Live data from Hacker News

The Gender Earnings Gap: Evidence from Over a Million Rideshare Drivers [pdf]

web.stanford.edu

31–40 of 59 posts

Re: The Gender Earnings Gap: Evidence from Over a Million Rideshare Drivers [pdf]

#31
post #24
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well obviously if the choices were simply "Push button A to get money, or push button B to get more money" then everyone would push button B. But in reality there are other factors. Like "button B has a slightly higher chance of injuring you". Or "button B can only be pushed late at night". It's entirely possible that people are biologically programmed to have different risk/effort/reward preference curves.

You've hit the nail on the head with "button B can only be pushed at night". If we set up society such that it's riskier for one group to access good earning potential, basically the definition of systemic bias. To be more concrete here, if it's unsafe for women to drive uber at 2am on a Friday night because of the risk of assault, that's systemic bias (and it should be fixed).

[deleted]

Re: The Gender Earnings Gap: Evidence from Over a Million Rideshare Drivers [pdf]

#32
post #24
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well obviously if the choices were simply "Push button A to get money, or push button B to get more money" then everyone would push button B. But in reality there are other factors. Like "button B has a slightly higher chance of injuring you". Or "button B can only be pushed late at night". It's entirely possible that people are biologically programmed to have different risk/effort/reward preference curves.

You've hit the nail on the head with "button B can only be pushed at night". If we set up society such that it's riskier for one group to access good earning potential, basically the definition of systemic bias. To be more concrete here, if it's unsafe for women to drive uber at 2am on a Friday night because of the risk of assault, that's systemic bias (and it should be fixed).

If there were no incentive to do the riskier, arguably more critical jobs...then nobody would do them.

Re: The Gender Earnings Gap: Evidence from Over a Million Rideshare Drivers [pdf]

#33
post #2

This is interesting. What interventions can be made to reduce this pay gap? With the reasons in the paper, should this gap be corrected (eg, force maximum speed, pay higher for slow drivers but only gender specific, etc etc).

Better protections for female drivers that make them less likely stop driving for Uber. For example having an option to favor Women or only pickup women, or only pickup women and men with a high rating, etc so that they can feel more safe driving for Uber. If a female Uber driver has controls that allow her to stay out driving longer than she would normally be comfortable with, she can generate higher earnings and close some of that gap.

Re: The Gender Earnings Gap: Evidence from Over a Million Rideshare Drivers [pdf]

#34
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>I don't see how you could do this without rewarding inefficiency and inexperience. It's easy though. Just pay women more. Uber can take a smaller cut of your pay if you have two x chromosomes. Another approach would be to allow passengers to chose their driver's gender. More passengers will chose female over male drivers.

That's wage discrimination and is illegal.

And paying women less is legal?

https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/types/equalcompensation.cfm

"The Equal Pay Act requires that men and women in the same workplace be given equal pay for equal work."

"If there is an inequality in wages between men and women, employers may not reduce the wages of either sex to equalize their pay."

Seems pretty straightforward. Pay has to be equal. Can't lower wages. Therefore, pay women more. Easy as pie.

Re: The Gender Earnings Gap: Evidence from Over a Million Rideshare Drivers [pdf]

#35
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's wage discrimination and is illegal.

And paying women less is legal? https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/types/equalcompensation.cfm "The Equal Pay Act requires that men and women in the same workplace be given equal pay for equal work." "If there is an inequality in wages between men and women, employers may not reduce the wages of either sex to equalize their pay." Seems pretty straightforward. Pay has to be equal. Can't lower wages. Therefore, pay women more.…

"for equal work" you missed the most important line. This paper is showing that they are not doing equal work. Not time wise nor trip wise.

Re: The Gender Earnings Gap: Evidence from Over a Million Rideshare Drivers [pdf]

#36

"Furthermore, while Uber now allows riders to tip their drivers in-app, this did not become available until June 2017, which is outside the scope of our data. We do not believe that cash tips – which were possible before in-app tipping – had a material impact on driver earnings." The study did not have any actual tip data for drivers. Tipping was always an option in Uber before June 2017, it just became mandatory for…

> Tipping was always an option in Uber before June 2017, it just became mandatory for the app to ask a user after each ride.

That's not true, tipping was not possible in the app, at all.

Re: The Gender Earnings Gap: Evidence from Over a Million Rideshare Drivers [pdf]

#37
post #35
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And paying women less is legal? https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/types/equalcompensation.cfm "The Equal Pay Act requires that men and women in the same workplace be given equal pay for equal work." "If there is an inequality in wages between men and women, employers may not reduce the wages of either sex to equalize their pay." Seems pretty straightforward. Pay has to be equal. Can't lower wages. Therefore, pay women more.…

"for equal work" you missed the most important line. This paper is showing that they are not doing equal work. Not time wise nor trip wise.

Women are making less money driving the same amount of time. The easiest fix is to pay women more. The technical fix is to auto report speeders (mostly men) to the cops for automated tickets. Since we're all about upholding the law here, Uber knows they are speeding and putting people at risk for a few bucks. Uber should report them to the authorities for proper penalties.

Re: The Gender Earnings Gap: Evidence from Over a Million Rideshare Drivers [pdf]

#38
post #37
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"for equal work" you missed the most important line. This paper is showing that they are not doing equal work. Not time wise nor trip wise.

Women are making less money driving the same amount of time. The easiest fix is to pay women more. The technical fix is to auto report speeders (mostly men) to the cops for automated tickets. Since we're all about upholding the law here, Uber knows they are speeding and putting people at risk for a few bucks. Uber should report them to the authorities for proper penalties.

You really should read the paper. One of the factors influencing their pay is the amount of time spent driving, so no, they are not "driving the same amount of time". Secondly, nowhere does it say they are going above the speed limit only that they drive speedier.

Re: The Gender Earnings Gap: Evidence from Over a Million Rideshare Drivers [pdf]

#39
post #12

So the service can be unbiased, but the society/system it exists in will still be biased.

So location, work experience, and driving speed are gender biased? Those are all free choices which depend entirely on the driver. As others have noted, women tend to earn more from tips in general, which are poorly represented in this study. So women will actually earn more than the study has indicated, and claims to have fully identified with those three points. Thus women actually appear to probably earn at the very least their fair share - or perhaps even more - when tips are taken into account.

Re: The Gender Earnings Gap: Evidence from Over a Million Rideshare Drivers [pdf]

#40
post #38
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Women are making less money driving the same amount of time. The easiest fix is to pay women more. The technical fix is to auto report speeders (mostly men) to the cops for automated tickets. Since we're all about upholding the law here, Uber knows they are speeding and putting people at risk for a few bucks. Uber should report them to the authorities for proper penalties.

You really should read the paper. One of the factors influencing their pay is the amount of time spent driving, so no, they are not "driving the same amount of time". Secondly, nowhere does it say they are going above the speed limit only that they drive speedier.

An hour in the car is an hour in the car. It's the same amount of time. I'm not saying that women spend more hours in the car than men. Don't be deliberately obtuse.

According to the paper, 50% of the wage gap is due to driving speed alone. The conclusion is that men are speeding more frequently than women. To level the playing field, all speeders could be auto reported to the proper authorities.

Or, you know, just pay women more. It's a non-technical solution which requires no programming.

Personally, I'd like to see Uber speeders reported/ticketed automatically. Uber is hiding evidence of institutionalized crime from the authorities, again. It's an old story at this point.

Post reply on HN