Live data from Hacker News

The Netherlands Closes Prisons Because It Doesn't Have Enough Prisoners

fastcoexist.com

21–30 of 91 posts

Re: The Netherlands Closes Prisons Because It Doesn't Have Enough Prisoners

#21
post #20

There are a couple reasons why there are so little people in jail in the Netherlands and not all are positive. Crime reporting rate has never been lower. People have very little confidence that reporting a crime will lead to the criminal getting caught or even convicted. Many crimes are not solved. The crime solve rate is about 2-3% which means out of that small number of actual reported crimes only a marginal amount…

>>It's very common for judges to pass a community services punishment or an electronic ankle bracelet house arrest. But that's a good thing unless you consider sending people to the mines and keep them locked behind bars for years a better alternative.

In the US at least, community service is typically only an option if:

- It's your first offense

- You more-or-less admit to the crime (not necessarily meaning you turned yourself in, but you didn't go through a trial while maintaining your innocence the whole time)

- You are clearly remorseful

- The crime is minor and non-violent

- The odds are seen as low or very low that you'd do it again

There are exceptions of course, but if you commit armed robbery, I don't think many people would feel community service is a just sentence. Nor would shoplifting if it's the 5th time you've been caught.

Re: The Netherlands Closes Prisons Because It Doesn't Have Enough Prisoners

#22
post #21
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>>It's very common for judges to pass a community services punishment or an electronic ankle bracelet house arrest. But that's a good thing unless you consider sending people to the mines and keep them locked behind bars for years a better alternative.

In the US at least, community service is typically only an option if: - It's your first offense - You more-or-less admit to the crime (not necessarily meaning you turned yourself in, but you didn't go through a trial while maintaining your innocence the whole time) - You are clearly remorseful - The crime is minor and non-violent - The odds are seen as low or very low that you'd do it again There are exceptions of co…

>> if you commit armed robbery...

There are significantly less guns available compared to the US, so armed robberies are likely heavily punished too.

While I don't say all sentences should be light as a feather, there are a lot of 'jails' (especially in Norway) where the inmates can go home for the evening or weekend.

Re: The Netherlands Closes Prisons Because It Doesn't Have Enough Prisoners

#24

There are a couple reasons why there are so little people in jail in the Netherlands and not all are positive. Crime reporting rate has never been lower. People have very little confidence that reporting a crime will lead to the criminal getting caught or even convicted. Many crimes are not solved. The crime solve rate is about 2-3% which means out of that small number of actual reported crimes only a marginal amount…

> People have very little confidence that reporting a crime will lead to the criminal getting caught

I thought that way too, but it's not all bad. I was recently positively surprised when the police actually investigated a bike theft that I reported (online) and caught and prosecuted the thief! Court session is next month, I'm going and will take my daughter (who's bike it was) there to learn...

Re: The Netherlands Closes Prisons Because It Doesn't Have Enough Prisoners

#25

There are a couple reasons why there are so little people in jail in the Netherlands and not all are positive. Crime reporting rate has never been lower. People have very little confidence that reporting a crime will lead to the criminal getting caught or even convicted. Many crimes are not solved. The crime solve rate is about 2-3% which means out of that small number of actual reported crimes only a marginal amount…

Out of those solved crimes only a percentage reaches an actual conviction for the criminal. Well, that's literally true anywhere. Besides, a very high conviction rate indicates an unhealthy judicial system: http://www.economist.com/node/8680941

98% accused of the crime in US plead guilty.

Re: The Netherlands Closes Prisons Because It Doesn't Have Enough Prisoners

#26
post #21
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>>It's very common for judges to pass a community services punishment or an electronic ankle bracelet house arrest. But that's a good thing unless you consider sending people to the mines and keep them locked behind bars for years a better alternative.

In the US at least, community service is typically only an option if: - It's your first offense - You more-or-less admit to the crime (not necessarily meaning you turned yourself in, but you didn't go through a trial while maintaining your innocence the whole time) - You are clearly remorseful - The crime is minor and non-violent - The odds are seen as low or very low that you'd do it again There are exceptions of co…

Forgot the obligatory:

- You are rich/famous.

Re: The Netherlands Closes Prisons Because It Doesn't Have Enough Prisoners

#27
Unthinkable here in the USA. When prisons start emptying, just increase sentence lengths to keep those beds full and corporate prison profits up. EDIT: Also effective: simply increase enforcement. Since so many things are illegal, police just need to fish more if they want to catch more.

Re: The Netherlands Closes Prisons Because It Doesn't Have Enough Prisoners

#30

There are a couple reasons why there are so little people in jail in the Netherlands and not all are positive. Crime reporting rate has never been lower. People have very little confidence that reporting a crime will lead to the criminal getting caught or even convicted. Many crimes are not solved. The crime solve rate is about 2-3% which means out of that small number of actual reported crimes only a marginal amount…

> People have very little confidence that reporting a crime will lead to the criminal getting caught I thought that way too, but it's not all bad. I was recently positively surprised when the police actually investigated a bike theft that I reported (online) and caught and prosecuted the thief! Court session is next month, I'm going and will take my daughter (who's bike it was) there to learn...

Please reply to your comment and let us know what the outcome is, if you remember too.
Post reply on HN