Live data from Hacker News

Apple to hold iPhone 4 press conference on Friday

loopinsight.com

51–60 of 80 posts

Re: Apple to hold iPhone 4 press conference on Friday

#51

I'm guessing admit full fault and a return/exchange of iPhone4. Oh, and one more thing -- new MacPro and iMacs! Making the iPhone recall a non-event, in terms of news and stock price :-)

why was this downvoted? this is a relevant and productive comment

Re: Apple to hold iPhone 4 press conference on Friday

#53

I think this thing is ridiculous. My iPhone 4 so far has better reception of all the previous models for me (I owned all of them)

maybe it seems like that because they're faking the bars that display the reception? http://www.apple.com/pr/library/2010/07/02appleletter.html

Re: Apple to hold iPhone 4 press conference on Friday

#54
post #50
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's common knowledge that Apple's rubber bumpers are a workaround for the antenna problem. But you shouldn't have to buy a $30 case for your $200 phone just for the privilege of making calls reliably.

You don't. On day one, my wife spent a couple minutes covering the gap with a piece of scotch tape. It's almost impossible to see and it worked flawlessly. Anyone who drops $30 just to solve the antenna issue is either lazy or a fool or a foolish lazy person or a loolish fazy person.

Or someone who doesn't like mucky Scotch tape on their brand-new high-tech device? I don't care, but I know plenty of people who buy the iPhone as a design statement & I can see how that tiny imperfection could infuriate these types of people.

Re: Apple to hold iPhone 4 press conference on Friday

#55
Free bumpers seems unlikely to me: wouldn't it make iPhone 4 owners a laughing stock? Here you are with a super-sleek 800$ device, and then you are forced to deface it with an ugly rubber case. I think that solution would contradict Apple's supposed dedication to perfection.

Re: Apple to hold iPhone 4 press conference on Friday

#56

I'm guessing admit full fault and a return/exchange of iPhone4. Oh, and one more thing -- new MacPro and iMacs! Making the iPhone recall a non-event, in terms of news and stock price :-)

An iPhone recall would never be a non-event, especially in stock price.

Re: Apple to hold iPhone 4 press conference on Friday

#57
post #28
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think they are going to own up. I mean, even Microsoft called iPhone4 "Apple's Vista moment". Steve must have spit his coffee out and said "Oh crap! I have to make this right". Anyway, that is what I am hoping.

By owning up, they are not making it right. Owning up is for the mediocre 90% of the pack. Apple lives and dies by its perfectionist reputation, and "owning up" would shatter that asset. They will most likely announce something big to change the conversation, as someone else already mentioned. This way, they'll make us forget us fast, and this will be making it right for them.

I thought that by definition being a perfectionist means being cognizant of your mistakes. . . At the moment not owning up is making that asset a little toxic: "Apple think they're perfectionists but that's just because they don't acknowledge their mistakes" seems to be floating around right now

Re: Apple to hold iPhone 4 press conference on Friday

#58
post #39

Another interesting theory from Dan Rubin: $10 says Friday's Apple press conference is the announcement about Verizon, to — in the words of Don Draper — change the conversation. http://twitter.com/danrubin/status/18565906020 While probably not too likely, it would be an interesting move on Apple's part none the less.

Apple will wait until Verizon goes LTE. The lost market is not a large enough incentive to make a phone that will only work on a few carriers. My guess is June 2011 or maybe June 2012.

I think you may be correct. The reason I say this is that Bell Canada and Telus upgraded their entire network across the country this past year just to be compatible with the iPhone and other GSM phones (but primarily they were motivated by the iPhone). I can't help but think they would be privy to information on any sort of CDMA compatible iPhone before they made this decision. Certainly I don't think their upgrade would have been worth it just to get the iPhone a year ahead of time.

Re: Apple to hold iPhone 4 press conference on Friday

#59
post #7

Wow. This is unprecedented. What are they going to do? 60 day return period with no restocking fee? Free bumpers for everyone?

My wild guess: $50 gift certificate until the manufactured units have a mitigating change. At that point, a limited period of swap-ups if requested.

Since I've yet to encounter the problem, that would make me pretty happy. But for the same reason, I struggle to believe they'd be that generous.

Re: Apple to hold iPhone 4 press conference on Friday

#60
post #9

As long as Apple holds it the right way, the press conference will work correctly.

I know I'm not supposed to say this because my account is less than a year old but this thread is definitely like being on Reddit. I actually like Reddit, I'm just not used to seeing these types of comments being upvoted so high on Hacker News.

Sorry, but the use of the verb "to hold" in connection to the iPhone4 made it too difficult to resist. I know snarky comments are not always well received here and generally agree they should never be the core of a discussion, but not many of us watch soap operas and companies like Apple and Microsoft, along with their Steves and Bills provides us with the missing drama.

A world without Apple would be a lot less interesting. In fact, I am convinced one of us would have no alternative but to invent it.

Post reply on HN