One of the requirement listed to apply via the author's company is native fluency in English. How do they evaluate that? If it's some test, I am not aware of any test which measures this. If it depends on where you are born? Is that kind of stratification legal?
There are plenty of tests that achieve this. My university got a lot of international candidates whose first language wasn't English and who hadn't been educated in English up until that point. As a result, they established a process to assess your fluency so they could accommodate you with additional training on English to ensure you'd be successful. https://uwaterloo.ca/future-students/admissions/english-lang... li…
Why I turned down my Y Combinator interview
21–30 of 109 posts
Re: Why I turned down my Y Combinator interview
#22Re: Why I turned down my Y Combinator interview
#23Re: Why I turned down my Y Combinator interview
#24Because people have always liked to pursue things that interest them regardless of the odds.
(cue Han Solo's "Don't tell me the odds!")
Why do aspiring writers work on novels with long odds of it ever being a bestseller on NYTimes -- or even being published by a reputable publisher for that matter? Because, writing is what that person wants to do. Telling them it's a "waste of time" isn't going to change their mind if writing is what makes them happy.
Why does the high-school basketball player keep working on his jump shot even though the odds of NCAA players getting picked in one of the 60 slots of the NBA draft is ~1%? It's because playing basketball is what interests him.
Same for aspiring actors pursuing Hollywood fame that probably won't happen, researchers toiling away on scientific breakthoughs that may never materialize, startup founders building elusive unicorns, etc.
Yes, the similar DHH essays promoting "bootstrapping" and "slow growth" are always highly upvoted on HN because VCs are widely perceived as detrimental. However, both your and DHH's philosophy leaves out a crucial detail: What is the entrepreneur interested in working on?
If the interests happens to be a business that can be bootstrapped, then great. Pursue that option. However, if it's a business that requires millions to build out infrastructure (e.g. many consumer-facing websites), somebody with deep pockets (e.g. VCs) is the typical financing option since banks won't provide loans.
Re: Why I turned down my Y Combinator interview
#25The motivation seems to have changed, and its showing...
Re: Why I turned down my Y Combinator interview
#26Good luck bootstrapping biotech or robotics company! Of course it’s better to be sole owner, but it does not work when building product takes years.
Are VCs investing in companies that are years from "traction"?
Re: Why I turned down my Y Combinator interview
#27Re: Why I turned down my Y Combinator interview
#28Earlier quoted context omitted.
Requiring "native fluency" could be interpreted as requiring the candidate to be a native English speaker, which would obviously be discriminatory. That's probably not the intent, but it's a bad choice of wording. If they mean "as fluent in English as a native speaker", then that's arguably much too high a standard.
One wonders about the "fluency" of whoever wrote that requirement...
Re: Why I turned down my Y Combinator interview
#29I was expecting a shitty article after a clickbaity title, but was positively surprised. Not new information, but well argued!
I pocketed most this money (after taxes) ... had I raised money I'd be broke right now...
Re: Why I turned down my Y Combinator interview
#30I think the biggest difference between today and 20 years ago when I first go into Silicon Valley is that most founders are generally already planning their exit. There are a lot of startups whose mentality is "get big quick enough so that we can get bought out by Google/Facebook/Amazon/etc". And unfortunately this is a legitimate play because it leads to quick payouts so it motivates founders and VCs alike. It's a f…
But how do you know how much time will it take to reach that $50 million? If it was a VC backed company sure it might have taken couple of years ie short term. But for a bootstrap company focusing on a smaller pie or niche markets this could take years to happen.