Live data from Hacker News

Google Has Started Penalizing Mobile Websites with Intrusive Pop-Up Ads

scribblrs.com

71–80 of 406 posts

Re: Google Has Started Penalizing Mobile Websites with Intrusive Pop-Up Ads

#71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

On my iPhone 6s Safari AMP sites don't even work. I see the AMP header and everything below it is just blank. I always have to "Request Desktop Site" to even load the site.

Are you using an adblocker?

Yea, I'm using a content blocker: Firefox Focus

Too bad AMP won't work with it, but there's no way I'm disabling it as life before content blockers on iOS was hell. (Sites hijacking you to the app store, etc.)

Re: Google Has Started Penalizing Mobile Websites with Intrusive Pop-Up Ads

#72
post #47

What's really stupid are sites from which you can buy things, but then pop up an ad for something else. Fandango, which sells movie tickets, does this. As you're trying to get to the "buy ticket" page, they shove movie trailers for other movies in your face. I mentioned a site earlier today which sold plumbing supplies.[1] They pop up a "gimme your email" box which 1) cannot be dismissed , and 2) isn't even theirs, i…

[deleted]

Re: Google Has Started Penalizing Mobile Websites with Intrusive Pop-Up Ads

#73
post #70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Pop-ups asking me to please take a survey about the user experience of the website, too. Well, I was trying to actually buy something on your website, before your goddamn survey pop-up got in the way.

I've had many sites pop this up within seconds of being on the site. Though the attention span of some might be short, I suspect the data collected by these surveys is highly unhelpful simply because you have not yet experienced the product. Given they're all from the same company usually whose name escapes me right now, you'd think they'd be better at it?

ForeSee

Re: Google Has Started Penalizing Mobile Websites with Intrusive Pop-Up Ads

#74
post #47

What's really stupid are sites from which you can buy things, but then pop up an ad for something else. Fandango, which sells movie tickets, does this. As you're trying to get to the "buy ticket" page, they shove movie trailers for other movies in your face. I mentioned a site earlier today which sold plumbing supplies.[1] They pop up a "gimme your email" box which 1) cannot be dismissed , and 2) isn't even theirs, i…

Interesting how pop-up blockers made their way into browsers years ago, so now they no longer open a new window, but simply display the "pop-up" within the page dom.

Re: Google Has Started Penalizing Mobile Websites with Intrusive Pop-Up Ads

#75

A client has just asked me to add a pop-up "whatch this vid, join our newsletter", when the user scrolls to about half way down the homepage for their SAAS startup. Further the pop up is not to reappear for 90 days. They got the approach from attending an online marketing workshop that suggested this increases their list. Felt like a bit of an anti-pattern to me. Anyone have advice as to if this is effective or if it…

Pop-ups like that have long been shown to improve conversion rates... at the increase of pissing off people who wouldn't have been a conversion anyway.

Do they increase conversion rates long term? A lot of those pissed off people might not be customers today but could be in future.

Re: Google Has Started Penalizing Mobile Websites with Intrusive Pop-Up Ads

#76
post #47

What's really stupid are sites from which you can buy things, but then pop up an ad for something else. Fandango, which sells movie tickets, does this. As you're trying to get to the "buy ticket" page, they shove movie trailers for other movies in your face. I mentioned a site earlier today which sold plumbing supplies.[1] They pop up a "gimme your email" box which 1) cannot be dismissed , and 2) isn't even theirs, i…

> This is usually considered a big mistake in retail.

Is it? Grocery stores keep essentials far away from each other so you have to walk past stuff you don't want in order to get to what you want. Imagine a store where they had milk at the checkout counter! That's the retail equivalent of amazon.com ;)

Re: Google Has Started Penalizing Mobile Websites with Intrusive Pop-Up Ads

#77
post #70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've had many sites pop this up within seconds of being on the site. Though the attention span of some might be short, I suspect the data collected by these surveys is highly unhelpful simply because you have not yet experienced the product. Given they're all from the same company usually whose name escapes me right now, you'd think they'd be better at it?

ForeSee

Lots of unhappy customers in the survey. And we gave that to you for free- we could optimize your web page - for a fee. Even take the survey out- or to the exist- after we are done.

A business model worth of our admiration!

Re: Google Has Started Penalizing Mobile Websites with Intrusive Pop-Up Ads

#80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I was under the impression they would (hidden content/different content for Googlebot).

Most paywalls which offer the Googlebot the full site also offer the full site if you follow a Google search result to the article. So while you're correct that providing the Googlebot and people coming from Google Search different results is prohibited, most paywall sites just don't show the paywall for either.

Some only give you 2 or 3 article views then cut you off. But, of course, they still appear in search results.
Post reply on HN