Live data from Hacker News

Facebook, Amazon, Google, IBM and Microsoft Create Partnership on AI

techcrunch.com

141–150 of 270 posts

Re: Facebook, Amazon, Google, IBM and Microsoft Create Partnership on AI

#141
post #132
post #114

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Deep learning is not a simple statistical clustering algorithm. Trial and error is a main way that people learn and it works.

> Deep learning is not a simple statistical clustering algorithm. What is it, then? In the 60s people used backpropagation to train neural networks. NN + BP is a very simple statistical clustering algorithm. I know that when I worked on neural networks in the 90s we still used backpropagation. Are they using something different now?

>Are they using something different now?

Yes, why else do you think we've had such breakthroughs in the past six years?

Re: Facebook, Amazon, Google, IBM and Microsoft Create Partnership on AI

#142
post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> best of breed product company focused on a great user experience somehow i put them in the same category as LG, Samsung and Sony, albeit 100x better at what they do.

Apple's fastest growing revenue stream is services. It's already a 20 billion a year profit machine.

Can you give more information on this? I had no idea they had such a potent revenue stream in the services sector.

Re: Facebook, Amazon, Google, IBM and Microsoft Create Partnership on AI

#143
post #99

Earlier quoted context omitted.

'it really is a giant among giants.' You're confused. That would be Alphabet, not Apple. To put it in perspective for you, Google has: ~90% of the search market ( https://www.statista.com/statistics/216573/worldwide-market-... ) ~90% of the smartphone market ( https://techcrunch.com/2016/08/18/gartner-androids-smartphon... ) ~50% of the online advertisement market ( http://www.emarketer.com/Article/Google-Still-Domin…

>* I can think you can see the point I'm making: yes, Apple has a big pile of cash, a fat amount of profit and high stock value. However, Alphabet its influence and reach is far, far beyond that of Apple. Its just not as flashy & visible.* Yeah, Alphabet is bigger in every way that counts except those two inconsequential things for companies: revenue and profit.

Actually only profit matters. If I offered to sell you $2 billion worth of anything for $1 billion, voila, billion dollars in revenue.

Re: Facebook, Amazon, Google, IBM and Microsoft Create Partnership on AI

#144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

'it really is a giant among giants.' You're confused. That would be Alphabet, not Apple. To put it in perspective for you, Google has: ~90% of the search market ( https://www.statista.com/statistics/216573/worldwide-market-... ) ~90% of the smartphone market ( https://techcrunch.com/2016/08/18/gartner-androids-smartphon... ) ~50% of the online advertisement market ( http://www.emarketer.com/Article/Google-Still-Domin…

Both Google and Apple are extremely important, valuable companies that have had a very significant impact on the world and culture. Google created Google - they more or less are the internet (that and Facebook) for the world. To 'Google' something is a phrase that entered into the vocabulary a very long time ago. Both their enormous presence in Internet/search, plus more cultural things like Youtube makes it unable t…

What would have actually happened if Apple didn't make the iPhone?

Maybe Maemo wouldn't have been botched so badly?

Re: Facebook, Amazon, Google, IBM and Microsoft Create Partnership on AI

#145

Who gives a sh!t that Apple was not at the meeting. I think the main takeaway is that 4-5 companies might control one of the most powerful technologies/ideas of the last 5 years. Its already hard enough competing with these companies how is this good for everybody else?

edit: "The group plans to make discussions and minutes from meetings publicly available." I guess that is cool. But what about the competitive advantage these companies have right now? Does anybody monitor that stuff? I am not talking robots and singularity crap but rather companies that have means and the ability to make every decision with ML and the data to create an insurmountable competitive advantage.

...except for the secret meetings. Those records will be secret.

Re: Facebook, Amazon, Google, IBM and Microsoft Create Partnership on AI

#146

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apple's fastest growing revenue stream is services. It's already a 20 billion a year profit machine.

Can you give more information on this? I had no idea they had such a potent revenue stream in the services sector.

When Apple reported Q3 earnings this year, Tim Cook said that the services revenue would be "the size of a Fortune 100 company by next year."[0] Revenue was ~6 billion in Q3, up 19% from a year prior. That comes out to roughly 20 billion a year.

When I saw everyone playing Pokemon Go and buying coins and what have you, I thought of Apple taking a 30% cut of every transaction...

The service revenue really is the strongest case for being a bull. Of course this is just my own personal opinion. I own the stock and I'm long on the prospects. I also love the products. Also so much cash!

[0] http://www.businessinsider.com/apple-ceo-tim-cook-services-q...

Re: Facebook, Amazon, Google, IBM and Microsoft Create Partnership on AI

#147
post #41
post #30

Oh, great. So all the companies that have recently had the most problems with ethics issues and user privacy issues are now collaborating in order to more effectively address those issues? Pardon me if my scoffing is audible.

IMHO ethics will effectively be the defining characteristic of AI in the future. The companies who innovate AI, however, will probably never mention it except as marketing copy. That leaves literally everyone else holding the bag in regards to judging the industries actions and holding it accountable for transgressions. I'm not sure how that will work out, but I'm not terribly hopeful...

A major book about ethics, "After Virtue", takes as half of is subject matter what the author calls "the interminable nature of ethical debates" and the failure of post-enlightenment ethical thinking.

I don't see how AI is going to suddenly make us capable of ethical reasoning on a large scale... unless... maybe AI could do the reasoning for us...

Re: Facebook, Amazon, Google, IBM and Microsoft Create Partnership on AI

#148
post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> best of breed product company focused on a great user experience somehow i put them in the same category as LG, Samsung and Sony, albeit 100x better at what they do.

Apple has its own OS, compilers, IDE, 2+ languages, various frameworks etc. This is more than what Google, more importantly used a lot by people. But yeah it just a hardware company.

Not really. Google has Android OS, Chrome OS, Brillo OS, Andromeda OS, Fuchsia OS, Android Studio, Go, Dart, Angular JS, etc...

Re: Facebook, Amazon, Google, IBM and Microsoft Create Partnership on AI

#149
post #49

>>"As of today’s launch, companies like Apple, Twitter, Intel and Baidu are missing from the group. Though Apple is said to be enthusiastic about the project, their absence is still notable because the company has fallen behind in artificial intelligence when compared to its rivals — many of which are part of this new group." It seems Apple's lack of engagement in the community [1] is really starting to hurt it. Did…

There's no conspiracy here. Apple is just not involved in the machine learning community in the same way as these others. Look at NIPS and you'll see activity from all of the other participants in this announcement. Apple isn't present in the same way.

Re: Facebook, Amazon, Google, IBM and Microsoft Create Partnership on AI

#150
post #120
post #49

>>"As of today’s launch, companies like Apple, Twitter, Intel and Baidu are missing from the group. Though Apple is said to be enthusiastic about the project, their absence is still notable because the company has fallen behind in artificial intelligence when compared to its rivals — many of which are part of this new group." It seems Apple's lack of engagement in the community [1] is really starting to hurt it. Did…

I see a list of companies which are ethically compromised. Apple has publicly taken the opposite side of the fence on this one. I'm not sure they want to be associated with Facebook, Google, Amazon or Microsoft using AI to strip apart user's private behavior and reassemble it as advertising data. Would we trust a cooperative of tobacco companies funding scientific research and ethics surrounding the use and promotion…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN