Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft and GitHub have held acquisition talks

businessinsider.com

421–430 of 567 posts

Re: Microsoft and GitHub have held acquisition talks

#421
I don't understand why all the bashing, there is no better time to cash in. Gitlab in few years time will make Github worth less.

Gitlab.com and self host GitLab offer the best of both worlds. Gitlab right now still isn't as good as Github, but it is good enough for many things. And we see improvement coming in every few months. Not to mention Microsoft will likely move the whole Github infrastructure to Azure.

Re: Microsoft and GitHub have held acquisition talks

#423

Earlier quoted context omitted.

what makes you think that? they killed off their own code hosting site in codeplex and moved everything to github. they are one of the largest if not the largest open source contributors in the world. and .net core is setting itself up to be a major player in cross-platform application development. it has a chance, if microsoft brings over uwp, wpf, and windows forms to .net core, to take over cross-platform gui deve…

You mention a lot of stuff that's in the same '.NET world' skellera mentioned, but the currently dominant GUI platform is the web, and neither is going to do take over. There's also still embedded software, hardware description, databases, emulators/simulators, competing virtual machines and GUI frameworks, a whole bunch of non-tech stuff, etc. They do get a lot of this stuff, but I feel like whatever they want to do…

not really. half the stuff i mentioned is all about the web. that’s the core market for .net core and visual studio code. visual studio code is certainly not .net centric at all. the in the box language support primarily targets web languages.

and i don’t get why you are mentioning those other things. what do they have to do with anything regarding microsoft understanding github? microsoft is no doubt and expert in all of those fields anyway, at least internally.

and what cross-platform gui framework would compete with a .net core cross-platform implementation of uwp, wpf, and windows forms? nothing, in my opinion. people would flood the .net ecosystem to get away from things like c++ and qt and the horror of writing script-based GUIs in python.

Re: Microsoft and GitHub have held acquisition talks

#424
post #351

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Atlassian is very much a Software Company.

I wouldn’t exactly call them the gold standard of software. JIRA is a holy mess and well... many of us are still stuck with HipChat

Who is the gold standard?

Re: Microsoft and GitHub have held acquisition talks

#426
post #266

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's Steve Ballmer. He had the reverse-Midas touch, but he's gone now.

Microsoft was actually highly successful under Ballmer. Just not in terms of image or in the consumer-facing world.

No. Microsoft's market cap remained steady during a 10 year boom that gave rise to most of the dominant players in the tech industry.

https://blogs.wsj.com/moneybeat/2013/08/23/the-steve-ballmer...

Re: Microsoft and GitHub have held acquisition talks

#428

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Microsoft was actually highly successful under Ballmer. Just not in terms of image or in the consumer-facing world.

It's a big company and hard to blame an individual for mistakes. But they totally missed out on being the mobile OS of the future under him. And they ended up getting a late, slow start to cloud computing (minus SAAS).

They lost their market leading position in not just mobile, but also browsers and consumer operating systems.

Re: Microsoft and GitHub have held acquisition talks

#429
post #135
post #6

Really hope these talks fall through and nothing comes of it. Too many bad experiences with Microsoft buying something out, mismanaging it, and it goes down the drain. As much as I love GitHub, I won't be using a Microsoft-owned GitHub for any of my company's work.

If it were maybe 5 years ago I would be horrified, but under Nadella they are a lot less ... Microsoft-y.

That's what they want you to believe :D

Re: Microsoft and GitHub have held acquisition talks

#430

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That code you mentioned has opt-out spyware. It's not in the spirit of free software at all. It's just part of embrace, extend, extinguish.

Microsoft has never been about free software. They are however embracing open source in a manner that feels very sincere to me. For the record, the so-called "spyware" is telemetry which exists only in the SDK for .NET Core and not the actual runtime that you would ship to the user with the software. It is anonymous data, completely open source so it really is only what they say it is, and the first time you use it i…

> so-called "spyware" is telemetry

Doublespeak.

Post reply on HN