Live data from Hacker News

We got banned from PayPal after 12 years of business

blog.niteo.co

191–200 of 536 posts

Re: We got banned from PayPal after 12 years of business

#191

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There are lots of horror stories about Paypal, but there is an obvious problem, nobody is going out of their way to write a blog post about how Paypal always worked for them. You can find pretty much the same horror stories about any Bank or credit card company.

Can you point me towards examples of a bank (not the government - a bank) confiscating a company’s account balance?

Quadriga

Re: We got banned from PayPal after 12 years of business

#192

For me as a customer, having PayPal as payment option increases the propability of purchase. Especially with one-time purchases from small vendors. Reasons: No risk of credit card info misuse (by vendor), I only need username and password and I get certainly at least some kind of receipt for accounting.

I’m always surprised as to why people are concerned about card details misuse. You are not responsible for card-not-present fraud (without 3D Secure). You can dispute any fraudulent charge with your bank, and I’d bet good money the bank has actually better customer service in that regard compared to PayPal.

It's just a pain when it happens and you have to notice and catch it to begin with. Last time I had my debit card skimmed I had a lot of subscriptions lapse and fail to charge because the old card had been cancelled but I hadn't gotten the new card yet to switch to.

I got all the money they'd charged back but it was still a stressful time because I didn't have any other card at the time.

Re: We got banned from PayPal after 12 years of business

#193
post #98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> and some don't have a credit card If your customers are from Europe, it's not some , but most customers that don't have a credit card. Credit cards are uncommon here (probably hard to imagine if you are from USA). Online payments are a fragmented mess in Europe. Most countries have their own preferred online payment method (like iDEAL or bancontact), Paypal is basically the only reliable method that works everywher…

> If your customers are from Europe This is not a great approximation. In the UK you can assume almost every person has a payment card that works on the internet (debit and/or credit). In Poland on the other hand, the number of systems gets silly ( https://m.lot.com/us/en/payment-methods-on-lotcom )

Same with the Baltic states - almost everyone here has a CC and there are no popular local payment systems AFAIK.

Re: We got banned from PayPal after 12 years of business

#196
post #164

Not surprised at all. We got banned too without any warning a few years ago. I wrote about my story here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11944701 Lots of people would simply think "It won't happen to me" and move on. But this is just another example that if it can happen to people using Paypal for years, it can happen to you too. It's better to offer other payment channels to customers so you can diversify. And…

You got banned for running a file sharing site, I’m afraid. PayPal’s terms require all file sharing sites to seek explicit approval before using the service, no exceptions.

[deleted]

Re: We got banned from PayPal after 12 years of business

#197
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Non-US credit or debit card owners are not in that good position wrt. disputes and getting their money back. Most of them charge for disabling the card and sending a new one. Dispute last for months, and are not automatically protecting the customer.

This is the first time I hear about this for UK. The chargeback rules are set by the network , i.e. MasterCard, Visa (sure Amex as well but they are both issuer , acquirer and network so that’s perhaps an unfair example). Is there a different rule set for MC USA vs MC rest of the world? I worked for a fraud detection company in the UK that existed precisely because chargebacks work so well, here. So this is definitel…

Laws in each country are different. In the US that is not just a network rule it is a law. In many other countries they are just rules that can change at any time. Check with your local country's laws as each are different. I would expect that the network's rules are in large part the intersection of the laws in every country they operate in - one set of rules is easier to track than trying to figure out which countries laws might be in effect (with disastrous consequences if they get it wrong).

Don't get me wrong, sometimes the networks rules are stronger than the laws for other reasons. Last I checked in the US the customer was legally out $50 in case of fraud, but all networks reduced it to zero figuring if they were already out potentially a large sum of money they may as well eat the last $50 too for goodwill reasons.

Re: We got banned from PayPal after 12 years of business

#199
post #147
post #134

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Frozen, as long as they don't take the money either.

But with PayPal, that’s not the case. Your “money” in your account at PayPal is just a number in a table. The actual money, however, is in PayPal’s bank account where it is earning PayPal interest and investment opportunities.

To be fair, anything other than M0 (physical cash) is just a number in a table. Banking regulations that ensure ease of access are the only reason other "numbers in tables" are considered part of the money supply.

Re: We got banned from PayPal after 12 years of business

#200
post #134

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Right, if someone says alright, put your money in this box. But then they take the box and close it and say no, you can't open it, Sorry. What does that sound more like? Frozen, or stolen?

Frozen, as long as they don't take the money either.

PayPal has no obligation to keep your money in a secure trust, so essentially your balance is just a recorded number. The actual money is being invested. They keep a small pool of money in reserve and in easily liquifiable investments to cover withdrawals of course.
Post reply on HN