Live data from Hacker News

Nanopore MinION – $1k solid-state DNA sequencers

nanoporetech.com

11–20 of 111 posts

Re: Nanopore MinION – $1k solid-state DNA sequencers

#11
post #6
post #5

How much are the flow cells?

Ah. ~$500 - $1000 each. That seems like an expensive consumable, but I have no basis for comparison. Is this a lot? https://store.nanoporetech.com/flowcells.html

The washing procedure is a simple 2-step process and the kit contains buffers to remove the previous library and equilibrate for reuse or storage. There are sufficient reagents supplied for 12 washes.

https://store.nanoporetech.com/catalog/product/view/id/122/s...

Re: Nanopore MinION – $1k solid-state DNA sequencers

#12
post #2

Wow. Can I do whole-genome sequencing with this? Is this a similar product/result as buying whole genome sequencing from an established company for the $500 to $800 they charge these days?

You're buying a service for the 500-800$. Here you're buying a flowcell for 1000$ (the "sequencer" is more or less free). The technology is pretty different and a lot more bleeding edge. If what you want is just a genome aligned to a known reference and you can wait a few days then this is not what you want.

We use ONT's minION for strange niche stuff, where either the DNA prep method matters or the latency (the time from loading to the first data out of the machine) matters. Read quality is typically not as good as illumina, so for applications where we need quality we stick with the NextSeq. There's no reason to think nanopore technology won't get better though, but for now, if you've got the money illumina is still the way to go most of the time.

Re: Nanopore MinION – $1k solid-state DNA sequencers

#14
post #2

Wow. Can I do whole-genome sequencing with this? Is this a similar product/result as buying whole genome sequencing from an established company for the $500 to $800 they charge these days?

There is a good reply to you that is currently dead for some reason, so I’m reposting it here for people who don’t have dead visible:

> You're buying a service for the 500-800$. Here you're buying a flowcell for 1000$ (the "sequencer" is more or less free). The technology is pretty different and a lot more bleeding edge. If what you want is just a genome aligned to a known reference and you can wait a few days then this is not what you want. We use ONT's minION for strange niche stuff, where either the DNA prep method matters or the latency (the time from loading to the first data out of the machine) matters. Read quality is typically not as good as illumina, so for applications where we need quality we stick with the NextSeq. There's no reason to think nanopore technology won't get better though, but for now, if you've got the money illumina is still the way to go most of the time. >

Re: Nanopore MinION – $1k solid-state DNA sequencers

#15
post #9

I remember looking into this device before, but as I recall it was intended for small bacterial genomes. A quick Google turns up that a paper using the device to sequence a human genome has only just been published [0] hence the update to the website. I'm not at all familiar with the technology, but doesn't the fact that experts have only just now been able to sequence human DNA mean it would be pretty unlikely the d…

Human dna is not particularly special except there's so much of it relative to bacteria and also the sequencing method is stochastic.

Re: Nanopore MinION – $1k solid-state DNA sequencers

#16
post #9

I remember looking into this device before, but as I recall it was intended for small bacterial genomes. A quick Google turns up that a paper using the device to sequence a human genome has only just been published [0] hence the update to the website. I'm not at all familiar with the technology, but doesn't the fact that experts have only just now been able to sequence human DNA mean it would be pretty unlikely the d…

A few years ago, the sequencing field was really excited for this platform as an alternative/competitor to Illumina. Unfortunately, the MinION platform has never been able to generate enough high-quality data for most eukaryotic sequencing use cases. The MinION still has it's niche... long read sequencing can resolve problematic regions of the genome, and the minION is the only option for rapid sequencing in the field. For production genome sequencing centers though, Illumina's still the dominant tech. Their HiSeq X platform can put out a human genome right about $1k.

Re: Nanopore MinION – $1k solid-state DNA sequencers

#18
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ah. ~$500 - $1000 each. That seems like an expensive consumable, but I have no basis for comparison. Is this a lot? https://store.nanoporetech.com/flowcells.html

The washing procedure is a simple 2-step process and the kit contains buffers to remove the previous library and equilibrate for reuse or storage. There are sufficient reagents supplied for 12 washes. https://store.nanoporetech.com/catalog/product/view/id/122/s...

The flowcell is a consumable. You can run it for ~2 days on average. You can wash it out and run other samples during the 2 days if you want, but it will stop working after ~2 days of running.

And in my experience, the washing buffer doesn't do a great job. I read somewhere there is ~10% carryover.

Re: Nanopore MinION – $1k solid-state DNA sequencers

#20
post #8

I just ran a couple of flowcells last week. I've ran 8 total so far now. My impression is that it can be very inconsistent depending on the quality of the flowcell that they send you and your DNA prep. Great for smallish genomes (bacteria), not enough throughput/quality for large eukaryotic genomes (1gb+) unless you got money to burn.

$1,000 for the starter pack - what kind of use can you get out of that, and how much are the ongoing costs for the flowcells and anything else that needs to be replenished?

Are you using it for fun? professionally? academically?

Post reply on HN