Live data from Hacker News

The underground world of Singapore

yp.sg

11–20 of 78 posts

Re: The underground world of Singapore

#11
post #7

I could see Singapore building an air conditioned dome over the whole city. Besides the nonfree press, etc, the relentless heat and humidity is the biggest negative of the city.

When I visited I tried to walk ONE subway stop outside in DECEMBER. I almost fainted halfway through and had to sit down and drink water. Almost ended up calling an Uber.

Re: The underground world of Singapore

#12
post #11
post #7

I could see Singapore building an air conditioned dome over the whole city. Besides the nonfree press, etc, the relentless heat and humidity is the biggest negative of the city.

When I visited I tried to walk ONE subway stop outside in DECEMBER. I almost fainted halfway through and had to sit down and drink water. Almost ended up calling an Uber.

Months don't matter. In that region, the weather is always the same 2 variants year round: Hot & Humid and Hot, Humid & Raining.

Re: The underground world of Singapore

#13
That is cool. Would be great to have a "Common Service Tunnel" in all cities. Its insane how much roadway gets dug up each year. Of course I doubt they'd all be as clean as the one in the Singapore photo.

Re: The underground world of Singapore

#14
I was similarly impressed by the gigantic underground systems in Montreal. Many people go for months during the winter time never going above ground, working, shopping and living all inside the interconnected underground shopping malls businesses etc.

Re: The underground world of Singapore

#16
post #7

I could see Singapore building an air conditioned dome over the whole city. Besides the nonfree press, etc, the relentless heat and humidity is the biggest negative of the city.

> Singapore building an air conditioned dome over the whole city

By the time they build it, it won't just be for aircon, but also to purify the air coming in from outside. It'll also be nice to do without the rain. Singapore with a dome is probably what the first moon bases will look like.

Re: The underground world of Singapore

#17
post #8
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's funny: over in the comments about a healthcare article they say that Singapore has it easier because it's smaller. And here we admire them for pulling things off despite being small.

I didnt read those comments, but large capital projects one would think is harder, since they collect less overall revenue. For example its hard to imagine singapore sending a person to mars, over say China or US other things, especially people related, are much easier. its very close together, very homogeneous, etc.

[deleted]

Re: The underground world of Singapore

#18
post #13

That is cool. Would be great to have a "Common Service Tunnel" in all cities. Its insane how much roadway gets dug up each year. Of course I doubt they'd all be as clean as the one in the Singapore photo.

It's the advantage you get when your city's development occurs after centuries of experience of others, you can improve on the mistakes every other metropolis made. The same is true of sg's transit system, roads, etc.

Re: The underground world of Singapore

#19
As cool as this is, I think the space savings is a red herring. There's still plenty of undeveloped land in SG, and lots of low rise buildings. A combination of well placed subway stops, transitioning some low-rise apartments to high rise, avoiding excessive road/parking space and generally competent urban planning should be enough to accommodate Singapore's burgeoning population without the need for mole people. Its always cheaper and easier to build up and out than to dig down.

Re: The underground world of Singapore

#20
post #15

Is it not a problem that Singapore is right on the ocean? Does anyone know if there risk of flooding or anything?

Not really. Singapore is on the equator and surrounded by large landmasses (Malaya, Sumatra, Borneo, Java) on all sides, so it's never in the path of cyclones/typhoons and is shielded from tsunamis as well.
Post reply on HN