Live data from Hacker News

During Cold War, CIA Plucked Soviet Submarine from Ocean Floor Using Giant Claw

smithsonianmag.com

41–50 of 102 posts

Re: During Cold War, CIA Plucked Soviet Submarine from Ocean Floor Using Giant Claw

#41
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No? Why do you think that? Ask a Vietnam War veteran, or a Korean War veteran, if they fought any enemy soldiers at any point. War was not declared in those cases either. And these are obviously not soldiers in the first place - they're sailors.

> War was not declared in those cases either. Tell that to the dead.

You're stealing his point. ;-)

Re: During Cold War, CIA Plucked Soviet Submarine from Ocean Floor Using Giant Claw

#42
post #7

two separate Soviet ships (likely loaded with intelligence operatives) closely monitored the supposed mining vessel as it worked to retrieve the submarine. It sounds like they knew exactly what was going on. Tangent: My grandfather was part of a U.S. Navy operation during WWII that was responsible for verifying enemy submarine sinkings ... basically, sending someone down to pick up an artifact that would prove the su…

> It sounds like they knew exactly what was going on.

Perhaps they didn't have the means to recover it themselves, nor the desire (it would mean admitting to the accident and deaths of the soldiers)

Re: During Cold War, CIA Plucked Soviet Submarine from Ocean Floor Using Giant Claw

#43
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The phrase "Cold War" isn't without meaning. They were generally deemed to be the enemy by Americans at that time, enough so that Americans were often surprised to learn that Russia and the US were on the same side during WW2. This is how search auto completed my query on the matter: were russia and us allies in ww2 That suggests people are still surprised to learn that and routinely search that question. Americans t…

Allies is a bit much, they had a common enemy. Once the enemy was destroyed, no longer allies. Compare that to US/UK aka true allies.

Gosh, thank you for proving my point. But, in point of fact, the two sides that fought in WW2 were called the Axis and the Allies. Care to take a wild guess which side included both the US and the Soviet Union?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allies_of_World_War_II

Re: During Cold War, CIA Plucked Soviet Submarine from Ocean Floor Using Giant Claw

#44
post #32

I think this was partly spoofed in a Charles Stross book - https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/14150.The_Jennifer_Morgu...

Yes, he mentioned this in his "crib sheets" - http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2013/06/crib-she... it is an interesting read, but contains spoilers for his The Jennifer Morgue novel.

Re: During Cold War, CIA Plucked Soviet Submarine from Ocean Floor Using Giant Claw

#45
This is one of my favourite stories, this documentary is pretty good: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2042455/

This book goes into a lot more detail: https://www.amazon.com/Project-Azorian-CIA-Raising-K-129/dp/...

The engineering behind the gimble required to hold the huge length of pipe required to reach the sub is quite something.

Re: During Cold War, CIA Plucked Soviet Submarine from Ocean Floor Using Giant Claw

#46
post #8

Possibly the coolest and most spooky Cold War artifact: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aJAJUJ41PBI It's the video on board the Glomar Explorer of a burial at sea ceremony of Soviet sailors found in the half of the submarine they managed to bring to the surface. Supposedly this was Top Secret until a copy was given to Yeltsin in 1991 or so.

Buried in a shipping crate.

Re: During Cold War, CIA Plucked Soviet Submarine from Ocean Floor Using Giant Claw

#47
post #25
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't find it very spooky. Moving though, considering it's a solemn burial of the bodies of enemy soldiers. And if really it was top-secret, it's not even propaganda. Better times than ours. And how cool is the Soviet anthem?

I’d say the Soviet anthem is one of the best there is. They missed it so much it was brought back as the Russian national anthem after Yeltsin. Red Army Chorus has some good tracks like it. Very catchy and “patriotic” if you are in line to fight western imperialism.

Their rendition of Bella Ciao is my favorite. (Read the lyric’s translation if you haven’t already).

Re: During Cold War, CIA Plucked Soviet Submarine from Ocean Floor Using Giant Claw

#48
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No? Why do you think that? Ask a Vietnam War veteran, or a Korean War veteran, if they fought any enemy soldiers at any point. War was not declared in those cases either. And these are obviously not soldiers in the first place - they're sailors.

> War was not declared in those cases either. Tell that to the dead.

...that was the point...

Re: During Cold War, CIA Plucked Soviet Submarine from Ocean Floor Using Giant Claw

#49
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The phrase "Cold War" isn't without meaning. They were generally deemed to be the enemy by Americans at that time, enough so that Americans were often surprised to learn that Russia and the US were on the same side during WW2. This is how search auto completed my query on the matter: were russia and us allies in ww2 That suggests people are still surprised to learn that and routinely search that question. Americans t…

Allies is a bit much, they had a common enemy. Once the enemy was destroyed, no longer allies. Compare that to US/UK aka true allies.

Really? There were joint operations, they received US lend-lease like Britain, there were regular Arctic convoys to Murmansk and Archangel. Not just food and supply aid, Britain sent well over 1,000 Spitfires and 3,000 Hurricanes, the US over 6,000 P39s and P40s. No end of tanks and other vehicles too, including over 75,000 jeeps.

An alliance in every sense - it just wasn't a permanent alliance. Allied even though few liked Stalin's regime. Yalta conference - to plan the peace - was the point of change that slid toward cold war.

Edit: accurate numbers. :)

Post reply on HN