Live data from Hacker News

Facebook denies it collects call and SMS data from phones without permission

techcrunch.com

211–220 of 370 posts

Re: Facebook denies it collects call and SMS data from phones without permission

#211
post #201

Everybody is talking about Facebook these days, but is anybody considering to delete his Whatsapp and Instragram accounts too? I mean, aren't they part of Facebook nowadays? Wouldn't it be consistent to abandon all Facebook services?

Whatsapp still sends (for now) way less data than Facebook and also has much better security. I wonder how long it will continue.

Re: Facebook denies it collects call and SMS data from phones without permission

#212

I suspected this many years ago when familiar faces from our customers started to appear in the friend suggestion box. I've never installed the FB app on my phone, but our less privacy oriented customers probably have. What pisses me off is that while I can choose what information I share, I haven't given other people nor Facebook permission to read phone call logs that involve me.

The same applies to Gmail use.

While (an abstract) you may be OK with trading your privacy for a convinience of a free email account, it automatically means me also getting sweeped by Google's information dragnet.

Re: Facebook denies it collects call and SMS data from phones without permission

#213
post #134

I feel in a way very disturbed by all these news coming out. Not by their contents, I don't feel there's nothing new here, but by the way way they are written. Since when is it not known in the tech world that facebook's business model exists around the idea of making a piece of legal spyware. At least where I live it's unpolite to give someone's contacts to anyone without asking the person first. I don't see why is…

Well, the users of facebook do get the facebook service in exchange for the data they provide. TANSTAAFL. If you don’t pay with money, you’re paying with something else. Facebook is not a charity. The question is not whether they’re allowed to obtain (non-monetary) payment for using their service, it’s whether it was (and is) clear what the price is. What irks me is why non of these services allow monetary payment. W…

>TANSTAAFL.

Bless you?

(Seriously what does this mean?)

Re: Facebook denies it collects call and SMS data from phones without permission

#214

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is nothing to suggest dark UX patterns were at play here. People simply gave Facebook access to everything because it was fashionable and convenient. People simply do not care about their privacy if its in conflict with convenience. It has been common knowledge for years that Facebook will directly use that data against you and still people, completely aware of this, didn't care. The only thing that made people…

When you install malware on your computer, it asks for permission too. People don't understand why their USB drive suddenly needs their account password, but they need to get the files that are stored on there so they type it in. That UAC popup may as well be triggered at random based on how often it shows up, and it never explains why. Is that consent? Do you have a hard time finding the words to blame the malware c…

The difference there is that malware actually is a dark pattern and operates without your permission. Facebook is not a dark pattern and is nothing if you do not willingly surrender your data to their legal ownership.

Re: Facebook denies it collects call and SMS data from phones without permission

#215

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm still completely convinced that this whole scandal will not damage Facebook a bit, in the long term. Yeah, the stock is going to be a bit lower for some weeks, some people will leave, but the largest part of the Facebook users has not even realised the scandal in full scale. They're not going anywhere, they're going to continue as is, since there really is not alternative for Facebook right now and tbh they would…

Every company's destiny is decided by revenue and profit. Facebook will be fine as long as the advertising money keeps coming in. Will it? I don't see why not. Companies don't care about user privacy.

Agreed.

Many people didn't realize that we still living in a global society that pretty much made by many super large sized Black Pearl[0]s and Jack Sparrow(s) is the captain.

Dear Captain Jack is cool sometimes, and could bring you to the treasure, but you should never trust him that he will taking care of you. In fact, regardless what he said, he don't care about you even a little, all he care about is himself. If you fell off board, he will not bother to save you, unless it's out of coincidence.

So yes, you may follow him closely for an amazing adventure if you want to, but whether or not you will survive in the end, it's all depends on you.

[0] Yes, that pirate ship.

Re: Facebook denies it collects call and SMS data from phones without permission

#216
post #134

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, the users of facebook do get the facebook service in exchange for the data they provide. TANSTAAFL. If you don’t pay with money, you’re paying with something else. Facebook is not a charity. The question is not whether they’re allowed to obtain (non-monetary) payment for using their service, it’s whether it was (and is) clear what the price is. What irks me is why non of these services allow monetary payment. W…

>TANSTAAFL. Bless you? (Seriously what does this mean?)

There Ain't No Such Thing As A Free Lunch.

Re: Facebook denies it collects call and SMS data from phones without permission

#217

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is an easily testable premise. Ask anybody if they have deleted their Facebook account. If they are hesitating they probably won't.

Actually deleting the account doesn't matter -- if you don't use the account, that's what matters more and here's why. Facebook's revenue is almost exclusively from advertising. Advertising costs on Facebook depend on reach, PPM, and/or PPC. Facebook advertisers don't pay for "active users" or even "users" -- they pay for PPM/PPC. In other words, your data is relatively worthless if you aren't around to be targeted b…

Except that with any account at all, whatever information is available, can be sold to any third party that wants it through Facebook Research.

Advertising isn't the whole story by a long shot... hence CA / SCL Group (and whom else shall we add next?)

Re: Facebook denies it collects call and SMS data from phones without permission

#218

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm still completely convinced that this whole scandal will not damage Facebook a bit, in the long term. Yeah, the stock is going to be a bit lower for some weeks, some people will leave, but the largest part of the Facebook users has not even realised the scandal in full scale. They're not going anywhere, they're going to continue as is, since there really is not alternative for Facebook right now and tbh they would…

Every company's destiny is decided by revenue and profit. Facebook will be fine as long as the advertising money keeps coming in. Will it? I don't see why not. Companies don't care about user privacy.

Companies do care about being associated with negative PR, though.

Plus, how effective is the advertising in motivating purchase versus sowing seeds of discontent?

It has utility, yes, but what the majority seem to consider, "not good".

Re: Facebook denies it collects call and SMS data from phones without permission

#219
post #205

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm still completely convinced that this whole scandal will not damage Facebook a bit, in the long term. Yeah, the stock is going to be a bit lower for some weeks, some people will leave, but the largest part of the Facebook users has not even realised the scandal in full scale. They're not going anywhere, they're going to continue as is, since there really is not alternative for Facebook right now and tbh they would…

Anecdote here: I was talking to a college student who hadn’t heard about the whole Cambridge Analytica to-do. Why? She uses Facebook to check the news, and unsurprisingly it wasn’t coming up on trending news.

It came up a lot on my newsfeed, including the post by Mark Zuckerberg about it which went viral https://www.facebook.com/zuck/posts/10104712037900071

Is your friend into tech news a lot? If not maybe that's why it wasn't shown. The only people I know who care about this story are tech people.

Re: Facebook denies it collects call and SMS data from phones without permission

#220

I think we are talking differently about this permission concept. Legally yes, they had permission. But the fact that they used those dark ux patterns to request that permission should not be forgotten. Even though legally they are in the right, we as users should make this fact irrelevant and just abandon the platform. Let them be right, let them win the argument but lose the battle with the general public.

I'm still completely convinced that this whole scandal will not damage Facebook a bit, in the long term. Yeah, the stock is going to be a bit lower for some weeks, some people will leave, but the largest part of the Facebook users has not even realised the scandal in full scale. They're not going anywhere, they're going to continue as is, since there really is not alternative for Facebook right now and tbh they would…

I don't have a single non-technical friend who cares. Theyve assumed FB has been doing this all along and that's just the tradeoff for using the service. To that end they're not wrong.
Post reply on HN