Live data from Hacker News

Man Who Stole Plane Near Seattle Raises Troubling Security Question

nytimes.com

31–40 of 213 posts

Re: Man Who Stole Plane Near Seattle Raises Troubling Security Question

#31
post #9

Surprising it has taken decades for someone to try this. At least we don't have to wait on delayed planes while the pilot tracks down the key...

> Surprising it has taken decades for someone to try this.

It last happened 7 years ago. From the article:

> Colton Harris-Moore, nicknamed the Barefoot Bandit, was sentenced in 2011 for stealing small planes, which he had learned to fly himself as a teenager after reading flight manuals.

Re: Man Who Stole Plane Near Seattle Raises Troubling Security Question

#32
post #15

> "Mr. Russell...had worked his shift on Friday." So glad they told us this important fact. I wonder if his final direct deposit (to his estate) will include that days' pay or if it will count as a vacation day? Has the news always been this inane?

The paycheck might goto restitution.

Re: Man Who Stole Plane Near Seattle Raises Troubling Security Question

#33

> Mr. Russell stole a plane from the airport and flew it for about an hour before it crashed. (emphasis mine) Wonder why Air National Guard's scrambled F-15s [0] didn't engage and bring the plane down before the individual commandeering the prop -- Mr. Russell -- brought the aircraft down with himself in the Ketron Island. IIRC, the plane flew over several densely populated areas before going down, and I can imagine…

My uninformed guess is that the F-15 were scrambled to intercept if the plane started heading towards Bangor, Bremerton shipyards or JBLM. Lots of military bases and critical infra up in the PNW, thankfully it didn't appear to be the case in this incident.

I'm not sure they were terribly worried about JBLM considering they were trying to talk him into landing there.

Re: Man Who Stole Plane Near Seattle Raises Troubling Security Question

#34

> Mr. Russell stole a plane from the airport and flew it for about an hour before it crashed. (emphasis mine) Wonder why Air National Guard's scrambled F-15s [0] didn't engage and bring the plane down before the individual commandeering the prop -- Mr. Russell -- brought the aircraft down with himself in the Ketron Island. IIRC, the plane flew over several densely populated areas before going down, and I can imagine…

And to think, even if they decided to take him down, it would have likely been over a populated area. Unless they disintegrated it with missiles while in the sky, it likely would have ended in a catastrophe. The decision to not take the plan out as soon as they had the chance to safely was interesting. Their lack of action could have resulted in the deaths of hundreds, if not thousands of people. Interestingly enough…

Unless they disintegrated it with missiles while in the sky, it likely would have ended in a catastrophe.

And even then I imagine the raining shrapnel (likely burning too) would cause plenty of chaos itself.

The outcome of this was probably near the best (the best being the guy managing to land the plane safely and survive) --- it could've been much much worse.

Re: Man Who Stole Plane Near Seattle Raises Troubling Security Question

#35
post #9

Surprising it has taken decades for someone to try this. At least we don't have to wait on delayed planes while the pilot tracks down the key...

It's not like the engine start procedure on one of those things is a turnkey solution. The amount of domain knowledge needed serves as a form of soft security.

So soft, you can find the QRH in both the cockpit and online[0]. Or more fun learn it in an accurate simulator e.g.: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J0Z1WFDz81k

[0] https://flyuk.aero/assets/downloads/resources/checklists/UKV...

Re: Man Who Stole Plane Near Seattle Raises Troubling Security Question

#36
post #6

> Mr. Russell stole a plane from the airport and flew it for about an hour before it crashed. (emphasis mine) Wonder why Air National Guard's scrambled F-15s [0] didn't engage and bring the plane down before the individual commandeering the prop -- Mr. Russell -- brought the aircraft down with himself in the Ketron Island. IIRC, the plane flew over several densely populated areas before going down, and I can imagine…

Listen to the recording of ATC personnel talking to the rogue pilot. He's just a normal guy with a few screws loose. I think they correctly assessed this man to be non-threatening to ground targets. Now, if the guy was non-responsive or erratic or started making threats, I do expect that the F15s might have been used.

Do you trust your hijackers to announce their intention to run into a building? In fact if a 9/11 ever happens again, the hijackers will have a pretty hard job convincing the passengers this is not a suicide mission and they shouldn't rebel. I always thought that is what prevented another 9/11, not confiscating baby milk at airport security checks.

Re: Man Who Stole Plane Near Seattle Raises Troubling Security Question

#37

> Mr. Russell stole a plane from the airport and flew it for about an hour before it crashed. (emphasis mine) Wonder why Air National Guard's scrambled F-15s [0] didn't engage and bring the plane down before the individual commandeering the prop -- Mr. Russell -- brought the aircraft down with himself in the Ketron Island. IIRC, the plane flew over several densely populated areas before going down, and I can imagine…

And to think, even if they decided to take him down, it would have likely been over a populated area. Unless they disintegrated it with missiles while in the sky, it likely would have ended in a catastrophe. The decision to not take the plan out as soon as they had the chance to safely was interesting. Their lack of action could have resulted in the deaths of hundreds, if not thousands of people. Interestingly enough…

>Who else can ever say they did a freaking barrel roll in a commercial airliner.

Tex Johnston for one:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AaA7kPfC5Hk

Re: Man Who Stole Plane Near Seattle Raises Troubling Security Question

#38
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The Bombardier Q400 can seat 80 people and weighs 40,000 lbs empty.

Which is about half of the weight of a loaded 18 wheeler.

Which has a maximum speed about one quarter the Bombardier Q400 and one sixth the fuel capacity. It's not a "small prop plane" is the point here.

Re: Man Who Stole Plane Near Seattle Raises Troubling Security Question

#39
post #6

> Mr. Russell stole a plane from the airport and flew it for about an hour before it crashed. (emphasis mine) Wonder why Air National Guard's scrambled F-15s [0] didn't engage and bring the plane down before the individual commandeering the prop -- Mr. Russell -- brought the aircraft down with himself in the Ketron Island. IIRC, the plane flew over several densely populated areas before going down, and I can imagine…

Listen to the recording of ATC personnel talking to the rogue pilot. He's just a normal guy with a few screws loose. I think they correctly assessed this man to be non-threatening to ground targets. Now, if the guy was non-responsive or erratic or started making threats, I do expect that the F15s might have been used.

The calmness of ATC never fails to amaze me. Pilots too.

Re: Man Who Stole Plane Near Seattle Raises Troubling Security Question

#40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Which is about half of the weight of a loaded 18 wheeler.

Said 18 wheeler isn't traveling 130mph :)

kinetic energy of 20,000 kg at 600 mph = 1/2 (20,000 kg) * 268 m/s ^ 2 = 718,240,000 joules

11,000 gallons of gas in a tanker truck = 33 kwh * 11,000 gallons = 1,306,800,000,000 joules

FWIW, I'd be up for reviewing the systems, but let's not over react.

P.S. Feel free to correct my math if I was off the mark.

Post reply on HN