Live data from Hacker News

The underground world of Singapore

yp.sg

31–40 of 78 posts

Re: The underground world of Singapore

#31
post #19

As cool as this is, I think the space savings is a red herring. There's still plenty of undeveloped land in SG, and lots of low rise buildings. A combination of well placed subway stops, transitioning some low-rise apartments to high rise, avoiding excessive road/parking space and generally competent urban planning should be enough to accommodate Singapore's burgeoning population without the need for mole people. Its…

I'm not sure where you get that idea. There isn't plenty of undeveloped land unless you're talking about jurong or punggol, and it doesn't help if those places take 2 or so hours to commute to downtown from on the MRT. If you're talking about the small patches of parks and the historic heritage sites , I think they have their reasons for keeping those.

Either way, I'd argue that you need some parks and forests, or your populace will go insane. 20 or so golf courses in such a small and dense island are ridiculous, though.

Re: The underground world of Singapore

#32
post #15

Is it not a problem that Singapore is right on the ocean? Does anyone know if there risk of flooding or anything?

Singapore is one of the few major populations on earth that is shielded from most natural disasters. It's also not near a fault line, so earthquakes, tropical storms, tsunamis are unlikely to affect it. Major flooding can occur due to rains, however. The city has dealt with it in the past and seems to have that under control. The other major disaster that hits Singapore frequently throughout every year is the "haze"…

What about water level rising due to climate change?

Re: The underground world of Singapore

#33
post #14

I was similarly impressed by the gigantic underground systems in Montreal. Many people go for months during the winter time never going above ground, working, shopping and living all inside the interconnected underground shopping malls businesses etc.

Calgary too. There was an entire movie made that centers around a group of workers who make a bet for who can go the longest without ever going outdoors: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waydowntown

Re: The underground world of Singapore

#34
post #12
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When I visited I tried to walk ONE subway stop outside in DECEMBER. I almost fainted halfway through and had to sit down and drink water. Almost ended up calling an Uber.

Months don't matter. In that region, the weather is always the same 2 variants year round: Hot & Humid and Hot, Humid & Raining.

This is the most important point, but also Singapore is in the southern hemisphere (barely), so December is technically spring/summer as well.

Re: The underground world of Singapore

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Singapore is one of the few major populations on earth that is shielded from most natural disasters. It's also not near a fault line, so earthquakes, tropical storms, tsunamis are unlikely to affect it. Major flooding can occur due to rains, however. The city has dealt with it in the past and seems to have that under control. The other major disaster that hits Singapore frequently throughout every year is the "haze"…

What about water level rising due to climate change?

They're working on improving seawalls and rock slopes. [0]

[0] http://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/as-sea-levels-rise-sin...

Re: The underground world of Singapore

#36
post #19

As cool as this is, I think the space savings is a red herring. There's still plenty of undeveloped land in SG, and lots of low rise buildings. A combination of well placed subway stops, transitioning some low-rise apartments to high rise, avoiding excessive road/parking space and generally competent urban planning should be enough to accommodate Singapore's burgeoning population without the need for mole people. Its…

The most valuable space is the blank space on Singapore - the catchment areas are fabulous places to go hike and the island would be a nightmare without them.

Re: The underground world of Singapore

#37
post #14

I was similarly impressed by the gigantic underground systems in Montreal. Many people go for months during the winter time never going above ground, working, shopping and living all inside the interconnected underground shopping malls businesses etc.

Toronto's underground system is the largest one in the world. 1200 retail locations, 30km long, 4M sq feet of retail space. It's very nice, all marble or polished stone everywhere, brightly lit, good food courts. Many many food courts. Almost all of it privately maintained and owned by each of the 50+ connected downtown towers and buildings.

In the summer, no one goes above ground it's too hot and humid. In the Winter it's too cold. For a few glorious weeks in Spring and Fall however, all the downtown residents and office workers find it hospitable to occasionally pop outside of their towers to enjoy the outdoors.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PATH_(Toronto)

Re: The underground world of Singapore

#39
post #37
post #14

I was similarly impressed by the gigantic underground systems in Montreal. Many people go for months during the winter time never going above ground, working, shopping and living all inside the interconnected underground shopping malls businesses etc.

Toronto's underground system is the largest one in the world. 1200 retail locations, 30km long, 4M sq feet of retail space. It's very nice, all marble or polished stone everywhere, brightly lit, good food courts. Many many food courts. Almost all of it privately maintained and owned by each of the 50+ connected downtown towers and buildings. In the summer, no one goes above ground it's too hot and humid. In the Winte…

Sounds like the kind of people that could stand living underground on Mars.

Re: The underground world of Singapore

#40
post #34
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Months don't matter. In that region, the weather is always the same 2 variants year round: Hot & Humid and Hot, Humid & Raining.

This is the most important point, but also Singapore is in the southern hemisphere (barely), so December is technically spring/summer as well.

Singapore is in the northern hemisphere. It's north(west) of Pontianak which is on the equator.
Post reply on HN