Live data from Hacker News

Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

wsj.com

61–70 of 174 posts

Re: Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

#61

If this trend is real it will be really good for social mobility.

I don't think so. Having a degree from CC marks you as from the lower class. Upper level and prestigious positions tend to be filled with people just like those already there. There was a good study on this http://www.asanet.org/journals/ASR/Dec12ASRFeature.pdf

Re: Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

#62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What is your suggestion for OP where their resume is immediately discard because of no education? Networking and meetups won’t get you passed HR filters and corporate requirements. As I mentioned, even if you don’t get the job or lose the job, you’re still ahead of not trying. And you now have experience to put towards your next employer (and your old employer will only verify employment dates, as they don’t want to…

> As I mentioned, even if you don’t get the job or lose the job, you’re still ahead of not trying. I fail to see how poisoning your own reputation comes out as "still ahead"; that is absolutely guaranteed to get your résumé silently discarded. The tech community isn't that big, even in the tech hubs, and word does eventually get around both among engineers and recruiters.

Rumors are a quick way to get sued. Are you ready to pay a settlement as an employer because someone’s resume has an inaccuracy on it? Sometimes there are benefits of living in a litigious society when it works in your favor.

Re: Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

#63
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> If they don't, you have a job you otherwise wouldn't have had. No, you have a job for as long as you're able to keep your lie secret. Once the lie comes out, even if it's X years down the road, you're terminated for cause, and if a prospective new employer calls they will be told you are "ineligible to be rehired." There are possible legal consequences as well. GP, do not lie. In the long run, the world works out t…

There are number of recent very high c level executives who where fired for this.

Well seems like it worked then since they already got their payout

Re: Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

#64
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the other advantage is that at most community colleges you are required to branch out from technical topics and take at least a few humanities and liberal arts courses. You end up coming out slightly more well-rounded which can be hugely beneficial both career and life wise.

Is there actually good evidence on the value of a "well-rounded education"? But in any case, I don't think shoe-horning general education into what is basically jobs training is the right approach. We put kids through 12 years of "general education", if we haven't succeeded at that point, why would a few more college credits help?

Helps you pass the "Airport Test" If you have spent your uni years rote learning you not going to do very well.

If say you had been in the foot lights (Cambridge) got a blue or been on university challenge.

Our in a very interesting case when I worked at BT, been a under 21 international and had his foot blown off in the Balkan wars and been medevac'd to the UK

Re: Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

#65
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’m not sure that knowing about Æthelred the Unready is particularly useful for most jobs, but if you think of these classes as (covertly) teaching critical thinking and writing skills, then perhaps they make some sense even if you don’t value knowing about the world beyond your particular specialization.

But are they actually teaching critical thinking successfully? And why would you need to wait until college for those effects to show up? The humanities classes are taught throughout regular schooling.

Not at that level its only when you get to A level and Uni you realy get to do much critical thinking.

Re: Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

#66

I attended community college for a few years before transferring to a 4-year university. During that time I took a variety of technical and non-technical courses that I really enjoyed and felt I got a lot of value from due to the small class sizes and ability to connect with professors outside of class fairly easily. I would have stopped after getting my Associate’s degree as I felt like I had learned a lot and I had…

Community colleges really are underrated. In a world where increasingly a bachelor's degree does not guarantee a job, university education is super expensive, and especially in fields where a bachelor's degree is not necessary (I've never had an interview where they asked about my college education), vocational schools are the place to be. Four-year universities put big emphasis on well-rounded educations, so you're…

> math classes

You really shouldn't avoid math if you want to be an educated person. Math is the key to the universe.

Re: Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

#67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What is your suggestion for OP where their resume is immediately discard because of no education? Networking and meetups won’t get you passed HR filters and corporate requirements. As I mentioned, even if you don’t get the job or lose the job, you’re still ahead of not trying. And you now have experience to put towards your next employer (and your old employer will only verify employment dates, as they don’t want to…

"Fake it until you make it" is completely different from "lie until you are caught." Speaking from experience, lying is not a good idea. OP is competing against people who have put in work that he/she hasn't. That's just the reality. The best way in is to show the employer that they are a qualitatively superior employee. Networking and filters are _very often_ surpassed by leadership, sometimes even by creating new p…

Your anecdotes aren’t helpful compared to the macro scale at which employers disregard capable candidates due to unnecessary signaling requirements.

I don’t suggest lying lightly, but it is sometimes necessary in the current environment.

Re: Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

#68
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

you're not required to do humanities/liberal arts at US universities?

Outside the USA and its cultural appendages, Canada, South Korea and the like, it is assumed that anyone who goes to university has studied the liberal arts at secondary/high school. Given the low quality of secondary education in the US in the formative period of its third level system this could not be assumed so what would in Europe be considered (grammar school) high school classes and subjects are taught at univ…

The big differences in Universities between the US and Europe developed over a century ago and were the result of philosophical disagreements about what qualifies as a liberal education. It had nothing to do with poor quality secondary education.

Parts of the US have world class secondary education and parts don't--just like Europe. Even taken as a whole the US education system ranks higher than many countries in Europe.

>South Korea

The South Korean education system is nothing like the US education system. It's hard to think of a large country more different from the US in this regard.

Re: Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

#69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What is your suggestion for OP where their resume is immediately discard because of no education? Networking and meetups won’t get you passed HR filters and corporate requirements. As I mentioned, even if you don’t get the job or lose the job, you’re still ahead of not trying. And you now have experience to put towards your next employer (and your old employer will only verify employment dates, as they don’t want to…

> As I mentioned, even if you don’t get the job or lose the job, you’re still ahead of not trying. I fail to see how poisoning your own reputation comes out as "still ahead"; that is absolutely guaranteed to get your résumé silently discarded. The tech community isn't that big, even in the tech hubs, and word does eventually get around both among engineers and recruiters.

True that. The community I work with all know each other, and one's reputation is paramount. If anyone found out I lied about my degree, I'd be finished. I wouldn't work with a cheat, either.

Re: Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

#70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What is your suggestion for OP where their resume is immediately discard because of no education? Networking and meetups won’t get you passed HR filters and corporate requirements. As I mentioned, even if you don’t get the job or lose the job, you’re still ahead of not trying. And you now have experience to put towards your next employer (and your old employer will only verify employment dates, as they don’t want to…

B.Sc. Computer Information Systems, Wahresleben University, 2014. (Wahres Leben = “real life” in German) If they actually check they won’t find the university but they can’t discount the fact it might exist. So HR is more likely to follow up with you then throw your resume out, and you can take that chance to explain you being more to the table than a university graduate.

Employers don't care to hire a liar. What you'd "bring to the table" is a lack of trust. What else have you lied about? Would you lie on expense reports? Would you betray confidential information? Would you lie about the quality of the work you'd do?
Post reply on HN