Live data from Hacker News

Vine will be discontinuing the mobile app

medium.com

91–100 of 166 posts

Re: Vine will be discontinuing the mobile app

#91
post #48

Never used Vine, and the videos from it never worked on my browser, but this is truly shocking. Like, Google Reader shutdown level shocking. Twitter is seriously clueless if they weren't able to make any use of such a popular service. Especially when Periscope is still running somehow. Though it's only a matter of time for that too now.

Periscope may stick around for a while only because of the current obsession with live video. As soon as Facebook gives up on live (or at least stops focusing so much on it), Twitter will follow suit and fold up Periscope. If I were an engineer on that team, I'd do some proactive job hunting.

They mentioned Periscope during their live demo at the Apple event, so I would hope it stays for a while.

Re: Vine will be discontinuing the mobile app

#92
post #48

Never used Vine, and the videos from it never worked on my browser, but this is truly shocking. Like, Google Reader shutdown level shocking. Twitter is seriously clueless if they weren't able to make any use of such a popular service. Especially when Periscope is still running somehow. Though it's only a matter of time for that too now.

Periscope may stick around for a while only because of the current obsession with live video. As soon as Facebook gives up on live (or at least stops focusing so much on it), Twitter will follow suit and fold up Periscope. If I were an engineer on that team, I'd do some proactive job hunting.

Looks pretty clear that Facebook and Twitter are all-in on live video for the medium to long term. Twitter even has live broadcasting deals with NFL, MLB and NBA.

Re: Vine will be discontinuing the mobile app

#93

I don't get it. Why not make it Twitter's Dedicated Video App as vine already has a strong network which can be built upon. Very soon Facebook will release their dedicated video app and Twitter will be looking clueless. I don't get big companies

Twitter has another dedicated video app, Periscope.

To describe Vine and Periscope as "the same" because they are both "video apps" is like saying blueberries and a potato salad are the same because they're both food.

Re: Vine will be discontinuing the mobile app

#95
post #48

Never used Vine, and the videos from it never worked on my browser, but this is truly shocking. Like, Google Reader shutdown level shocking. Twitter is seriously clueless if they weren't able to make any use of such a popular service. Especially when Periscope is still running somehow. Though it's only a matter of time for that too now.

That's funny, I've always had the same experience with Vine--website always took a long time to load, then videos would hiccup a lot, if they loaded at all.

Re: Vine will be discontinuing the mobile app

#97

Never used Vine app and the vine video don't render on my browser which has flash disabled. But having just read the features of vine app, I'm surprised Twitter decided to let this go. An app which allows creating and playing 6 second video in a loop would, IMO, have been a good fit for advertising content creators and Twitter could have used Vine as one core product in their advertising platform - after all advertis…

I don't think advertisers would be happy with the 6-second format. If you could deliver a meaningful brand message in such a short amount of time, YouTube ads would look very different. (My proposition being that no-one ever watches more than the 5 seconds before the "Skip ad" button appears.)

Re: Vine will be discontinuing the mobile app

#98
post #92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Periscope may stick around for a while only because of the current obsession with live video. As soon as Facebook gives up on live (or at least stops focusing so much on it), Twitter will follow suit and fold up Periscope. If I were an engineer on that team, I'd do some proactive job hunting.

Looks pretty clear that Facebook and Twitter are all-in on live video for the medium to long term. Twitter even has live broadcasting deals with NFL, MLB and NBA.

I'm not sure that translates to full support for any random twitter user to be doing 'live' broadcasts. It may not be a huge impact on the infrastructure, but when cost-cutting comes up again, unless they're monetizing it somehow, I'd expect "random joe live-video broadcasting" to be on the chopping block.

MLB? NFL? NBA? I'm sure money's being exchanged to make it worthwhile to handle that.

Re: Vine will be discontinuing the mobile app

#99
post #70
post #57

Congress should make it illegal for a public company to shut down apps that see this much usage, unless the employees are quitting. Some users have 12 million followers.

That is the last possible thing we'd want. We already have contract law that covers the case where a customer has paid a provider to provide a service and the service provider stops without delivering. But, in the case of a free service, where there are no commitments, service providers should be free to stop providing services whenever they want.

So you think it should be legal for Facebook to decide to shut down, for example? Why does what the investors want matter more than what the users want?

Re: Vine will be discontinuing the mobile app

#100
post #57

Congress should make it illegal for a public company to shut down apps that see this much usage, unless the employees are quitting. Some users have 12 million followers.

Publicly-traded companies are still private sector. If Twitter were funded by taxes you might have a point. Someone should start an insurance company for startup users. ;)

Oh god, can you imagine the premiums on a policy where the probability of payout is "chances a startup fails" and the cost of payout is "enough money to run a failing startup indefinitely"?
Post reply on HN