Live data from Hacker News

Americans Are Delaying Health Care Until Tax Refunds Arrive

bloomberg.com

51–60 of 256 posts

Re: Americans Are Delaying Health Care Until Tax Refunds Arrive

#51
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And why not? I don't see any fundamental reason why your local taxes should be deductible for federal tax purposes.

Because you don't actually have that money. Suppose that the state and the federal government each had a 55% tax rate. Then you would make $1 and owe $1.10. You would owe more in taxes than you make, so you would quit your job. Of course, there is a simple way for the states to fix this -- move the taxes to the business side. Instead of having state income tax, have payroll tax paid by the employer. Then the employer…

If both the state and federal governments each had a 55% tax rate, you'd be justified in questioning the rates and voting for a different government! Just as I expect people would complain if there was just a single tax authority, but it set a rate of 110%.

Assume for now that we accept the federal government is entitled to raise money for its programs by taxing people's incomes (yes, some people might disagree, but that's a different discussion). Why should a state be allowed to reduce the federal government's take, and therefore shift the burden of paying for federal services to other states, by choosing to increase its own local tax?

Re: Americans Are Delaying Health Care Until Tax Refunds Arrive

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Anyone living in a state with high income and/or property taxes will likely pay more this year given the $10k cap on deductions for state and local taxes which was previously unlimited before the 2018 tax year...

“Anyone?” That isn’t accurate because you’re ignoring the doubling of the standard deduction. Higher income people who itemize would be the only ones affected. And with the reduced tax rates offset some of that lack of SALT deductibility. That SALT change only really affected less than 7% of taxpayers (10.9 million filers out of 153 million who filed returns.) https://www.cbsnews.com/news/salt-tax-deduction-on-2018-t…

I'm talking specifically about high tax states like CA, NY, NJ. If you isolate taxpayers in those states the change affects a lot more than 7% of residents of those states.

This change was about Trump's desire to hurt residents of blue, high tax coastal states. To minimize this as something that only affects the .1% is rationalizing his terrible tax policy.

Re: Americans Are Delaying Health Care Until Tax Refunds Arrive

#53

This has been true forever. Everyone is broke after Christmas and refunds turn the lights back on for retail starting in the end of March.

Yep... Even car sales increase because people have money for the down-payment.

A large population of Americans do not have much savings. Could be bad money management, low paying jobs, bad luck (health issues) etc.

Re: Americans Are Delaying Health Care Until Tax Refunds Arrive

#54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not a big fan of those either, but at least give access to invest the funds in a savings account or the market. I’d rather we teach some basic finance and civic responsibility in school.

Gee, you mean "civic responsibility" like not rewarding tax avoidance and tax cheats like the orange buffoon and his ilk? Yeah, we're all in favor. These tax changes have raped the lower and middle classes. Trying to be disingenuous about "civic responsibility" and "basic finance" is pretty shitty.

When you take the standard deduction on your return you are engaging in tax avoidance. When you invent a 3rd child that never existed you are engaging in tax evasion.

Re: Americans Are Delaying Health Care Until Tax Refunds Arrive

#55
post #53

This has been true forever. Everyone is broke after Christmas and refunds turn the lights back on for retail starting in the end of March.

Yep... Even car sales increase because people have money for the down-payment. A large population of Americans do not have much savings. Could be bad money management, low paying jobs, bad luck (health issues) etc.

Phht, bad money management. When loan sharks are peddling 450% payday loans people are being taken advantage of by corporations. The government needs to practice better money management, not us private citizens. Close tax loopholes.

Re: Americans Are Delaying Health Care Until Tax Refunds Arrive

#56
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because you don't actually have that money. Suppose that the state and the federal government each had a 55% tax rate. Then you would make $1 and owe $1.10. You would owe more in taxes than you make, so you would quit your job. Of course, there is a simple way for the states to fix this -- move the taxes to the business side. Instead of having state income tax, have payroll tax paid by the employer. Then the employer…

If both the state and federal governments each had a 55% tax rate, you'd be justified in questioning the rates and voting for a different government! Just as I expect people would complain if there was just a single tax authority, but it set a rate of 110%. Assume for now that we accept the federal government is entitled to raise money for its programs by taxing people's incomes (yes, some people might disagree, but…

> Why should a state be allowed to reduce the federal government's take

Because a state can often do a more effective job of using the money than the federal government.

> and therefore shift the burden of paying for federal services to other states

If you look at the states with high enough income taxes for this to all be relevant, they tend to be "donor" states that pay a lot more to the federal government than they get back.

It might be a good idea to even that all out, but eliminating the local and state tax deduction doesn't help.

Re: Americans Are Delaying Health Care Until Tax Refunds Arrive

#57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not a big fan of those either, but at least give access to invest the funds in a savings account or the market. I’d rather we teach some basic finance and civic responsibility in school.

Gee, you mean "civic responsibility" like not rewarding tax avoidance and tax cheats like the orange buffoon and his ilk? Yeah, we're all in favor. These tax changes have raped the lower and middle classes. Trying to be disingenuous about "civic responsibility" and "basic finance" is pretty shitty.

[flagged]

Re: Americans Are Delaying Health Care Until Tax Refunds Arrive

#58
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How is it the only option? If withholding is less, what’s stopping people from saving the reduction? A refund is essentially an interest free loan repayment from the government. Refunds should ideally be zero.

> How is it the only option? It’s not but it’s a lot easier for many people if they don’t realize they have the money. > If withholding is less, what’s stopping people from saving the reduction? Reality. It’s no different then walking around town with a couples $20 bills vs walking around with your pockets empty. Sure you could just not spend any of it but it’s a hell of a lot easier if you don’t even have the option…

>Not having cash on hand and being forced to make due with less is surprisingly effective.

This is exactly what the Democrats want and push with their agenda. They would rather raise taxes and make every one poor in order to feed into a larger government. Government programs that sound good, but don't actually work out on paper. By keeping the masses poor it's easier to sell them on "social programs" that would assist the poor but never really do.

Re: Americans Are Delaying Health Care Until Tax Refunds Arrive

#59
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How is it the only option? If withholding is less, what’s stopping people from saving the reduction? A refund is essentially an interest free loan repayment from the government. Refunds should ideally be zero.

> How is it the only option? It’s not but it’s a lot easier for many people if they don’t realize they have the money. > If withholding is less, what’s stopping people from saving the reduction? Reality. It’s no different then walking around town with a couples $20 bills vs walking around with your pockets empty. Sure you could just not spend any of it but it’s a hell of a lot easier if you don’t even have the option…

It's an extremely short term solution to make everyone feel happy and warm inside without any long term results. The lack of impulse control won't sudden vanish once the refund arrives, and they will be back in that situation again a few short months after.

Re: Americans Are Delaying Health Care Until Tax Refunds Arrive

#60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Whether you get a huge tax refund or not is about how much you chose to overpay on withholdings not how much you were taxed.

And typically lower-paid people have higher deductions on their taxes (versus withholdings) and usually get the larger refunds. So much so that they basically depend on it. That's why everyone is in such shock right now. Meanwhile, I've never been one to get a large refund at tax time. And I've always planned for my big annual expenses upfront (sometimes using an automatic bank account transfer to "incrementally save…

You choose how much is withheld. There is no versus. But I'm afraid the vast majority do not realize this and accept the default.
Post reply on HN