Live data from Hacker News

1500 Private Jets Fly to Davos for Climate Talks

theguardian.com

121–130 of 168 posts

Re: 1500 Private Jets Fly to Davos for Climate Talks

#121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>No one wants to give up their own personal comfort or lifestyle for the sake of "the planet." Seriously? Who are you to say that of others?! I'm French (Parisian, actually) and I keep demonstrating with yellow vests to try and force political action so we can save the biosphere. I've been giving up on my personal comfort for years to reduce my environment footprint and help others do the same: I don't go skiing anym…

Curious as to why you quit Skiing, why do you think that’s contributing to climate change? To me it seems like a really low emission activity, particaurly ski touring ?

I come from an area with lots of skiing.

Snow cannons, piste bashers, lift maintenance. Skiing is very polluting. Besides, you have to (usually) drive quite a bit to get to the mountain.

It's also extremely expensive.

Re: 1500 Private Jets Fly to Davos for Climate Talks

#122

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The end result of this is that driving a lot and excessive heating and cooling of spaces are more of an expensive luxury. The problem is people see owning and driving a personal vehicle as something like a right instead of the extravagant over-the-top luxury it really is. And once someone gets used to something, they get really angry when something threatens to take it away, pretty much no matter what it is. That's o…

Owning an economy car is not “extravagant over-the-top” in the least. Another problem is hardliners taking such extreme positions against reasonable everyday people.

It is though, globally speaking. It's something that consumes a massive amount of energy and pollutes a lot and should be priced that way.

Re: 1500 Private Jets Fly to Davos for Climate Talks

#123
post #47

Unpopular Opinion: There is no viable solution to climate change through policy or political action. No one wants to give up their own personal comfort or lifestyle for the sake of "the planet." Even people I know who are self-described ardent environmentalists still fly in planes frequently to all manner of touristy destinations so they can keep "collecting experiences." Shit, look at Paris. They champion this clima…

I also very much dislike the argument that it's the "corporations". The "corporations" are polluting this much because people buy and demand cheap consumer goods. These things need to be appropriately priced. Non-seasonal fruits, cars, consumer electronics, clothes shipped across half the world, air travel. Aside from cars, things that people can live without. They should be priced as a luxury. (Carbon tax maybe?)

But if you began pricing these things appropriately, you'd probably see a very bad reaction. Which is why you have a good point.

Re: 1500 Private Jets Fly to Davos for Climate Talks

#124
post #18

Also: "Just 90 companies caused two-thirds of man-made global warming emissions" https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2013/nov/20/90-compa... Individual behavior obviously matters but it's a drop in the bucket compared to corporate polluters.

Aren't the customers of those companies also culpable?

Absolutely. The reality is, if people actually cared, they could do a lot by not consuming as much. But they do not and we have to act appropriately.

Re: 1500 Private Jets Fly to Davos for Climate Talks

#125

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That isn't my intention at all. English is not my first language so it might not help but please bear with me. I intentionally said "I really want to scream" and not "Let me say" because I certainly do not want to be hostile. I shared the point of view of the person I responded to, so no, I really did not express hostility but an invitation to understand that some people actually are giving up "their own personal com…

There's a saying that comes to mind when I read this post.. You judge yourself based on intent. You judge others based on action.

I'd say we can judge him or her based on both intent and action, they seem in line with each other.

Re: 1500 Private Jets Fly to Davos for Climate Talks

#126

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> No one I understand your anger here, but I'm 99% sure that the person you're replying to didn't mean that literally. 'No one' is often used to mean 'almost no one'. I'm sure you'll agree that your behaviour is well into 1% territory, as an overall percentage of people. You are to be applauded of course.

>I'm sure you'll agree that your behaviour is well into 1% territory, as an overall percentage of people. I was in the 99% territory before being in the 1%, then. And your comment could have convinced me not to change and give up. That's what I'm trying to say in my bad English, and with vivid emotions, so my apologies if I'm rude or not clear enough.

> I was in the 99% territory before being in the 1%, then. And your comment could have convinced me not to change and give up.

> Seriously? Who are you to say that of others?!

> [...]

> I'm really tired and comments like yours are really adding insult to the injury.

> I really want to scream a big F*CK you to your face...

No zealot like a convert.

Re: 1500 Private Jets Fly to Davos for Climate Talks

#128
post #47

Unpopular Opinion: There is no viable solution to climate change through policy or political action. No one wants to give up their own personal comfort or lifestyle for the sake of "the planet." Even people I know who are self-described ardent environmentalists still fly in planes frequently to all manner of touristy destinations so they can keep "collecting experiences." Shit, look at Paris. They champion this clima…

>No one wants to give up their own personal comfort or lifestyle for the sake of "the planet." Seriously? Who are you to say that of others?! I'm French (Parisian, actually) and I keep demonstrating with yellow vests to try and force political action so we can save the biosphere. I've been giving up on my personal comfort for years to reduce my environment footprint and help others do the same: I don't go skiing anym…

[deleted]

Re: 1500 Private Jets Fly to Davos for Climate Talks

#129

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Curious as to why you quit Skiing, why do you think that’s contributing to climate change? To me it seems like a really low emission activity, particaurly ski touring ?

I come from an area with lots of skiing. Snow cannons, piste bashers, lift maintenance. Skiing is very polluting. Besides, you have to (usually) drive quite a bit to get to the mountain. It's also extremely expensive.

Ah I see, I live in an area where man made snow does is not a thing I didn’t consider that stuff, cheers.

Re: 1500 Private Jets Fly to Davos for Climate Talks

#130
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can’t think of a single case in human history where indiduals acting alone made a real difference in widespread issues like climate change. So suggesting it starts with individual steps seems wildly inaccurate.

Someone has to go first. If not you, then who? Everything starts with someone going first. And your actions do have an effect: by providing an example to others, making it more likely they too will participate; and economic, by reducing the income generated from the activity.

1/1,000,000,000 has no meaningful impact on any of those.

Silent Spring was written by a Rachel Carson and had real impact. However, her personal lifestyle was irrelevant.

PS: As to someone going first, that is not an issue when say a state adds a sales tax. In such cases the first person to pay the tax is a sign that it's already in place.

Post reply on HN