Live data from Hacker News

Switching to Android

chadfowler.com

51–60 of 62 posts

Re: Switching to Android

#51

Other then the fact that he says iTunes music is DRM'd (I don't think it is any more), I'd say this is a pretty fair review of the Android ecosystem. Edit: This is completely irrelevant, but Chad Fowler looks way different with shorter hair.

I have had an iPod since 2005 and have never purchased music from iTunes. You can purchase or rip music from anywhere and put it on any Apple device. eMusic and Amazon have been the main online music stores I have used. Many people seem to assume that Apple devices can only purchase music from Apple music stores but this has never been the case.

> You can purchase or rip music from anywhere and put it on any Apple device.

Unless it's in FLAC format.

Re: Switching to Android

#52
post #6

If I might go off on a tangent about one of his points I’ve been thinking a lot about this lately… “Speech recognition is actually useful. Big surprise here. I can tweet, search the web etc. with minor edits to my dictated text” For those who don’t know Android has a built in Voice Recognition API so any application can easily put use it for input while Apple has steadfastly refused to include this feature because “i…

I have never understood the appeal of speech-to-text on mobile phones. I don't want to sit next to someone on the train while they enunciate a long email or a text message to their girlfriend. Nor do I want to shout my own internet musings at those around me. Besides, these days most of us are used to editing as we write. Good PC dictation software makes that easy. On a mobile phone, you'll end up editing it by thumb…

When I am in the car driving, it is a great way to dictate notes to my self and others (to edit later), hands free. I end up forgetting some of those ideas when I don't get them recorded, and it's easier than going through audio recordings.

The cool thing about speech to text is that there seems to be a learning algorithm behind it, so it does just keep getting better.

Re: Switching to Android

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have never understood the appeal of speech-to-text on mobile phones. I don't want to sit next to someone on the train while they enunciate a long email or a text message to their girlfriend. Nor do I want to shout my own internet musings at those around me. Besides, these days most of us are used to editing as we write. Good PC dictation software makes that easy. On a mobile phone, you'll end up editing it by thumb…

>Yep, Android's has lots of cool features that iPhone has not, but a lot of its core functionality isn't fucking done. Like? I've had a G1 since launch, and I can't really agree with this sentiment. Yes, Android has had some very rough edges in terms of UI, but, if we're talking core functionality, I've never felt like anything was flat out unfinished. There've been a lot of things added iteratively over the last two…

If I was doing anything on my ADP1 when I got an incoming call, the phone would become completely unresponsive and quite warm to the touch while it tried to page out other activities in order to allow me to answer the phone.

Only about one time out of five did it actually finish whatever it was trying to do in time for me to answer the call.

Re: Switching to Android

#54
post #44
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Very interesting... ( http://www.swypeinc.com/ ) Requires touch-typing ability, as you hide a large amount of the display as you swype, but easily stands to be much more efficient than repeated jabbing, but it doesn't prevent specific, accurate input. I quite hope this takes over, it's a great idea.

Hmm, that looks a bit like Shapewriter for the iPhone.

Which is also available for Android :)

Re: Switching to Android

#55
post #6

If I might go off on a tangent about one of his points I’ve been thinking a lot about this lately… “Speech recognition is actually useful. Big surprise here. I can tweet, search the web etc. with minor edits to my dictated text” For those who don’t know Android has a built in Voice Recognition API so any application can easily put use it for input while Apple has steadfastly refused to include this feature because “i…

I have never understood the appeal of speech-to-text on mobile phones. I don't want to sit next to someone on the train while they enunciate a long email or a text message to their girlfriend. Nor do I want to shout my own internet musings at those around me. Besides, these days most of us are used to editing as we write. Good PC dictation software makes that easy. On a mobile phone, you'll end up editing it by thumb…

> Yep, Android's has lots of cool features that iPhone has not, but a lot of its core functionality isn't fucking done.

Right, like if only Android would get multi-tasking, like the iPh...oh, wait....

Re: Switching to Android

#56
post #49

Dude, iTunes music has been DRM-free for more than a year now.

Amazon has double the bit rate though. That may not matter to some people, but I'm not going to spend money on 128kps songs. I'm no audiophile, but there is a difference at that low of a bitrate.

Re: Switching to Android

#57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree, the voice speed is too slow, and it sends the data back to google for analysis each time, rather than doing it on the phone, which means if you are anywhere with less than stellar reception, or if you have limited data, it can become instantly useless. If you could download the maps for you local area, and do vocal direction searches on it, or search your phone without having to be connected to the internet,…

Google gestures sounds awful lot like iOS Spotlight - it too indexes apps, contacts, calendar and contents of some applications. Instead of full screen drawing it gives you the default keyboard. Swipe right on home screen to access it.

Well it's similar in the fact that they both search data on the device.. But gestures is an application to access the index using quick, simple gestures instead of typing. If you want to search using a keyboard (the default method) then you wouldn't start the gesture application.

Re: Switching to Android

#58
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hmm, that looks a bit like Shapewriter for the iPhone.

Which is also available for Android :)

Are you sure? Their site tells me otherwise:

http://www.shapewriter.com/android.html

I think I read something about it them stopping selling it for Android. Does anyone know why?

Re: Switching to Android

#59
post #49

Dude, iTunes music has been DRM-free for more than a year now.

Amazon has double the bit rate though. That may not matter to some people, but I'm not going to spend money on 128kps songs. I'm no audiophile, but there is a difference at that low of a bitrate.

Are Amazon music files in AAC or in MP3 format? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Audio_Coding#AAC.27s_i...

Re: Switching to Android

#60
post #49

Dude, iTunes music has been DRM-free for more than a year now.

Amazon has double the bit rate though. That may not matter to some people, but I'm not going to spend money on 128kps songs. I'm no audiophile, but there is a difference at that low of a bitrate.

As of April 2007, DRM-free iTunes songs are 256kbps AAC. Amazon MP3 is 320kbps MP3. Audio file formats are a highly-debated and subjective matter, but the consensus seems to be that “AAC is higher quality at the same bit rate, so you can use a smaller file to achieve the same quality as MP3” [1]. (Originally DRM-free songs on iTunes cost extra, but now they are the default.)

[1] http://www.planetofsoundonline.com/articles/compression1.htm...

Post reply on HN