Live data from Hacker News

How to Tell If You’re a Jerk

nautil.us

21–30 of 58 posts

Re: How to Tell If You’re a Jerk

#21
post #7

Sounds like a sociopath rather than a jerk. I hire sociopaths, fire jerks

I agree with this. There’s a difference, though it’s a fine line, between those who have jerky tendencies as the result of a highly focused or driven personality and those who derive enjoyment from just being a jerk.

Re: How to Tell If You’re a Jerk

#22

Depending on who you talk to I am either unreadable, a jerk, a creep, insanely nice, demanding, nit-picky, angry, obsessive, or one of a myriad other things. I think it's definitely possible to be a well liked jerk.

And perhaps, manic.

Oh definitely manic.

Re: How to Tell If You’re a Jerk

#23

I recently had a baby, and the self-realization that I am a jerk became very clear when I thought about the world. Let me explain: From a young age, growing up in Queens, I quickly learned the value of being a jerk/asshole as a deterrent for getting "jumped" for my jacket/sneakers. The idea was: kids mugging other kids would go for easy targets. Even an inkling of belief that someone would put up a fight was a disinc…

You don't have to be assertive to be a jerk... ...in fact, I'd say it's the people who correlate assertiveness with jerkiness that are in fact most often jerks.

Would love to hear more about why you think that.

Re: How to Tell If You’re a Jerk

#25

Depending on who you talk to I am either unreadable, a jerk, a creep, insanely nice, demanding, nit-picky, angry, obsessive, or one of a myriad other things. I think it's definitely possible to be a well liked jerk.

I've read some research that suggests that certain characteristics--namely agreeableness--are more relationship-specific than others.

For example:

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0092656616...

That meta-analysis shows that rather-specific variance is greatest for agreeableness, although that is misleading (in an underestimating kind of way) because what you really want to know is the target-rater interaction variance, which is often not studied because it requires a lot of combinations of targets and raters. What I remember (and I might be incorrect) is that in such studies, there's also a lot of relationship-specific variance for agreeableness.

The papers I've read by Vazire ignores this interaction variance and focuses on agreement across traits. The interaction variance is implied, though, by the huge amount of variance not accounted by target or rater.

The takeaway message is that there will be a lot of disagreement for most people about who thinks who is a jerk.

Re: How to Tell If You’re a Jerk

#26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You don't have to be assertive to be a jerk... ...in fact, I'd say it's the people who correlate assertiveness with jerkiness that are in fact most often jerks.

Would love to hear more about why you think that.

Well, the "nice guys", who often get upset that women go after the aggressive/manly/"jerk" guys instead of them, and who secretly do believe that women owe them something, would generally be considered jerks. However, few would ascribe aggression as a trait of theirs.

Re: How to Tell If You’re a Jerk

#27
post #8

I know that I used to be a jerk quite often in the past looking back at my own behavior. It has never been intentional, I simply did not think about it. Don't know about my current jerkiness I think one needs outside perspective to really judge that.

I would say that one does not need to intentionally be a jerk to be one. As you said, all it takes is to simply not think of how your actions affect others.

Re: How to Tell If You’re a Jerk

#28

Interesting tidbit: Sweethearts also seem clueless to the presence of jerks, offering concessions to, and excuses for jerk behavior. Question: what's with jerks teaming up? How does jerk signaling work, such that it attracts jerks-of-a-feather, when jerks in the wild are found joining forces?

A theory of Jerkodynamics: The only people who will hang around jerks tend to either be other jerks with the same problem, or people too insanely nice to set boundaries and tell the jerks to get bent.

Re: How to Tell If You’re a Jerk

#29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I like Burroughs' take on the matter: "Don't be such a shit that you don't know you are one."

"A gentleman is never unintentionally rude"?

Someone once told me how polite I was even when being an asshole. I took that as a high compliment.
Post reply on HN