Live data from Hacker News

How Mapbox Is Winning Over Developers to Challenge Google's Mapping Dominance

forbes.com

61–70 of 114 posts

Re: How Mapbox Is Winning Over Developers to Challenge Google's Mapping Dominance

#61

There are more alternatives to Google & Mapbox that mostly use OpenStreetMap as a backing data source: https://openmaptiles.org (only map tiles) https://stadiamaps.com (map tiles, static maps & routing) https://www.thunderforest.com (only maps) https://geocoder.opencagedata.com (only geocoding) https://geocode.earth (only geocoding) A laundry listing: https://switch2osm.org/providers/ Tile providers are very thankful…

Do you know of any tile service offering colored, shaded elevation reliefs? I've been trying to find something for our meteorologists to use and the best I've found is https://maps-for-free.com

Re: How Mapbox Is Winning Over Developers to Challenge Google's Mapping Dominance

#63
post #61

There are more alternatives to Google & Mapbox that mostly use OpenStreetMap as a backing data source: https://openmaptiles.org (only map tiles) https://stadiamaps.com (map tiles, static maps & routing) https://www.thunderforest.com (only maps) https://geocoder.opencagedata.com (only geocoding) https://geocode.earth (only geocoding) A laundry listing: https://switch2osm.org/providers/ Tile providers are very thankful…

Do you know of any tile service offering colored, shaded elevation reliefs? I've been trying to find something for our meteorologists to use and the best I've found is https://maps-for-free.com

> Do you know of any tile service offering colored, shaded elevation reliefs?

Does that imply variation in coloration based on elevation? (Just making sure I understand your question.) We have limited support for basic hillshading and are actively looking into contour lines. Coloration for various elevations is something we do not currently offer (nor am I aware of any other providers), but it is something we would be willing to investigate.

Depending on what precise application you need, this may be possible one the web using our normal vector maps and contour lines.

Re: How Mapbox Is Winning Over Developers to Challenge Google's Mapping Dominance

#64

The era of mashups / cool web projects using Google Maps has ended. Their recent 28x price change (from $0.50 / 1000 views to $14 per 1000) has been cleverly disguised by the simultaneous rebranding to the "Google Maps Platform".

I wonder how many of the projects showcased over googlemapsmania.blogspot.com are just going to close the door.

Re: How Mapbox Is Winning Over Developers to Challenge Google's Mapping Dominance

#65
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Mapzen, a now sadly defunct mapping startup, also had an awesome (if I say so myself - I used to work there, but not on that team) vector tile renderer for browser and mobile. Check it out at https://github.com/tangrams Also, there was a great interactive style editor ( https://github.com/tangrams/tangram-play ), although it seems the demo site is broken now :-(

Any chance mapzen would open source the code used to make metro extracts? The formats your team had to offer were so much nicer than working with raw OSM data

I'm glad you found them useful! The code which made all the metro extracts was embedded as a Chef recipe, although I'm sure you could just extract the bits which do stuff from the Chef wrappers: https://github.com/mapzen/chef-metroextractor

Re: How Mapbox Is Winning Over Developers to Challenge Google's Mapping Dominance

#66
post #51

There are more alternatives to Google & Mapbox that mostly use OpenStreetMap as a backing data source: https://openmaptiles.org (only map tiles) https://stadiamaps.com (map tiles, static maps & routing) https://www.thunderforest.com (only maps) https://geocoder.opencagedata.com (only geocoding) https://geocode.earth (only geocoding) A laundry listing: https://switch2osm.org/providers/ Tile providers are very thankful…

Hmmm I evaluated a lot of those (mainly OSM-based) geocoders recently. Unfortunately the quality of results is orders of magnitude worse than Google. The only ones that even came close were Mapbox, Mapquest and Here.

Hi,

co-founder of OpenCage here.

It depends heavily on what your use case is: forward or reverse, which part of the world, what level of granularity, etc. Google offers a great geocoding service, no doubt. But you also have to pay their price, and obey their terms and conditions. Their great service is overkill for many very common use cases, at least those that we see from our customers.

Anyone who wants to try us out, our demo page is here: https://geocoder.opencagedata.com/demo

Re: How Mapbox Is Winning Over Developers to Challenge Google's Mapping Dominance

#67
post #61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you know of any tile service offering colored, shaded elevation reliefs? I've been trying to find something for our meteorologists to use and the best I've found is https://maps-for-free.com

> Do you know of any tile service offering colored, shaded elevation reliefs? Does that imply variation in coloration based on elevation? (Just making sure I understand your question.) We have limited support for basic hillshading and are actively looking into contour lines. Coloration for various elevations is something we do not currently offer (nor am I aware of any other providers), but it is something we would b…

Yes, color for elevation and shading for slope.

Another use case that I've been searching for is a tile set not of images, but of just elevation data. So that I could implement something similar to google earth's lat/lng/elevation info wherever your mouse cursor is.

Re: How Mapbox Is Winning Over Developers to Challenge Google's Mapping Dominance

#68
More crucially, they are winning over executives of medium-to-large internet businesses with superior sales and marketing.

Individual engineers at these places do not have the power to make decisions about which map software to use, which are often six- or seven-figure contracts. Mapbox offers a service that is comparable to Google Maps in terms of price, quality and flexibility. From a technical standpoint, there are pros and cons to both services; Mapbox's toolkit is more modern than Google, which means documentation is a pro for Mapbox but legacy browser support is a con (though it's just a minor annoyance).

Where they far outstrip Google is in sales and customer support. Google Maps won't bat an eye for you, even if you're paying them millions of dollars a year. The Mapbox team, in contrast, will devote developer time to answering your questions, respond to GitHub issues for you in a timely manner, and even create new plugins and repos if you have a legitimate need. That is their big advantage and that is what is driving adoption.

Source: I was employed at a medium-sized internet publisher, and tasked with evaluating Mapbox to replace Google Maps, was a primary developer working on the switch-over, and even wrote a blog post about the experience [0]. They even invited me to their office to work with them for a day (which, regrettably, I wasn't able to follow up on).

[0]: https://blog.rentpathcode.com/webpack-progressive-enhancemen...

Re: How Mapbox Is Winning Over Developers to Challenge Google's Mapping Dominance

#70
post #67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Do you know of any tile service offering colored, shaded elevation reliefs? Does that imply variation in coloration based on elevation? (Just making sure I understand your question.) We have limited support for basic hillshading and are actively looking into contour lines. Coloration for various elevations is something we do not currently offer (nor am I aware of any other providers), but it is something we would b…

Yes, color for elevation and shading for slope. Another use case that I've been searching for is a tile set not of images, but of just elevation data. So that I could implement something similar to google earth's lat/lng/elevation info wherever your mouse cursor is.

You don't need a web service for that. The data is free, search for "SRTM" and download the continents you need.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shuttle_Radar_Topography_Missi...

Post reply on HN