Live data from Hacker News

How to Stop Apologizing for My Stutter, and Other Important Lessons

longreads.com

51–60 of 60 posts

Re: How to Stop Apologizing for My Stutter, and Other Important Lessons

#51
post #17

Stutterer here. Was in speech therapy for a long time as a child; my sister actually became a speech therapist b/c of that experience. It will always be a challenge (I'm 37 now), and it seems to rear its ugly head at random times not necessarily tied to stress. Two nights ago I made my first ever best man speech in front of about 150+ people and I maybe stammered once during the 5 or so minutes. Felt amazing and I ha…

I'm also a stutterer and the last sentence rings true. I am a lot better now than I was as a child, but I used to be a master at the art of avoidance and replacement. If I felt I was going to stutter on a given word, I'd replace it with something I felt more confident with. I was constantly evading a ruthless, arbitrary censor, and I'm certain it gave me a greater facility with synonyms, rephrasing, and general lingu…

Very similar experience.

I had to preempt the word and then either imagine a synonym or add a long vowel as a launching pad ...."Oh! Blackboard"

Re: How to Stop Apologizing for My Stutter, and Other Important Lessons

#53
post #48
post #36

I'm a stutter too. My condition is a bit special I think. When I'm alone, I don't stutter at all if I think out loud or just read something on the screen, every scary word turns into a piece of cake. But as soon as I realize someone can hear me (even if it's remote like video chat), I start to stutter, pretty badly. I wonder if other people are in the same camp. I didn't stutter when I was kid until I played with a n…

As a child I used to stutter when reading aloud to myself. Practicing by reading whole books aloud helped a lot. Some books were more difficult than others, especially those with really weird sentence structure, or really short sentences, which used to get me out of the flow. With practice, I stopped stuttering when reading aloud altogether, and then even when reading to other people (family members first). Talking t…

My stutter is minor but definitely rears its ugly head when I'm stressed. Reading aloud also works for me, as well as singing and boisterous conversations (!) I think that rather than confidence (at least for me) the key is to keep the voice going and maintain a normal 'speed' throughout.

Regarding your strangers problem, honestly you're being too harsh to yourself. You won't get judged for asking a question to be repeated!

Re: How to Stop Apologizing for My Stutter, and Other Important Lessons

#54
post #53
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As a child I used to stutter when reading aloud to myself. Practicing by reading whole books aloud helped a lot. Some books were more difficult than others, especially those with really weird sentence structure, or really short sentences, which used to get me out of the flow. With practice, I stopped stuttering when reading aloud altogether, and then even when reading to other people (family members first). Talking t…

My stutter is minor but definitely rears its ugly head when I'm stressed. Reading aloud also works for me, as well as singing and boisterous conversations (!) I think that rather than confidence (at least for me) the key is to keep the voice going and maintain a normal 'speed' throughout. Regarding your strangers problem, honestly you're being too harsh to yourself. You won't get judged for asking a question to be re…

That's for sure a factor, and I should probably care less about judgement (thanks) although I've mainly attributed my stuttering in those situations to the fact I have to say something unexpected. Other examples are when I need to correct myself (I get stuck in something like a loop of "actually no"), or when I say I need to hang up and call back later. I also often find it difficult to say "goodbye" to people without first acquiring eye contact, or in general to say something to people while they are doing something else and haven't noticed me approaching.

Re: How to Stop Apologizing for My Stutter, and Other Important Lessons

#55
post #54
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My stutter is minor but definitely rears its ugly head when I'm stressed. Reading aloud also works for me, as well as singing and boisterous conversations (!) I think that rather than confidence (at least for me) the key is to keep the voice going and maintain a normal 'speed' throughout. Regarding your strangers problem, honestly you're being too harsh to yourself. You won't get judged for asking a question to be re…

That's for sure a factor, and I should probably care less about judgement (thanks) although I've mainly attributed my stuttering in those situations to the fact I have to say something unexpected. Other examples are when I need to correct myself (I get stuck in something like a loop of "actually no"), or when I say I need to hang up and call back later. I also often find it difficult to say "goodbye" to people withou…

Sigh, yes I can relate to that. Others here mentioned that it's mental gymnastics, and I would add that crucial to the strategy also is to develop a thicker skin to protect yourself. Because the truth is, it'll always stay with you, no matter how hard you try, so it's best to be content with getting embarrassed now! And hey, that's how you learn anyway.

I used to hate answering phone calls. Then one day an admin from my team left and suddenly I had to do customer services too. The first two days was just awful, it's not even worth describing here. By third day, I had mapped out a script to read out from (and my team weirded out). By third week, I'd known the script by heart, and can comfortable say hello without any sweat patches. And now I can take unknown phone calls civilly.

Practice and exposure definitely helps, with a dose of immunity to what others think :)

Re: How to Stop Apologizing for My Stutter, and Other Important Lessons

#56
post #7

From an engineering perspective, I wish more technologists researched the intersection of speech and technology. For many who stutter there's a device called the SpeechEasy which is marketed as something to improve fluency, and reduce stuttering. Unfortunately for most it doesn't work, for those that it does work the effect wears off, it costs well over $3,000 for the intro pocket model, and typically not covered by…

Loopback microphone input on your smartphone, plug in earphones and you're good to go! How is that for disruption?

It doesn't exist. Why, I'm not sure. Would you create that app? Maybe make it so that you can use a Bluetooth earpiece or earbuds with an inline mic? That would be really awesome. If you created it and it worked just like the SpeechEasy you could sell it for a few dollars and make good money. It could be a way for potential users to test the effect in the real world before spending $3k+ on the device.

I look forward to your progress!

Re: How to Stop Apologizing for My Stutter, and Other Important Lessons

#57
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Loopback microphone input on your smartphone, plug in earphones and you're good to go! How is that for disruption?

It doesn't exist. Why, I'm not sure. Would you create that app? Maybe make it so that you can use a Bluetooth earpiece or earbuds with an inline mic? That would be really awesome. If you created it and it worked just like the SpeechEasy you could sell it for a few dollars and make good money. It could be a way for potential users to test the effect in the real world before spending $3k+ on the device. I look forward…

There are some already. Look for DAF or "delayed auditory feedback" on the play store. It is also trivial to build one with web audio.

Re: How to Stop Apologizing for My Stutter, and Other Important Lessons

#58
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It doesn't exist. Why, I'm not sure. Would you create that app? Maybe make it so that you can use a Bluetooth earpiece or earbuds with an inline mic? That would be really awesome. If you created it and it worked just like the SpeechEasy you could sell it for a few dollars and make good money. It could be a way for potential users to test the effect in the real world before spending $3k+ on the device. I look forward…

There are some already. Look for DAF or "delayed auditory feedback" on the play store. It is also trivial to build one with web audio.

Nope. They absolutely cannot be delayed auditory feedback. That disrupts speech. The device must reproduce the chorus effect. [0]

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xw_rVGUXgos

Re: How to Stop Apologizing for My Stutter, and Other Important Lessons

#59
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There are some already. Look for DAF or "delayed auditory feedback" on the play store. It is also trivial to build one with web audio.

Nope. They absolutely cannot be delayed auditory feedback. That disrupts speech. The device must reproduce the chorus effect. [0] [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xw_rVGUXgos

Some of those DAF apps can also apply pitch shifting (which is actually AAF). Provided they work properly, they should be able to provide that choral effect. I am no expert by the way, I've only toyed with those for a few minutes.

Re: How to Stop Apologizing for My Stutter, and Other Important Lessons

#60
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Loopback microphone input on your smartphone, plug in earphones and you're good to go! How is that for disruption?

It doesn't exist. Why, I'm not sure. Would you create that app? Maybe make it so that you can use a Bluetooth earpiece or earbuds with an inline mic? That would be really awesome. If you created it and it worked just like the SpeechEasy you could sell it for a few dollars and make good money. It could be a way for potential users to test the effect in the real world before spending $3k+ on the device. I look forward…

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.ad960009.a...

I use this

Post reply on HN