Live data from Hacker News

Why People Dislike Really Smart Leaders

scientificamerican.com

241–250 of 336 posts

Re: Why People Dislike Really Smart Leaders

#241

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> That's just run of the mill anti-intellectualism. Respectfully, you just dismissed an entire school of economic thought out of hand.

Which school in particular?

Von Mises, which is notoriously anti-empirical (which is close to, but not quite the same as, anti-intellectualism).

Re: Why People Dislike Really Smart Leaders

#242
post #40

Related: 'George W. Bush is smarter than you'. Elite leaders often make themselves look dumber than they really are. https://keithhennessey.com/2013/04/24/smarter/

He’s a Fool that cannot conceal his Wisdom. — Benjamin Franklin

> Related: 'George W. Bush is smarter than you'.

While it may be in vogue to flaunt intelligence in certain professional circles, many, including Bill Gates define "smart" as "an elusive concept. There’s a certain sharpness, an ability to absorb new facts. To walk into a situation, have something explained to you and immediately say, 'Well, what about this?' To ask an insightful question. To absorb it in real time. A capacity to remember. To relate to domains that may not seem connected at first. A certain creativity that allows people to be effective."

https://www.thejournal.ie/bill-gates-top-quotes-690230-Dec20...

According to many intelligence officials and former advisors, Bush perfectly fits Bill Gates definition of being incredibly intelligent. The reality is, just because a leader hasn't convinced you of their abilities, that in no way detracts from them.

Re: Why People Dislike Really Smart Leaders

#243

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Trump's whole persona is about winning brashly and bigly. It's ludicrous to think that he entered a race he didn't intend to win. > If the recent book is to be believed at all It isn't to be believed, literally at all. http://thehill.com/opinion/white-house/367902-dont-believe-m... https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2018/01/03/mi...

"by Sebastian Gorka" Yeah, no thanks. I'll believe 100% of the book before I believe 0.01% of what Gorka spouts.

Well that’s silly, but you also chose to ignore the other link.

Re: Why People Dislike Really Smart Leaders

#244
post #129

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People who "hate politics" tend to create a lot of it. Being politically savvy/expedient is as much about knowing how to get along with people as it is getting what you want.

> People who "hate politics" tend to create a lot of it. There is a reason for that. Politics is basically the process of pasting kludges together until the net result is something that no powerful group hates enough to be willing to smash it all to smithereens with a sledgehammer. But if you objectively look at any of the kludges individually, or even the overall result after a few years, it's a horrific mess. A hor…

Lot of black and white, 1+1=2 type statements here. Politics is about dealing with uncertainity and ambiguity. The real world is full of it. If your parents can't stand each other but tomorrow you get cancer and this dsyfunctional unit has to deal politics applies. Good politics makes things better.

Writing down on a piece of paper - these truths are self evident that all men are created equal does not make it so in the real world. That's an example of ambiguity. There is no question of smashing things up and hitting a reset button when dealing with ambiguity. Here too good politics applies cause everyone in the room knows the statement is false but good politics can bring everyone into the room and keep them there and make them decide they are going to change the "truth".

Young people like you, aren't exposed to ambiguity or expected to solve ambiguities, cause you have enough on your plate accumulating knowledge about all the unambiguous stuff. It is easy for a young person to get it into his head, that all problems are pointless to work on if the text book is only filled with ambiguous problems. Which is why students textbooks aren't filled with them. The flip side is some students get it into their heads that all problems are unambiguous. They are the ones that misunderstand politics. Leave alone what good politics can do.

Re: Why People Dislike Really Smart Leaders

#245

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know. Why do we push files to production on a Friday evening? Why do we snipe hot-fixes into production via FTP? Because we are all crazy & lazy bums, I would guess.

> I don't know. Why do we push files to production on a Friday evening? Because we worked for the whole week on it and now want that other people can see it on their weekend. Since we are so proud of our work and trust in its quality, we are willing to do an extra shift on the weekend, should problems occur.

I feel this is an extremely selfish attitude, as generally it's not just the one who pushed into production who has to do extra work on the weekend, and usually they are not willing to do extra work because someone's ego couldn't wait 2 more days.

Re: Why People Dislike Really Smart Leaders

#246

If you are struggling with such issues, you might find some of the resources at Hoagies Gifted Page helpful. I don't read it myself anymore, in part because it is the smart version of poor little rich boy. In other words, it whines a lot about "Oh woe is me. I am so smart and it is ruining my life." But if you are having social challenges as a smart person, that isn't necessarily a bad thing to be exposed to. You can…

i never got the self pity vibe from hoagies' page. i felt it was more explanatory than comiserational. it's a great resource, though.

Re: Why People Dislike Really Smart Leaders

#247

>The study’s lead author, John Antonakis, a psychologist at the University of Lausanne in Switzerland, suggests leaders should use their intelligence to generate creative metaphors that will persuade and inspire others—the way former U.S. President Barack Obama did. “I think the only way a smart person can signal their intelligence appropriately and still connect with the people,” Antonakis says, “is to speak in char…

I think charisma is best used to signal a lack of intelligence. Someone else posted a link to a op-ed about GWB, but Trump follows a similar approach. Lots of people question his intelligence and decision-making ability, yet, every one of us hear or talk about him several times a day. He also has a political sleight-of-hand that I don't think has ever been matched. Every time a key policy decision is being debated, t…

[deleted]

Re: Why People Dislike Really Smart Leaders

#248

Earlier quoted context omitted.

this is a crock. it was a crock when it was written and it's still a crock now. the idea that someone can for 8 years in the spotlight disguise themselves so much so that appear wholly opposite is ludicrous. it takes months for professional actors to produce 90 minutes of performance - the guy was on camera for literally weeks. he's not "smarter than you" this kind of revisionist nonsense is politically motivated - p…

You don’t become president of the United States by accident.

No, it is not an accident. It is mostly a matter of money applied with some precision. Brand recognition helps.

Re: Why People Dislike Really Smart Leaders

#249
post #214

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And that's kind of scary. I don't want some average Joe I can relate to being the most powerful person in the world. I want someone smarter than me with a lot of solid political experience who knows how to navigate issues while being pragmatic enough to get stuff done. Being president of the US isn't like being a plumber.

If you believe this you will always get a technocrat with a great resume who has spent years enforcing the status quo, and, once elected, will do nothing to change it. If you want anything to be better you need to move away from gatekeeping "qualifications" because they are always bestowed upon proponents of business as usual by proponents of business as usual. What does "smart" mean? They went to Harvard and are the…

> Obama was brilliant and supremely qualified, how did that work out for us?

Would have worked better if the Republicans hadn't made it their singular goal to obstruct his presidency for 8 years.

Re: Why People Dislike Really Smart Leaders

#250
post #138

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People feel that leaders they can relate to are more likely to take their interests seriously.

It would be better to say, if a leader can relate to the people, then he may be more likely to take their interests seriously.

But is that true? Or do the campaign managers know that helps get their candidates elected?
Post reply on HN