Live data from Hacker News

Stop Obsessing Over Comments On Hacker News (2015)

venngage.com

51–58 of 58 posts

Re: Stop Obsessing Over Comments On Hacker News (2015)

#51
post #32
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Any time I read someone saying something like that I internally replace the subject with food. "Why would anyone buy food professionally made at a restaurant when you could make something similar at home?" Because I want something nice and I'm willing to spend some cash to get it. C'mon..

Valid point. Counterexample by way of metaphor: I used to feel the same way about restaurant food, but then my cooking skills increased to the point where I can make most Italian or French food just as well as if not better than most restaurants I've been to. Now, I rarely if ever go out for French or Italian any more.

French food is an interesting case, IMHO.

Aside from pommes-frites and crepes, finding French food at the bottom of the price scale is pretty difficult.

And I wonder why that's true. I mean, in Los Angeles, I can find food from other great culinary traditions at both the high end and the low end of the price scale: Korean, Mexican, Chinese, Thai, Indian, Peruvian, Vietnamese, Middle Eastern -- even Japanese, which, considering general price levels in Japan, is surprising.

But French food? It's almost always some high priced, sit-down place with a valet out front. There don't seem to be a lotta reasonably/low priced French food joints out there.

(Even stranger is the price of "British" food, usually found in pubs: always seems overpriced. And British is not exactly known as a great food tradition.)

Re: Stop Obsessing Over Comments On Hacker News (2015)

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yup, that is literally HN's community in a nutshell. Not passing judgement, mind you, but at least it isn't a Goddamned echo chamber like most other websites. Well, at least, not nearly as bad.

Yes, but you made the mistake of attempting to be witty, so now you must be downvoted into oblivion!

I will accept my downvotes proudly.

Re: Stop Obsessing Over Comments On Hacker News (2015)

#53

This really just puts more strength in the idea that success is largely luck-based. No one can accurately predict success. Not specialized forums, not specialized workers in the field, and not even VCs whose sole incentive is to make money by investing in great ideas . Even YC says as much that they have no clear idea as to what will be a success, and their strongest signal is the strength of the founders, and that t…

  >> not sure how their experiment went with inducting people into YC just based solely on who they were, without an idea,
It was not a success, and was not tried again.

Re: Stop Obsessing Over Comments On Hacker News (2015)

#54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yup, that is literally HN's community in a nutshell. Not passing judgement, mind you, but at least it isn't a Goddamned echo chamber like most other websites. Well, at least, not nearly as bad.

I like that HN is an echo chamber with a multitude of groups yelling at one time. Like binaural beats, something good comes from the synthesis.

> HN is an echo chamber with a multitude of groups yelling at one time

That's not a bad description, at least of one segment of the spectrum.

Re: Stop Obsessing Over Comments On Hacker News (2015)

#55
Interesting article, but the example at the beginning doesn't strike me as a very good one.

The commenters were correct in being concerned about safety, and the suggestion to link Facebook was implemented.

I remember when I signed up for AirBnB my biggest concern was not being able to trust the person renting the place. Their account being linked to a Facebook profile (mostly) solved this problem for me.

Re: Stop Obsessing Over Comments On Hacker News (2015)

#56
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I like that HN is an echo chamber with a multitude of groups yelling at one time. Like binaural beats, something good comes from the synthesis.

> HN is an echo chamber with a multitude of groups yelling at one time That's not a bad description, at least of one segment of the spectrum.

I find that's how HN is in general. There's a Rust contingent. There's a general FP contingent with a Haskell flank. A few years ago there was a Clojure Independency Party that provided things. I'm a member of the ArangoDB Activists Movement. The noisiest group right now is focuses on Machine Learning with NN. Fun times. Good way to get exposed to different ideas.

Re: Stop Obsessing Over Comments On Hacker News (2015)

#57
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> HN is an echo chamber with a multitude of groups yelling at one time That's not a bad description, at least of one segment of the spectrum.

I find that's how HN is in general. There's a Rust contingent. There's a general FP contingent with a Haskell flank. A few years ago there was a Clojure Independency Party that provided things. I'm a member of the ArangoDB Activists Movement. The noisiest group right now is focuses on Machine Learning with NN. Fun times. Good way to get exposed to different ideas.

Ph'nglui mglw'nafh Erlang R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn

Re: Stop Obsessing Over Comments On Hacker News (2015)

#58
post #34

Who'd have thought a community of grognards seemingly interested only in the latest JavaScript framework and a priori inserting Latin idioms into places they don't belong makes a poor predictor of startup success?

Did HN comments in aggregate ever intend or claim to be an above average predictor of startup success? Why would you expect it to be?

And, consequently, why would you then feel smug posting ad-homs about how you aren't surprised that it isn't?

Post reply on HN