Live data from Hacker News

Robot cracks open safe live on Def Con's stage

bbc.com

81–90 of 122 posts

Re: Robot cracks open safe live on Def Con's stage

#81
post #65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When I was 10, I found a rotary bicycle lock + connected chain, locked alone to a post in a park. Having read up on locks even then (god knows how), I tried the method of "pull on it and spin the dials". About 30 seconds later, it was unlocked. I used that lock for about 10 years, until I went to University, where the thieves were a bit smarter.

Just a note that the lock you found may have not been abandoned. Many bike posts in my university's undercover bike shed often had several locks without a bike in sight. It turned out many people leaving bike locks on posts they often use (it doesn't take up much space or prevent someone from using the post). It saves those cyclists the hassle of carrying the the lock with them (only the key), which is particularly a…

Agreed. I have a lock on the work bike lockers I use. Everyone seems to do this. Means you can have a very hefty lock but not carry it. Speaking of we moved buildings I need to snag it.

Re: Robot cracks open safe live on Def Con's stage

#82

Last month I had the disappointing surprise of finding a lock on my bike. I forgot I put it (it's been years since I last used it). And it's not a key lock.. so I'm screwed. Not willing to cut the cable.. I decided to brute force it. 999 space is fun. Luckily you quickly find similar tips than the alignment one to speed up the process. And since it's not a full rotary lock, I could also "DDR" the tests by testing whe…

For 1000 possible combinations, wouldn't you expect to have to try ~500 combinations on average to find solutions? Since you found it in 800 attempts, this suggests that whatever method you used may have actually made your odds of success worst.

Re: Robot cracks open safe live on Def Con's stage

#83
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A key element of this is it's ability to limit the amount of possible combinations from 1 million to about 1000 due to small flaws in the dials. A contact microphone might be able to even further reduce this search space in combination with the existing exploits.

There are Sergeant and Greenleaf locks with a half-digit tolerance, so you have to get the number exactly right. They're not popular, because they're such a pain to use.

  >> half-digit tolerance
I assume you mean There is a big difference between 0.55digit tolerance (might be able to try two numbers at once with enough mechanical precision to the solver) and 0.45digit tolerance.

Re: Robot cracks open safe live on Def Con's stage

#84

Last month I had the disappointing surprise of finding a lock on my bike. I forgot I put it (it's been years since I last used it). And it's not a key lock.. so I'm screwed. Not willing to cut the cable.. I decided to brute force it. 999 space is fun. Luckily you quickly find similar tips than the alignment one to speed up the process. And since it's not a full rotary lock, I could also "DDR" the tests by testing whe…

After taking assembler my freshman year (1970's) i wrote the combination lock code in the octal representation of 1-9. I wrote it on the bottom if the storage unit rented to?store furniture between terms..

When i returned to unlock it, the numbers were faded and unreadbale.

Got lock pliers from the office

Re: Robot cracks open safe live on Def Con's stage

#85
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Bear in mind that local governments view property crime as a form of economic stimulus. You'll be spending money to replace the stolen items, presumably some of that locally, and on repairs, presumably all locally. Meanwhile, whatever money the criminals get back in selling the stolen items (and subsequent profits by their fences) will also presumably be spent locally.

A literal broken window fallacy example. Amazing.

It's not quite as fallacious. The negligent window breaker does not profit from the broken window.

Re: Robot cracks open safe live on Def Con's stage

#86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's exactly what I did.

Then it should not have taken you 800 attempts?

In reality there are other issues:

- mechanism is rusty

- has backlash/play

you're never sure you isolated the empty slot, so you assume so, go deeper, then backtrack when you reached the leaf of that exploration tree. Also, the double scan thing made it quick enough to avoid trying to probe too long for the right slot, hence the hybrid solution.

Re: Robot cracks open safe live on Def Con's stage

#87

Last month I had the disappointing surprise of finding a lock on my bike. I forgot I put it (it's been years since I last used it). And it's not a key lock.. so I'm screwed. Not willing to cut the cable.. I decided to brute force it. 999 space is fun. Luckily you quickly find similar tips than the alignment one to speed up the process. And since it's not a full rotary lock, I could also "DDR" the tests by testing whe…

For 1000 possible combinations, wouldn't you expect to have to try ~500 combinations on average to find solutions? Since you found it in 800 attempts, this suggests that whatever method you used may have actually made your odds of success worst.

Well if you enumerate in order and your code is 800 then you have to try 800 cases.

Re: Robot cracks open safe live on Def Con's stage

#88

Last month I had the disappointing surprise of finding a lock on my bike. I forgot I put it (it's been years since I last used it). And it's not a key lock.. so I'm screwed. Not willing to cut the cable.. I decided to brute force it. 999 space is fun. Luckily you quickly find similar tips than the alignment one to speed up the process. And since it's not a full rotary lock, I could also "DDR" the tests by testing whe…

After taking assembler my freshman year (1970's) i wrote the combination lock code in the octal representation of 1-9. I wrote it on the bottom if the storage unit rented to?store furniture between terms.. When i returned to unlock it, the numbers were faded and unreadbale. Got lock pliers from the office

lol. Funny someone suggested to engrave similar encoding into the frame.

And since I was eyeing on CNC milling machines .. that might be a nice project. I am thinking about stealing the correction scheme used on CD to be scratch resistant.

Re: Robot cracks open safe live on Def Con's stage

#89
post #71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Depends on where you are. UL ratings are used in north america. There are similar EU ratings that I dont recall of hand. TL ratings are for theft/entry resistance. There are other modifiers for fire, water, chemical, etc resistance. Unrated "safes", and even some that are said to be rated, are junk. In NA you want to get in touch with a local safe dealer/specialist. Most of their business is commercial, and they are…

That video was much dirtier and louder than I expected. Lots of brute force still involved. Not quite the domain of out of shape hackers. But I guess that's why we build robots. For anyone who wants a good safe cracking story, this book is excellent: https://www.amazon.com/Flawless-Inside-Largest-Diamond-Histo... A group of Italians went to Belgium's diamond district and bypassed an very expensive vault door. The bes…

For contrast here's two guys with crowbars opening a non-UL-rated but serious-looking safe in less than 3 minutes.

Re: Robot cracks open safe live on Def Con's stage

#90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And then I just cut the power to the building.

Police response is what, 6 minutes? Can you open the safe in 6 minutes after cutting the power? Probably not.

Cut communications hardlines to the building, and also use a cell scrambler.
Post reply on HN