Live data from Hacker News

Medieval Wellness Tips

laphamsquarterly.org

61–70 of 70 posts

Re: Medieval Wellness Tips

#61

I wonder if anyone is going through these old texts to discover things. Perhaps rabbit bile contains something unique. Always makes you wonder... thats all for now, got a warm bed waiting for me.

> warm bed waiting

Sore from a beating are ya?

It's a shame they didn't have a cure for the uncomfortable feeling of having coffee in the sinuses!

Re: Medieval Wellness Tips

#62

I wonder if anyone is going through these old texts to discover things. Perhaps rabbit bile contains something unique. Always makes you wonder... thats all for now, got a warm bed waiting for me.

2015 Nobel Prize in Medicine was for an ancient Chinese medicine.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_Youyou

Re: Medieval Wellness Tips

#63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Rabies isn't that uncommon in the US - uncommon in domestic animals, sure, but I shot a likely rabid skunk a couple of weeks ago. It was out during the day, was walking at an angle, and was aggressive toward me.

That's actually completely correct, I don't know how I missed that when I wrote my comment. I've never seen a rabid animal, but I know that in the US, squirrels and bats are still a significant vector of rabies virus. It's probably not a good idea to play around with wild mammals. EDIT: From Wikipedia: > In wild animals, bats were the most frequently reported rabid species (30.9% of cases during 2015), followed by ra…

Radiolab on a modern rabies case: https://www.wnycstudios.org/story/312245-rodney-versus-death

Re: Medieval Wellness Tips

#64
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Except that any historian of medicine will tell you that pharmaceuticals well into the 18th century were dominated by ideas of "potency" where surely things would have beneficial effect because they have powerful smells or whatever. Uses of animal excrement are exceedingly common in early-modern remedy guides.

I remember learning from a historian that the use of animal excrement was used for all kinds of things; for example "curing" warts. The effectiveness was of course questionable, but that didn't stop people buying in to the hype of the day. Someone else recently posted about the Templar diet[1], and I thought that was actually quite ahead of it's time. What I find most interesting is how they could have been so ahead…

In defense of at least that wart remedy, a wart will turn green/black pretty much right away and then fall off relatively quickly if you keep it saturated with vinegar for a few hours here and there. I am willing to believe that some excreted waste materials could have a similar effect.

Re: Medieval Wellness Tips

#65

We should keep in mind that these tips are specifically chosen because of their unusual and laughable nature, and so should refrain from attempting to generalize about the nature of medieval medicine from a biased dataset.

Except that any historian of medicine will tell you that pharmaceuticals well into the 18th century were dominated by ideas of "potency" where surely things would have beneficial effect because they have powerful smells or whatever. Uses of animal excrement are exceedingly common in early-modern remedy guides.

"Fecal microbiota transplant (FMT), also known as a stool transplant, is the process of transplantation of fecal bacteria from a healthy individual into a recipient. FMT involves restoration of the colonic microflora by introducing healthy bacterial flora through infusion of stool, e.g. by colonoscopy, enema, orogastric tube or by mouth in the form of a capsule containing freeze-dried material, obtained from a healthy donor. The effectiveness of FMT has been established..."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fecal_microbiota_transplant

Re: Medieval Wellness Tips

#66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe an old phrase meaning "rabid dog" or "raged dog". Rabies was probably orders of magnitude more common of an occurrence back then (which is non-existent in most Western countries right now).

Rabies isn't that uncommon in the US - uncommon in domestic animals, sure, but I shot a likely rabid skunk a couple of weeks ago. It was out during the day, was walking at an angle, and was aggressive toward me.

I had a racoon walk right through my open front door that was likely rabid. Looked like he was drunk and staggering, aggressive but not quite there. Ended up chasing it back outside with a piece of copper pipe since it was blocking the way to my varmint rifle.

Re: Medieval Wellness Tips

#68
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Big and heavy - requires anatomic knowledge (you know there was no Wikipedia showing exactly where that dog carries it’s liver)...

You don't need academic knowledge of anatomy if you grow up in a culture (that of medieval peasants) where hunting, cleaning, and cooking animals was likely common. Much can be inferred from analogy, in the way the non-human dissections were (and still are) used for training surgeons.

Many assumptions about the knowledge of the persons who shall apply the guidelines - but might be right.

Re: Medieval Wellness Tips

#69
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Big and heavy - requires anatomic knowledge (you know there was no Wikipedia showing exactly where that dog carries it’s liver)...

Probably in the same place as a sheep or a pig. A butcher would have no problem finding it. ;)

Probably. Clearly if you happen to have a butcher at hand to get you the liver. Not sure if nowadays you could just bring a random dig to a butcher and ket him extract the liver for you - might be hygienic standards preventing to do it. Earlier might be the belief that dogs are dirty etc. but i don’t know...

Re: Medieval Wellness Tips

#70

> If you doubt this’ll work, test it on a dog which is completely red. This really confuses me. Why does the dog need to be red? Also, if someone ever tested it, it should be obvious to not work...

Maybe an old phrase meaning "rabid dog" or "raged dog". Rabies was probably orders of magnitude more common of an occurrence back then (which is non-existent in most Western countries right now).

The reference to a Red Dog is likely to refer to the saying "seeing red", so yes a rabid animal can probably also be inferred just like Stags shed the velvet from their antlers exposing the bloodied red antlers at the start of the rutting season (a violent act to win over females) as seen here. https://www.mailonsunday.co.uk/news/article-6206553/Stunning... Overall a red dog is almost likely to mean a dog that is angry for some reason.
Post reply on HN