Live data from Hacker News

Syncthing Usage Data

data.syncthing.net

71–80 of 125 posts

Re: Syncthing Usage Data

#71
This looks pretty cool, and I'll definitely look at it as a Dropbox replacement.

On the negative side, your stats page doesn't have a link back to your main page, so you won't even know how many folk had a look based on this HN post. It's a good idea to ensure that all your pages have a link back to your main page.

Re: Syncthing Usage Data

#72
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There are public relays which you can use (automatically unless you disable the feature), so NATing and firewalls shouldn't be an issue.

I think they're upset that the Network Administrator is blocking the system intentionally, not that it didn't make it through in the first place. Don't upset your Network Administrators!

Well I am in about 10 different school districts and they all have different policies. I just won't do anything that won't work as a default so I can claim ignorance.

Re: Syncthing Usage Data

#73
post #55
post #8

Brilliant piece of software. Perfect to gather data from different devices to backup in the cloud or to sync documents or a massive music collection. The only thing missing is an encrypted external sync node so I can put it on a VPS somewhere

This is the blocker for me too. Support for a zero knowledge server where even if someone gets access to the filesystem on the server, they can only see it encrypted. Other than that, Syncthing is absolutely amazing!

I would like to mix it. Then my desktop could be a mirror for my friend without knowing his files and vice versa.

Re: Syncthing Usage Data

#74
post #71

This looks pretty cool, and I'll definitely look at it as a Dropbox replacement. On the negative side, your stats page doesn't have a link back to your main page, so you won't even know how many folk had a look based on this HN post. It's a good idea to ensure that all your pages have a link back to your main page.

Yeah that page which was linked to isn't really part of the website: it's a separate site entirely, which is a frontend to the data-collection service.

People aren't really supposed to link to it directly as a means of introducing new people to Syncthing...

Re: Syncthing Usage Data

#75
post #2

It amazes me that Syncthing handles rapidly-changing files better for me than Dropbox. Where Dropbox has left different versions of files on different computers even after they have changed multiple times, Syncthing happily synchronizes them without issues. And the fact that Syncthing is open source and allows me to keep files on my own machines is a big plus. However, I would love to see a paid option for easy backu…

Just a heads up: that almost certainly means SyncThing is failing to recognize some classes of conflicts and concurrency races, and is destroying some changes. Doing this right is a hard problem. I know they can be a pain to deal with, but we don't spin out conflicts for no reason!

Disclosure: I work on the Dropbox sync engine.

Re: Syncthing Usage Data

#76

Syncthing is sorely missing iOS support. I know they have their reasons not to implement it[0], but I feel that feature might be worth the hassle. Photo sync on iOS without iCloud is a huge pain atm. My backup strategy involves a NAS folder that stays up to date (i.e. also deletes photos that I delete on my phone), and which I occasionally sort into final location. After that I can free the space on my phone. All oth…

To avoid lock-in with Apple, I tried Amazon Drive for photos. It has worked perfectly for backing up media to their cloud storage. So now I keep my photos in two places.

Re: Syncthing Usage Data

#77
I had to stop using syncthing on my MacBook and MacBook Air because it was using far too much ram/cpu.

I wish it could be made more efficient somehow.

Re: Syncthing Usage Data

#78
post #65
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For those with some spare CPU cycles and bandwidth you can give back to the project by running a relay server. https://docs.syncthing.net/users/strelaysrv.html Eg that VM running a DNS adblocker, from another front page article :)

What are the system requirements for running a relay server? And is there any easy way to configure traffic quotas?

You don't really need anything except a fast enough internet connection. The relay page [1] has some stats about that. And there are various configuration options, see the documentation [2].

[1] http://relays.syncthing.net/ [2] https://docs.syncthing.net/users/strelaysrv.html#strelaysrv

Re: Syncthing Usage Data

#79
post #71

This looks pretty cool, and I'll definitely look at it as a Dropbox replacement. On the negative side, your stats page doesn't have a link back to your main page, so you won't even know how many folk had a look based on this HN post. It's a good idea to ensure that all your pages have a link back to your main page.

Why wouldn't they know? Check all IPs that visited both the linked and home page and you'll know.

Re: Syncthing Usage Data

#80
post #75
post #2

It amazes me that Syncthing handles rapidly-changing files better for me than Dropbox. Where Dropbox has left different versions of files on different computers even after they have changed multiple times, Syncthing happily synchronizes them without issues. And the fact that Syncthing is open source and allows me to keep files on my own machines is a big plus. However, I would love to see a paid option for easy backu…

Just a heads up: that almost certainly means SyncThing is failing to recognize some classes of conflicts and concurrency races, and is destroying some changes. Doing this right is a hard problem. I know they can be a pain to deal with, but we don't spin out conflicts for no reason! Disclosure: I work on the Dropbox sync engine.

Do you have any specific bug or design reference to the Syncthing codebase that illustrates this, or do you simply believe that it's impossible to do it faster than Dropbox does it?

Fwiw, i frequently get notifications from Syncthing that it's found a conflict it can't resolve and asks me to resolve manually.

Post reply on HN