Live data from Hacker News

Primer (film)

en.wikipedia.org

31–40 of 93 posts

Re: Primer (film)

#31
I like to maintain my take on time travel as described by Sheldon in Big Bang theory

"Sheldon: It occurs to me that if I ever did invent a time machine, I will just go into the past and give it to myself. Thus eliminating the need to invent it in first place. That really takes the pressure off".

I would like to hear what you guys think of time travel, after all it has be one of the favourite subject of speculative science fiction.

Re: Primer (film)

#32

Please, don't read the Wikipedia article before you go out and rent or buy this movie. The movie is absolutely fantastic. I have seen it 17 to 18 times, and even-though people have attempted to explain everything that is going on to me I still have a hard time wrapping my mind around it. Awesome for the hacker in you!

I'm ashamed to say I haven't seen this movie yet, I must order the DVD this weekend, (now that I've been reminded for the umpteenth time). On a side note, my biggest annoyance with Wikipedia is manifest in articles about movies. For some reason, they allow an editorial policy of essentially writing out a scene by scene account of a movie.

True, but it's informational not editorial. I think the best they could really do is have a spoiler/non-spoiler view.

Re: Primer (film)

#33

I like to maintain my take on time travel as described by Sheldon in Big Bang theory "Sheldon: It occurs to me that if I ever did invent a time machine, I will just go into the past and give it to myself. Thus eliminating the need to invent it in first place. That really takes the pressure off". I would like to hear what you guys think of time travel, after all it has be one of the favourite subject of speculative sc…

The whole universe only needs one well maintained time machine.

I like the clause in their roommate agreement - if any of them ever invents a time machine, the first stop will be their meeting on the roommate agreement when they are discussing it.

Re: Primer (film)

#34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm ashamed to say I haven't seen this movie yet, I must order the DVD this weekend, (now that I've been reminded for the umpteenth time). On a side note, my biggest annoyance with Wikipedia is manifest in articles about movies. For some reason, they allow an editorial policy of essentially writing out a scene by scene account of a movie.

True, but it's informational not editorial. I think the best they could really do is have a spoiler/non-spoiler view.

It's indeed informative. Now I have to watch it five more times to understand what the wikipedia article says.

From about two or three viewings, I got about a third of it right.

Re: Primer (film)

#35
post #26
post #15

Yeah a great flick. Only cost $7k dollars to make or something. Needs to be watched MANY times to figure it out, but the great thing is it seems to all hold together.

The DVD commentary is incredibly interesting because of this - mostly explaining how they kept the cost so low

It's rather simple. They traveled back in time with the complete movie. $7K was what the cost to build the time machine they used.

Re: Primer (film)

#40

I like to maintain my take on time travel as described by Sheldon in Big Bang theory "Sheldon: It occurs to me that if I ever did invent a time machine, I will just go into the past and give it to myself. Thus eliminating the need to invent it in first place. That really takes the pressure off". I would like to hear what you guys think of time travel, after all it has be one of the favourite subject of speculative sc…

Some spoilers, beware.

Honestly, I'm rarely a fan of time travel stories. They tend to be full of plot holes and half-baked logic. Since everything is theoretical, it seems like many writers just pull whatever rules they feel like out of a hat, and use it as a sort of deus ex machina. Very rarely is it used well in my opinion. Primer is one of the rare exceptions because it's well structured and thought out (maddeningly so), but overall I tend to skip such things.

Also, it could be noted that Primer being about time travel could be considered a spoiler. I didn't know what it was about until it was actually revealed in the movie, and I was kind of happy having it that way.

Post reply on HN