This is such a well crafted statement not from Zuck's heart but from a PR team that has been working over time. Shame on you FB and Zuck you Suck. If they are so honest or like to be honest going forward why can't they make it easy to see all my pics and posts that are public? Why can't they make it easy to see who can see what I posted? Which app or user is using my data. They have billions of dollars and can't impl…
A better question is, why aren't you using a decentralized, open-source alternative to Facebook today?
Zuckerberg on Cambridge Analytica situation
291–300 of 583 posts
Re: Zuckerberg on Cambridge Analytica situation
#292Earlier quoted context omitted.
The UI could be a web page, mobile app, etc just like FB.com. But to see any user data you would actually have to be authorized as that specific user. I.E. a developer could test their app by logging in with their own FB account and using their own data but would have no capability to look at the raw DB entries of other users. Or perhaps their could be a limited capability for developers to log in to their app as ano…
Hm, the catch here is something like this could happen: +--------------+ +----------+ +--------------+ | | | | | | | other server | | Server | | other server | | | | | | | +-------+------+ +----+-----+ +-------+------+ ^ | ^ | | | | http request | | containing user | | data for UI | http request made | rouge http request with a legit purpose | sending the user data say fetching assets v to some other server | +------…
Re: Zuckerberg on Cambridge Analytica situation
#293The trusting developers not to sell any data but putting zero safeguards in place to prevent this and extremely punitive repercussions despite being repeatedly told by the public, media, and even high level employees tells me Facebook can't plead ignorance to this and they not only knew this was happening, but they probably intended for it to happen. They knew it was illegal but put all the incentives for companies n…
What about the punishment to Christopher Wylie, by closing/suspending his accounts in facebook, whatsapp, etc ?
Re: Zuckerberg on Cambridge Analytica situation
#294Earlier quoted context omitted.
The UI could be a web page, mobile app, etc just like FB.com. But to see any user data you would actually have to be authorized as that specific user. I.E. a developer could test their app by logging in with their own FB account and using their own data but would have no capability to look at the raw DB entries of other users. Or perhaps their could be a limited capability for developers to log in to their app as ano…
Hm, the catch here is something like this could happen: +--------------+ +----------+ +--------------+ | | | | | | | other server | | Server | | other server | | | | | | | +-------+------+ +----+-----+ +-------+------+ ^ | ^ | | | | http request | | containing user | | data for UI | http request made | rouge http request with a legit purpose | sending the user data say fetching assets v to some other server | +------…
All of this tends to trade one problem for another, though: the user no longer has to worry that the third-party app has access to their Facebook data. But now the user has to worry that Facebook has access to their third-party app data.
Re: Zuckerberg on Cambridge Analytica situation
#295I am skeptical of Facebook's ability "guarantee" that a third party developer has not cached any data. I would equate this to finding all N needles in a haystack of size M where M >> N; it's just not a feasible task to complete. Even if you find N-1 needles, the last needle can be used as a sort of "mold" to reproduce all N-1 needles. My "golden rule" for the internet is: Once you give up information, assume it's everywhere and impossible to rescind.
I believe this statement will be eaten up by the press, and Facebook will continue to carry on its operations as if nothing happened. The stock will probably recover, and we'll go back to square one. Give it a few weeks.
The true demise of Facebook requires several things to happen simultaneously; a resonance of perfect conditions, so to speak. You've probably heard that Einstein and Newton discovered their theories because "they were decently smart men in the right place at the right time". A similar effect is also true here. If we want to see Facebook's demise, the world must have a suitable alternative in place, one which already has a critical mass. Until then, Facebook has a monopoly on attention and they will keep it as long as they are producing enough positive externality.
Re: Zuckerberg on Cambridge Analytica situation
#296This is such a well crafted statement not from Zuck's heart but from a PR team that has been working over time. Shame on you FB and Zuck you Suck. If they are so honest or like to be honest going forward why can't they make it easy to see all my pics and posts that are public? Why can't they make it easy to see who can see what I posted? Which app or user is using my data. They have billions of dollars and can't impl…
https://techcrunch.com/2017/10/20/robert-scoble-has-allegedl...
Re: Zuckerberg on Cambridge Analytica situation
#297Re: Zuckerberg on Cambridge Analytica situation
#298This is such a well crafted statement not from Zuck's heart but from a PR team that has been working over time. Shame on you FB and Zuck you Suck. If they are so honest or like to be honest going forward why can't they make it easy to see all my pics and posts that are public? Why can't they make it easy to see who can see what I posted? Which app or user is using my data. They have billions of dollars and can't impl…
You can do all of that... trivially. As you say, those are simple features. Ones they implemented years ago. Perhaps you should be more specific about what you're asking for?
Re: Zuckerberg on Cambridge Analytica situation
#2991000 word statement. Number of times the word "advertising" was mentioned: 0 Facebook continues to pretend it's business model is unicorns and kittens, not selling user data for money.
Who doesn't know Facebook sells targeted ads?
Re: Zuckerberg on Cambridge Analytica situation
#300And Facebook is not that bad. You can use Facebook with a fake name and without a phone number. But for example in Russia social network sites require a phone number to register. They have much more to leak.