Live data from Hacker News

You Are Old, Father William

firstthings.com

51–54 of 54 posts

Re: You Are Old, Father William

#51
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If they've been writing for decades they aren't 'hot new writers' over 70.

The emphasis is not on the "new" but on the "hot new". You can hone your skills for decades, and even publish, but only become "hot" (based on some nicely selling or award winning work) later in life. You still deserve to be in a list.

I think this is pedantic, but whatever. If you include previously popular authors then your article is not look at these new authors who are seventy, its look how old these authors are.

Or at least, that would be my takeaway if number one on the list were Steven King. It’s not interesting that he is still a good author. It is noteworthy that he is older than I expect. He is ~72 btw.

Re: You Are Old, Father William

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, the whole article reads like a hasty generalisation to me, but in an effort to avoid being trite . . . The author's generalisation is that society (i.e. everyone) doesn't respect authors over 70 and characters over 70 (and by extension, people over 70). Yet, he goes on to give examples of celebrated authors over 70 and celebrated stories where the main characters are over 70, leaving his argument where, exactly…

> The author's generalisation is that society (i.e. everyone) doesn't respect authors over 70 Nowhere does the author say that. Your whole comment is a strawman.

If you say so . . . clearly, we took different meanings away from it.

Re: You Are Old, Father William

#53

> Where are the lists of “Hot New Writers Over 70”? Because most people who want to write will have done so before 70, and a large chunk of them just want to watch TV (or rather, have nothing better to do in their minds, which is sad). > Why do so few of the expensive, risible fashion ads in the New York Times Magazine and its equivalent at the Wall Street Journal feature oldsters? I don’t think this is true for many…

Those of us over, say, 50 have seen hot new writers come and go.

As for fashion ads, we may be creatures of habit, not to say biased against the "risible" ads.

Post reply on HN