in comparison!), you could pay for an extra Mac Pro with the savings

I think Apple has managed to price something so poorly that even "I'm such a professional I don't care what it costs" professionals have to do a double take.

Re: Apple Pro Display XDR

#96

Not hearing anyone mention the precision counter-balancing arm (there's an animation of it on the website). I've never seen a monitor stand arm that isn't pure trash. Not that I would pay $1000 for the stand but it looks to be well-engineered and I really wish I could have one.

That reminded me of the arm on the iMac g4, I hope it’s better than that.

Re: Apple Pro Display XDR

#97
post #5

I'm hearing that the LG displays were running out of stock, possibly in anticipation of a new Apple display. Sure enough...wait a minute, FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS?! Oh, I understand it's a reference-quality, blah, blah, blah, but I just need something to replace an aging Cinema display that was originally $1000. The fucking stand for the new display costs that much (note the audience response when that price popped on t…

Eizos are outstanding. You can find pretty good deals on used ones with good color space coverage.

True. FlexScan are sometimes not too expensive. With a discount, a 2k one can match Dell UltraSharp in pricing.

They also have those amazing 1:1 1920x1920 that are widely used in air traffic control.

Re: Apple Pro Display XDR

#98
post #58
post #5

I'm hearing that the LG displays were running out of stock, possibly in anticipation of a new Apple display. Sure enough...wait a minute, FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS?! Oh, I understand it's a reference-quality, blah, blah, blah, but I just need something to replace an aging Cinema display that was originally $1000. The fucking stand for the new display costs that much (note the audience response when that price popped on t…

Just to be sure, you get that this display isn't targeted at developers? :)

There's actually a little bit at the end of the store page that mentions how developers can put it into portrait mode to see more code.

The thought of some dev buying this thing just to stare at xcode all day is kinda hilarious.

Re: Apple Pro Display XDR

#99
post #58
post #5

I'm hearing that the LG displays were running out of stock, possibly in anticipation of a new Apple display. Sure enough...wait a minute, FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS?! Oh, I understand it's a reference-quality, blah, blah, blah, but I just need something to replace an aging Cinema display that was originally $1000. The fucking stand for the new display costs that much (note the audience response when that price popped on t…

Just to be sure, you get that this display isn't targeted at developers? :)

I do get it, but my question remains: what does Apple suggest that I, a developer/prosumer, buy? Something without an Apple logo on it?

Re: Apple Pro Display XDR

#100
Apple produced the best $6,000 display you can buy. When the majority of pro users wanted the best $1,500 display you can make. We want an iMac without all the computer part. And they delivered a real 'pro' display.

Maybe this is a big middle finger up to all those asking for Apple's pro line up to be more 'pro'.

Post reply on HN