Live data from Hacker News

Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

theguardian.com

81–90 of 546 posts

Re: Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

#81
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> If we can afford a program to feed the poor, we can afford a program to feed everyone This isn't actually true, which is why means testing exists. If San Francisco gave every resident just $200/month for food, it would cost the city over $2 billion/year. And that's assuming only $200/month and no other assistance programs. The only way to get rid of means testing while maintaining existing social services would be…

"drastically raise taxes." Sure, on paper it would drastically raise taxes, but the net effect would be nil. The average taxpayer would have taxes raised by $200 and receive a benefit of $200/month. And the raise should be substantially less than $200 because you no longer have to pay for the old food assistance program, nor most of the bureaucracy for it.

The state would still be at a negative loss with your example.

Re: Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

#82

“Back in the day, [the wage] would have been a great number,” said Victor, “but because of Facebook moving in, everything is so expensive. I have to get payday loans sometimes. We barely make it.” They make a combined (rounded) $75,000/year. The real tragedy is that you can't afford to make it in the Bay Area on $75k/yr. I don't think that's something you can blame solely on Facebook.

> I don't think that's something you can blame solely on Facebook.

They could pay their cafeteria workers better. Of course, it's not only Facebook that's a problem. I doubt many cafeteria workers make 75K/year.

That said, aren't social housing projects an option here?

Re: Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

#83
post #65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well you can't really consider the Bay Area housing bubble and cost of living spike without taking the tech boom into account. I think it's both the fault of NIMBYism/failure to build sufficient housing in the South Bay, and the fault of large companies, VCs, and startups for doubling down on the South Bay instead of distributing new jobs more evenly throughout the rest of the country.

Why should they given the gains to concentration? Other metro like Chicago and NYC do have tech offices.

Maybe to not effectively destroy cities and communities with CoL traps? Y'know. Basic "we are members of a society and should be working to make it better" stuff. (Shocking, I know, but there have been eras where even Big Businessmans thought about this.)

Re: Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

#84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Don't be so susceptible. The literal story is about food workers who can't afford to raise a family in Palo Alto. The intended message seems to be that Facebook should pay food workers more than $20/hr. I think it's acceptable for people to ponder outside of that claim.

I think people are pondering outside of that claim because young programmers in Palo Alto also want cheap real estate so there's a shared interest. But things this article brings up that are more uncomfortable for the members of this board to think about like paying service workers more or pondering this: “They look at us like we’re lower, like we don’t matter,” said Nicole of the Facebook employees. “We don’t live t…

> At the end of every shift, Nicole watches large amounts of leftover food go into the compost – food that she’s not allowed to take home.

On that one in particular - is there a law against that? I know rules on food service workers taking things home vary quite a bit.

Re: Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

#85
post #11

“Back in the day, [the wage] would have been a great number,” said Victor, “but because of Facebook moving in, everything is so expensive. I have to get payday loans sometimes. We barely make it.” They make a combined (rounded) $75,000/year. The real tragedy is that you can't afford to make it in the Bay Area on $75k/yr. I don't think that's something you can blame solely on Facebook.

Where is their $75k/year going? I totally get that the bay is ridiculously expensive, but they're living in his parents' garage. Are his parents charging him that much rent? I'd think someone living in their parents' garage and earning $75k would be doing pretty well in terms of money. (Setting aside the fact that living with your family in a 2-car garage would definitely suck.)

Maybe the parents also rent the house. At 29/26 the parents could easily be 49/46 and still working.

Also, mind that poverty has a role in poor economic decisions (payday loans being one of them).

https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/11/your-br...

(edit: added some extra info)

Re: Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

#86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Even then. Housing prices are obviously related to Silicon Valley companies, but there's much to be said about housing policy as well.

The sad part is that California, being the largest state in the US, should be the last one to have this sort of housing problems...

This comment is wrong on many levels...

1/ State borders within the US aren't any sort of obstacle to commuting for work, so how big your state is is completely irrelevant (it's only a slight exaggeration to say that half of New Jersey is fully integrated suburbs of NYC).

2/ Even if it did matter, California is definitely not the largest state in the US.

Re: Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

#87
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Perhaps but consider even in developing economies these kinds of jobs aren't the ones which allow you to raise a middle class family, never mind a doing so in a developed economy.

Just to be clear - I'm not advocating for minimum wage jobs to put a family of 4 (or 5) in the middle class bracket. What I'm advocating for is that (2!) minimum wage jobs should afford rent, food, and medical/dental expenses. There is absolutely no excuse why $75k combined income should afford a 2 or 3 br apartment, food, and to keep the kids healthy. The only options are to a) either lower costs to make things affo…

Low end jobs that can be automated will be automated. Only reason they have not is because wages have been depressed via replenishment of the low end of the worker pool from underdeveloped economies. If you look at Japan lots of the fast food stuff is automated. We will see more automation in agriculture. No kids will grow up wanting to pick vegetables, quite reasonably but they still need harvesting.

Re: Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

#88

Everybody here is focusing on real estate. (because young wealthy programmers and older poorer workers have a shared interest in cheap real estate) But I'm really interested in how HN feels about this section: “I felt more secure at my other job. You didn’t have people looking down at you,” Nicole said. Now she works at cafeterias with names like “Epic” and “Living the Dream”, and the distance between the two classes…

This is the real problem.

Re: Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

#89

A few things. They aren't Facebook employees, as some people might infer when reading the headline. They're working for the cafeteria contractor - Flagship Facility Services. They are making $2 and $4/hour more than the $15/hour minimum wage people are fighting for. Obviously $15 isn't enough and neither is more than $15. >> Earlier in their relationship, the couple both earned about $12 per hour as managers at Chipo…

> They aren't Facebook employees, as some people might infer when reading the headline. They're working for the cafeteria contractor - Flagship Facility Services.

Not saying you're doing this, but this is very regularly used as a dodge to erase the responsibility of very large companies (and smaller too, of course) to ensure that the people working for their contractors to be treated fairly and equitably, too.

Contractors-as-plausible-deniability is a bad, bad scene.

Re: Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

#90
post #25

MacDonald's is also a multibillion dollar corp., nobody in their right mind thinks they can raise a family working at MacD's without additional income or subsidy. It's a job for teenagers to get experience and for blue collar retirees to make some money to and to their SS checks. People should stop thinking teenager jobs sustain families. It doesn't have the value add. If you want to make a living open up a stand and…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN