Live data from Hacker News

Project from Hell (2008)

projectfailures.wordpress.com

31–40 of 157 posts

Re: Project from Hell (2008)

#31
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Same in German. It's a quirk of English that free as in freedom and free as in no cost are the same word.

But then you get the great quip that 'freedom isn't free'...

"Freiheit ist nicht umsonst" just doesn't have the same ring :-)

Re: Project from Hell (2008)

#32
post #9

>Average turn-over for the newcomers: 3 months, the legal time to leave your job in France. Can someone explain the meaning of this? I think something got lost in translation.

That would be the notice period. Germany is similar, it tends to be 6 weeks to the end of the quarter, and it generally applies to both employee and employer. Though it often isn't quite as applicable to the employee...what are they going to do if you don't show up, fire you?

Sweden is also like that. You usually have to linger for two months before leaving after you've quit.

> what are they going to do if you don't show up

They will simply not pay you.

What you do when you're deep into a project like the OP describes is to quit your job by telling your manager that he's the worst you have ever worked for. Then one of three things happen:

1. He/she asks me to stick around for two months. I do and get paid regular salary during. 2. He says "hey, if you want to leave today, that's fine with me". I do but I wont get any more pay checks. 3. They are offended by my critique and says "walk away from you computer right now and never come back". I get paid for two months without having to work.

When #3 happens it's excellent because you will have two months of pay and enough time to find a new job if your resignation was in the spur of the moment. And no need to worry about bad references. When my up and coming boss calls my last horrible boss, someone who I happily divorced, things will work out fine.

Even though (middle?) managers are usually full of prestige and are quite easily offended, #3 has happened to me only once.

Although most don't, I try to utilize or take advantage of the system to the max in my quest to find a decent work place/project. I job hop a lot.

Re: Project from Hell (2008)

#33

> It is forbidden to come to work after 9am. One day, the site manager stayed behind the main gates and fired on the spot every person who came in after 9.01am, including a number of managers and sales. This surprised me. I thought it was extremely difficult to fire people in France.

From another post in the blog: "Among the many comments, some surprised me. Seems lots of people cannot believe you can be fired in France for being 1 minute late at work. Sorry to burst your bubble, mates, but this is what SSIIs (contractor companies) were invented for. You don’t lose your job, you immediately lose the contract you are working on (no justification needed, this is what contractors are for)" So they w…

> So they were not really employees, but consultants.

On places where it's hard to fire people, mostly everybody works as consultants and people tend see those positions as normal job positions.

Re: Project from Hell (2008)

#34

I love how the first thing complained about was the use of C++ for the project. Compared to the lack of sane source control and release management, inexperience of the team, dozens of layers of abstraction, management bureaucracy, toxic culture, basic facilities like toilets being inoperative... I think using C++ was literally the least of their concerns.

They also started, if I'm doing my arithmetic right, in 1996. Honestly, I could see C++ having been their best choice back then. Every language I would rather do a large project in is either newer than that or would have been pretty immature for a large project in the mid-90s.

Re: Project from Hell (2008)

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From another post in the blog: "Among the many comments, some surprised me. Seems lots of people cannot believe you can be fired in France for being 1 minute late at work. Sorry to burst your bubble, mates, but this is what SSIIs (contractor companies) were invented for. You don’t lose your job, you immediately lose the contract you are working on (no justification needed, this is what contractors are for)" So they w…

> So they were not really employees, but consultants. On places where it's hard to fire people, mostly everybody works as consultants and people tend see those positions as normal job positions.

In Germany it is hard to fire somebody. Almost nobody works as consultant, and consultants are not normal job positions.

Re: Project from Hell (2008)

#36
post #25

I would guess the project was (is?) running pretty much just as the people in charge wanted it to run. 10 years in and they were still billing -- more than ever -- for a project that would have completed 7-8 years previously if things had been done according to plan. All the seemingly massively stupid and counter productive decisions made make sense if the goal is to confuse matters to make it seem like progress has…

But they are being fined at E1000's a day. In the UK we now have projects forced to go through regular if not frequent traffic light reviews - a panel of actual experts reviews the project - i think it was one such thing that killed the NHS network project (12 billion over spend). one panel, one review. saved money.

i suspect the french gov will have put something similar in place, but i do agree with the final paragraph of the piece - it's probably a corrupt practise not top management stupidity.

Re: Project from Hell (2008)

#37
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> So they were not really employees, but consultants. On places where it's hard to fire people, mostly everybody works as consultants and people tend see those positions as normal job positions.

In Germany it is hard to fire somebody. Almost nobody works as consultant, and consultants are not normal job positions.

Technically, using consultants as French SSII do is illegal, but nobody cares. In factories, it used to be the same until 10 years ago when labour inspection finally intervened. We can only hope it'll be the same for IT/CS jobs in the coming years.

Re: Project from Hell (2008)

#38
post #9

>Average turn-over for the newcomers: 3 months, the legal time to leave your job in France. Can someone explain the meaning of this? I think something got lost in translation.

That would be the notice period. Germany is similar, it tends to be 6 weeks to the end of the quarter, and it generally applies to both employee and employer. Though it often isn't quite as applicable to the employee...what are they going to do if you don't show up, fire you?

In Spain, the notice period is 15 days, even if your contract says you have a longer notice period and an economic penalty clause. 15 days including the holidays you have accumulated. The trade-off is if you leave you don't have the right to unemployment benefits, that only happens if your employer fires you.

Re: Project from Hell (2008)

#39

>Average turn-over for the newcomers: 3 months, the legal time to leave your job in France. Can someone explain the meaning of this? I think something got lost in translation.

You have to work for 3 months before you can quit an employer in France. It's not "at-will". At least that's how I interpreted it, and given France's stronger labor laws I wouldn't be surprised if that's the case.

That's exactly how it's done, except in Alsace-Moselle (the German part of France during a few wars) where it's two weeks when the employee wants to leave and two to four months (depending on job-specific labour laws – convention collective – and seniority) when the employee is fired.

Re: Project from Hell (2008)

#40
There are lots of people on the pipeline that take their share of our taxes to deliver to "the letter of the contract" [1], without considering the intend.

Closest I've been is when an agency sold my time to another agency which sold my time to the end client, who paid me with "profit" from insurance money ( the end client was an insurance agent ).

And as I'm not in my 20s anymore and I look at how government related IT services work, I'm so much afraid about everything else happening around me. Questions like "What about the tram I use every day? There should be a company maintaining these things. Probably is hell there as well."

1 : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Letter_and_spirit_of_the_law

Post reply on HN