Live data from Hacker News

Six women computer scientists respond to why women don’t pursue computer science

seattletimes.com

51–60 of 102 posts

Re: Six women computer scientists respond to why women don’t pursue computer science

#51
Instead of interviewing women who decided on computer science it would be better to interview women who were thinking of or who switched from CS. I am willing to venture that sexism, gender bias, and unfair policies aren't reasons women would cite.

In fact in my personal experience talking with women while I was in college who started off in CS or others that took intro CS courses typically the responses were:

  "Didn't click for me"
  "Didn't like all the math requirements"
  "Found it boring and teadious"
  "Isolated, rather work with people"
Those reasons are much simpler and frankly make more sense then a grand sexist and biased plot by men to oppose and opress women from getting into CS.

Re: Six women computer scientists respond to why women don’t pursue computer science

#52
For example, from 2007 to 2017, the number of males taking the AP computer science test went up by a factor of 7,

Are AP CS exams relevant now? I took both in the early 90s, then got to college only to find out that nobody accepted AP credit in CS. Every school said "we use C, and the AP exam uses Pascal".

Curious if anyone younger has a different experience.

Re: Six women computer scientists respond to why women don’t pursue computer science

#53
post #19
post #14

I read through the responses. It appears all disagree with Stuart Reges. The first few responses disagree, a couple toward the end go farther and discuss the harm that occurs when someone expresses this opinion. One essay does insinuate that perhaps he should lose his leadership position for expressing this opinion. I read all these responses with interest. The only strong opinion I hold is that we should accurately…

It is frustrating how often misrepresentation occurs in this particular topic. So many words are wasted misrepresenting the record and then setting it straight again. A similar thing happened w/ the Google Memo when so many prominent media outlets (as well as commenters all over the Internet, including here at HN) attacked it for saying things it never said before the accusation was changed to "well, it was based on…

Why is this (and children) being down-voted? These seem like perfectly rationale comments on the topic.

Re: Six women computer scientists respond to why women don’t pursue computer science

#54
So, all these women present anecdotal evidence.

If you are interested in an opposite opinion from another woman coder: https://medium.com/@marlene.jaeckel/the-empress-has-no-cloth...

Reality looks very different.

Women have a 2:1 chance over men to get a job in STEM: https://www.mindingthecampus.org/2015/11/04/women-favored-2-...

more detailed research on this: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4611984/

Then there's the Scandinavian gender paradox, which states that women are LESS likely to choose a career in STEM the more equal society becomes. This is because there's no more economic necessity, and other reasons. See http://www.thejournal.ie/gender-equality-countries-stem-girl...

I'm not surprised by the responses of these women. They represent the acceptable opinion of Silicon Valley.

Re: Six women computer scientists respond to why women don’t pursue computer science

#55
At my last gig I was paid ~30% less than the person I worked with on the project. They joined a bit earlier and negotiated a better deal, that's all.

All this talk about being promoted and receiving pay raises is funny to me. Never in my work history I was just 'promoted'. One climbs up by looking for new and better job. Same goes to pay.

Where is this magical land where men climb up by being men? I'd love to experience that!

Also, coding is not some magical job. For most people I know the line between work/free time barely exist. People that are good 1) code all day at work and then 2) go home and code some more at home. 1 and 2 may be unrelated but only on the surface. By coding at home they improve their skills and do better at work. But there's a price to pay. Other hobbies/interests have to be sacrificed. So is social life.

All articles of this kind make it sound like coding is some sort of magical job that's easy and well paid and has no downsides. My life experience is that finding a good programming job is incredibly hard and only very few people I know are happy with theirs. More often than not it's just daily grind.

Re: Six women computer scientists respond to why women don’t pursue computer science

#56

The title looks paradoxical... It seems that they would be precisely the less qualified people to talk about this subject. Maybe the women who didn't become computer scientist should know better why.

If you read the article you would have probably gleaned that these women had to overcome certain challenges to get into CS.

Maybe those hurdles are what other women face, hmmmm

Re: Six women computer scientists respond to why women don’t pursue computer science

#57
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's perfectly fine for women not to be interested in CS or any other field. There's probably a nature/nurture argument to be made for some of the disparity but that doesn't explain all of it. For example, one of the women in the article referenced a boss commenting about her breasts, another talked about being encouraged to drop out so a more deserving man could take her place... that's not lack of interest, that's…

Can any men here seriously recall in a professional context a boss referring to their 'package'? I can recall someone who did that before he became my manager. Or that they should leave the field so that some more deserving woman could take their place? I know a man who was told almost exactly that by a professor. (Minus the woman specifier.)

> Minus the woman specifier.

So, "you should leave this field so someone more deserving can have a place"? When you take out the gender qualifier it doesn't seem so ominous.

Re: Six women computer scientists respond to why women don’t pursue computer science

#58

So, all these women present anecdotal evidence. If you are interested in an opposite opinion from another woman coder: https://medium.com/@marlene.jaeckel/the-empress-has-no-cloth... Reality looks very different. Women have a 2:1 chance over men to get a job in STEM: https://www.mindingthecampus.org/2015/11/04/women-favored-2-... more detailed research on this: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4611984/ Th…

In one breath you dismiss these women and their "ancecdotes" while in the next breath you claim that what another woman says is "reality".

Hey, I guess as long as it supports your hypothesis, right?

Re: Six women computer scientists respond to why women don’t pursue computer science

#59

It's a wider issue with feminists and arguments, not specific to computing. Look at the interview of Jordan Peterson by Cathy Newman. Newman constantly misrepresented and lied about what he was saying in the interview itself, right in front of him , to an absurd level ("are you saying we should model our society after the lobsters"). The whole thing is on YouTube, it's worth watching if you can get through it without…

Sadly, misrepresenting is a common political tactic.

Remember, "you didn't build that?" President Obama made the argument that businesses do rely on substantial government services that are critical to a healthy commerce sector. He said "If you’ve got a business — you didn’t build that. Somebody else made that happen."

It was a clumsy way to put it, but it was clear to me what Obama was saying. Yet many on the right attacked him for stating that people who have a business didn't build their business.

Again, it's sad, because you know what? I think the center-right has a decent point to make here. Perhaps the government should leave some of these services to the private sector. Perhaps they are providing them inefficiently. There's all kinds of ways to disagree, discuss, debate, and rightly object to President Obama's thesis.

But we didn't get that debate. Instead, we got treated to a ton of misrepresentation, 30 second attack ads, and non-discussion posturing around something that someone didn't even say in the first place. And the public was actually denied an important debate and discussion that might have led to a greater understanding of the relationship between government regulation and private business.

Yeah, the right does this all the time. I will agree with you, though, that the left does this cynically and perhaps deliberately, especially on this topic.

Another time, John Kerry said "You know education, if you make the most of it, you study hard, you do your homework, and you make an effort to be smart, you can do well. If you don’t, you get stuck in Iraq”"

His scripted statement was supposed to be: "Do you know where you end up if you don’t study, if you aren’t smart, if you’re intellectually lazy? You end up getting us stuck in a war in Iraq. Just ask President Bush."

It was a pretty dumb statement, and I gotta say, even the scripted one was no prize winning quip. But of course the republicans of course had a field day with this one, claiming that Kerry was arguing that only unintelligent and uneducated people serve in the armed forces in Iraq.

And it was hard to watch a guy who received multiple educational deferrments righteously scold a vet with shrapnel embedded in his ass for saying that people use education to avoid military service.

Trust me, the right does this plenty. Plenty. So does the left. Plenty.

Re: Six women computer scientists respond to why women don’t pursue computer science

#60
post #2

Begging pardon, but is this not the wrong group of people to ask this question? Shouldn't we be asking women who didn't pursue computer science, not women who did?

Also, could asking men in computer science why they didn't choose an female dominated industry shed any light on the issue as well? Might shed some light on the issue from a different perspective but I think it would leave out some externalities that women face that men do not.
Post reply on HN