Live data from Hacker News

China used Huawei to hack network, says report

theaustralian.com.au

51–60 of 127 posts

Re: China used Huawei to hack network, says report

#51
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's popular to hate the US government and US tech companies, but the US government and US tech companies are far more ethical than the Chinese. It's ridiculous to assert otherwise.

Are they though? Did the Chinese government spend the last century toppling democratically elected governments and subjecting the populations to the horrors that followed purely for economic gain? I guess not.

They subjected their own population to horrors, but at least it wasn't for economic gain.

Re: China used Huawei to hack network, says report

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are they though? Did the Chinese government spend the last century toppling democratically elected governments and subjecting the populations to the horrors that followed purely for economic gain? I guess not.

Hello whataboutism!

Calling other peoples argument whataboutism is the get out of jail free card for double standards.

Re: China used Huawei to hack network, says report

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Depends who is defining what is ethical of course. The fact that ethics is cultural will mean that each side will probably think they are the most ethical. To disprove that claim: try to come up with an ethical framework which makes no mention of a higher power as justification, and tell us why it is better than all others. Most land on some variant of utilitarianism and then disagree what the objective function shou…

We can dance around the idea of ethics or we can actually look at historical actions taken by both. Putting the Chinese & US government interventionism on the same plain for objective ethics judgements is a joke (regardless of whos cultural ethical standards you use).

Serious question, are you just hand waving the Cultural Revolution away or have you never heard of it?

Maybe it's like a C and a program stack, they just don't teach it in college anymore, because it's not important and you don't need to know about it.

Re: China used Huawei to hack network, says report

#54
post #4

> Don't think about this in terms of just governments tracking you. Consider if you have any work emails containing company secrets in them. Consider if you have 2FA apps installed that you would use to unlock or change your work password. And since it was almost certainly the Chinese Intel/Military that helps Huawei and other companies, you can be sure that whatever information Huawei gets access to doesn't need to…

2FA "apps" which are used on the same device are not really 2FA. Use a physical device instead of that.

Re: China used Huawei to hack network, says report

#55
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Already forgot PRISM ? No wonder they do stuff like this when the public attention span is so small.

The Snowden revelations caused tech companies to implement strong encryption for consumer facing communications. Apple, Google, and Facebook all offer encryption protocols that now piss off the US government and caused friction between the private and public sectors. People saying "but PRISM" have missed the past five years of US politics. Even Obama was getting mad at US tech.

Do you have any proof despite statements that the entire internal surveillance programs of the NSA was dismantled or we should just believe because the US government would never lie to us?

Re: China used Huawei to hack network, says report

#56
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Already forgot PRISM ? No wonder they do stuff like this when the public attention span is so small.

The Snowden revelations caused tech companies to implement strong encryption for consumer facing communications. Apple, Google, and Facebook all offer encryption protocols that now piss off the US government and caused friction between the private and public sectors. People saying "but PRISM" have missed the past five years of US politics. Even Obama was getting mad at US tech.

Yes and no. Google has all but abandoned the idea of end to end encryption for its users.

Re: China used Huawei to hack network, says report

#57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

China felt generous to build an entire new building for African Union. About $200 Million cost, and it came complete with bugs (as in spy ones) and backdoor-ed network that sent the data to China every night. NSA would have done the same, that's what countries do. There I said it. But the story, for me, is more about Huawei doing whatever their owner wants. Stay away from them

NSA would've bugged the building without investing anything in that country. Not quite the same. The original exploiters of Africa are mad that China is investing and building infrastructure on that continent, which will raise historically low prices.

Which prices will it raise? I'd expect the investment to lower prices for various raw materials China wants (because why would they invest to pay more in the end?) and consequently it would also lower prices for goods manufactured in China from those materials.

Re: China used Huawei to hack network, says report

#58
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Already forgot PRISM ? No wonder they do stuff like this when the public attention span is so small.

The Snowden revelations caused tech companies to implement strong encryption for consumer facing communications. Apple, Google, and Facebook all offer encryption protocols that now piss off the US government and caused friction between the private and public sectors. People saying "but PRISM" have missed the past five years of US politics. Even Obama was getting mad at US tech.

Technically, while I do think that those companies have moved to stronger encryption over the past few years (which is a general trend I think) for consumer facing stuff, at least one of the changes that came out of PRISM was that Google started encrypting all of their communications in and out of their data centers (and in between) because PRISM was tapping at the datacenter level if I recall (something related to the note with the smiley face).

Re: China used Huawei to hack network, says report

#59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you have proof that any of the news about China (from tons of different sources, including other countries that are not America) is propaganda or not accurate? You're implying a global conspiracy is afoot to besmirch the good Chinese name when everyone has known for a while that they're generally bad actors behind the scenes when it comes to spying and stealing of secrets/IP/tech.

IP theft aside, anti-Chinese propoganda goes back 200 years in the US and UK. Is this question about proof a joke?

Can I have some of the verifiable evidence of your anti-Chinese propaganda from the last 10 years? You seem adamant that there's an abundance of it across the globe and that it's so pervasive over the past 200 years. I'd love to see just some of the recent bits.

Re: China used Huawei to hack network, says report

#60
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They could disclose their warrants after cases have closed and there are no loose ends.

That'll never happen. Even if the case is closed and there are no loose ends for that particular case, it would still reveal the collection methods used, potentially impacting other foreign intel and FISA related cases.

Maybe. They could probably redact the 'how' details. And even if not I wonder how many of their methods are truly secret.

EDIT: typo

Post reply on HN