Live data from Hacker News

Would you send your kids to school on a self driving schoolbus?

fastcodesign.com

11–20 of 59 posts

Re: Would you send your kids to school on a self driving schoolbus?

#11
I remember walking to school myself when I was six, and taking a regular city bus every day since age seven. It was fine, never had a problem really.

A self-driving bus from door to door would have been fun... But on the other hand, getting familiar with the city environment by walking was useful at that age too.

(This was in Finland. I know Americans don't really let their kids outside on their own anymore.)

Re: Would you send your kids to school on a self driving schoolbus?

#12

Lol. That schoolbus is is going to be in flames on the side of the road with 20 kids on it with no supervision.

I'm also in the no supervision would be a disaster boat, but just to clarify the concept bus only has 6 seats.

"The design was influenced by campfires and dinner tables, and it ensures there’s no one sitting behind anyone else–likely reduced hair pulling and teasing as a result."

Re: Would you send your kids to school on a self driving schoolbus?

#13
post #11

I remember walking to school myself when I was six, and taking a regular city bus every day since age seven. It was fine, never had a problem really. A self-driving bus from door to door would have been fun... But on the other hand, getting familiar with the city environment by walking was useful at that age too. (This was in Finland. I know Americans don't really let their kids outside on their own anymore.)

It was fine because there were adults around. 30 kids unsupervised would be chaos.

Re: Would you send your kids to school on a self driving schoolbus?

#14
post #11

I remember walking to school myself when I was six, and taking a regular city bus every day since age seven. It was fine, never had a problem really. A self-driving bus from door to door would have been fun... But on the other hand, getting familiar with the city environment by walking was useful at that age too. (This was in Finland. I know Americans don't really let their kids outside on their own anymore.)

It was fine because there were adults around. 30 kids unsupervised would be chaos.

Good point!

Re: Would you send your kids to school on a self driving schoolbus?

#15
post #5

Great self driving so the steward has 100% focus on the kids.

No steward in the plan? The plan is, cheaper than busses. Hiring an adult for every 5 kids (only 6 seats) is prohibitively more expensive than 1 for 60 in a regular bus. And volunteers don't work either - if they drove to school to ride along with the kids, why didn't they just drive them home themselves?

> And volunteers don't work either - if they drove to school to ride along with the kids, why didn't they just drive them home themselves?

Insurance and liability come to mind.

Re: Would you send your kids to school on a self driving schoolbus?

#16
post #12

Lol. That schoolbus is is going to be in flames on the side of the road with 20 kids on it with no supervision.

I'm also in the no supervision would be a disaster boat, but just to clarify the concept bus only has 6 seats. "The design was influenced by campfires and dinner tables, and it ensures there’s no one sitting behind anyone else–likely reduced hair pulling and teasing as a result."

Wow, these people have a monumental lack of how bad kids are. My 7 year-old son got beat up on the playground with the adults supervising. Last year, when he was in another scuffle with 3:1 odds I went in to visit the principal and she not only failed to reprimand the perpetrators but also made my son apologize to them! This is the world we live in where ethnic minorities are given a pass for bad behavior at everyone else's expense. Until we solve this societal issue, I don't think drones, robots, or self-driving vehicles are going anywhere because there's too many shit heels who willfully cause harm for fun.

Re: Would you send your kids to school on a self driving schoolbus?

#18
post #12

Lol. That schoolbus is is going to be in flames on the side of the road with 20 kids on it with no supervision.

I'm also in the no supervision would be a disaster boat, but just to clarify the concept bus only has 6 seats. "The design was influenced by campfires and dinner tables, and it ensures there’s no one sitting behind anyone else–likely reduced hair pulling and teasing as a result."

Sounds like a perfect torture chamber for that one kid who is a bully.

Re: Would you send your kids to school on a self driving schoolbus?

#19
post #7

Don't know how many people on HN have ever driven a school bus full of kids, but its a lot more than "Point A to Point B". Its fairly common for kids in K-6 to not know: - Home Address - Home/Parents Phone Number - Last Name (you'd be surprised at how common this was) Thats not to mention what to do in the event of an emergency. Just play out the follow events in your mind with a bus full of kids and no trained adult…

>- Last Name (you'd be surprised at how common this was)

How does this happen? Is knowing your surname just a weird European thing?

Re: Would you send your kids to school on a self driving schoolbus?

#20
This is missing the point. You can't leave children alone for a long time without supervision. There may be bullies, or they may bring a screwdriver and start pulling the bus apart, drink beer, stick chewing gum, piss on seats, leave trash. Someone has to keep them in check. What if kids refuse to leave and block the bus ?
Post reply on HN