Live data from Hacker News

$1,000 per month cash handout would grow US economy by $2.5 trillion, study says

cnbc.com

51–52 of 52 posts

Re: $1,000 per month cash handout would grow US economy by $2.5 trillion, study says

#51
post #24
post #7

Do people actually believe this universal basic income nonsense? If money isn't scarce but goods are the goods become proportionally more expensive. Inflation is a thing.

Yup, inflation is a thing. Alaskans get Dividend checks every year -- almost $2k. Right after they get their checks, the price of everything skyrockets, on top of already extremely high prices for everything up there. The best time to spend the check is to wait until next year right before the checks are sent out to increase your buying power. If UBI made sense, Alaska would be a utopia. Not seeing it..

Horseshit. Prices of commodities are not affected by PFDs in any way.

Re: $1,000 per month cash handout would grow US economy by $2.5 trillion, study says

#52

Wait a minute, though: Every adult gets $1,000/month. That's $12,000/year. How many adults do we have? Well, the US population is 326,000,000. Median age is 37, so I'll guess that 3/4 of the population is "adult" (age >= 18). That means that paying this handout will cost $12,000/person * 244,500,000 people = $2.934 trillion. That's... not a net win.

How many make > 200k and will be paying 100% of that 1k back as a tax? maybe 30%? So you can cut that by 30%.

Do you honestly believe 30% of the US earn 200k a year? Where do you figure?
Post reply on HN