Live data from Hacker News

A Theory of Creepiness

aeon.co

41–50 of 75 posts

Re: A Theory of Creepiness

#41
post #9

I found this essay interesting: > It’s not “creepy” if he’s hot. I freely admit it. When a very attractive stranger approaches me and tells me I’m beautiful, it brightens my day. When a guy who is short, fat or balding does it, it makes my skin crawl no matter how tactful he is about it. I just want him to go away. I’m not alone in feeling this way. Most women feel the same, but hide the true extent of it when the gu…

[deleted]

Re: A Theory of Creepiness

#42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not are. Are perceived as such by the surveyed set of women. Specifically, an ugly solicitor elicits a reaction comparable to a zombie in some women. This is generally a subconscious reaction belying sexual selection. Extreme but it happens. Less extreme version is tied to disgust feeling. The root is probably the same: detecting contagious people and animals.

Then the article should be about the inexcusable reactions of these women, instead of blaming ugly men for thinking they get to be human too.

The reactions are non-voluntary and humans evolved this way. And since it's in our genes that our women are predisposed to feel like ugly people are genetically inferior, that is enough proof to say that they really are in a certain circumstances, specifically where sexual selection is the deciding factor in the success of reproduction. We live at the times where sexual selection trumps all other factors by a large margin, so people who are not desirable because of things they may not have control of, because they are genetic, they can be called genetically inferior.

Re: A Theory of Creepiness

#43
post #24
post #9

I found this essay interesting: > It’s not “creepy” if he’s hot. I freely admit it. When a very attractive stranger approaches me and tells me I’m beautiful, it brightens my day. When a guy who is short, fat or balding does it, it makes my skin crawl no matter how tactful he is about it. I just want him to go away. I’m not alone in feeling this way. Most women feel the same, but hide the true extent of it when the gu…

This essay is a troll, surely? Or, the author is mentally disturbed.

It might (and maybe should) be, but maybe not (despite some glimpses of PUA language in there). The really sad part is: This thing has more upvotes than downvotes! That seems to indicate that this POV is somewhat accepted/shared by the given community. And while it is stupid, ugly and nauseating, it's not surprising. Or do we still think it's only men who can be disgusting fucktards? Also, equating physical beauty and even young age with genetic superiority? They don't come much stupider, do they? LAWL!

Re: A Theory of Creepiness

#44
The article isn't about the creepiness described in the comments here. It's more about creepiness in general, like in clowns. It's pretty standard stuff actually...creepiness isn't just physical threat, it's a sense of impurity or a pollution of a thing's essence. Clowns are impure in the sense that they are humans gone wrong, with waxlike and distorted features.

Re: A Theory of Creepiness

#45
When going from riding a bicycle to learning to drive a car, it is very easy to feel a lot of anxiety about it. After all, driving a car on American roads is a very morally strange thing: you are in fact imposing upon other people a risk of death or lifelong-debilitating injury. And you have to work to accept this. Of course you can and should avoid exacerbating that: only drive when sober and well-rested. Don't text and drive. Don't have complex discussions when driving. Scan your mirrors for bikes and motorcyclists. But as long as you are going to get up and go to work, you cannot reduce risk to 0%. And you have to work to accept this. There are even things you can do to actively be much better than most drivers: do the Dutch Reach[1] when you open your door. Spend $10 on a wide-angle mirror[2]. But ultimately you are still imposing an increased risk of death on others. And you have to work to accept this.

Likewise, when going from reading things like http://tinyurl.com/schrodingers-rapist, or various blogs written by and for those on the receiving end of stalking and street harassment, it is very easy to feel a lot of anxiety about the possibility of creeping someone out. But humans are strange and varied people who have all sorts of backgrounds and perceptions. And you have to work to accept this. You still must avoid doing things that will cause a reasonable predictive model of people to feel fear: Keep a situationally-reasonable distance from people. Don't shout things at people on the street. Don't present sexual/romantic intent to someone with a high cost to removing themselves from the situation. There are ways you can trade time/money or your preferences for other's comfort if you choose: learn to choose and wear nicer clothing. Speak in a slightly higher pitch. Avoid facial hair or tattoos. Have a friend smell-check you if your nose is impaired. But ultimately, people percieve things in different ways and some might perceive you as a threat. And you have to work to accept this.

[1] https://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2016/09/08/this-cyclist-wa... [2] https://www.amazon.com/Fit-System-RM011-Clip-Mirror/dp/B001A...

Re: A Theory of Creepiness

#46
post #40
post #29

Interesting side note: The words "Awkward" and "Creepy" don't exist in German and there are no direct or inderect equivalents. It goes so far that it is culturally impossible to have creepy or awkward behaviour.

Creepy ~= Gruselig/Unheimlich Awkward ~= Komisch/Unbeholfen And the concepts totally do translate to German. A lot of people would describe a "creepy guy" as "gruselig" in German. Actually we've imported the word "Freak" to describe these people. As an aside: there was a German copy of the "Beauty and the Geek" show that was far more dehumanising and called "Das Model und der Freak" where the entire concept was that…

> Creepy ~= Gruselig/Unheimlich

> Awkward ~= Komisch/Unbeholfen

Those translations don't really contain that additional negativity of "Creepy/Awkward". It is hard really pinpoint it though.

> there was a German copy of the "Beauty and the Geek" show that was far more dehumanising and called "Das Model und der Freak" where the entire concept was that "pretty" c-list celebrity women would give a "nerdy loser" a makeover to turn him into a generic alpha male womanisers.

But that was so much more over the top. Those guys were more like "eklig" (disgusting).

Re: A Theory of Creepiness

#47
The article states a couple times: "cognitive paralysis is what generates the sensation of creepiness."

It's the most confident statement in the article, but without supplying a reference. Can this be validated?

Re: A Theory of Creepiness

#48
post #44

The article isn't about the creepiness described in the comments here. It's more about creepiness in general, like in clowns. It's pretty standard stuff actually...creepiness isn't just physical threat, it's a sense of impurity or a pollution of a thing's essence. Clowns are impure in the sense that they are humans gone wrong, with waxlike and distorted features.

I think a lot of people have a lot of anxiety around the concept of creepiness and when something that looks like an opportunity to try to discuss and maybe resolve this anxiety presents itself in a community where they feel at home, they jump to discussion.

Of course, an openly-readable Internet forum is a risky place to open yourself up emotionally.

Re: A Theory of Creepiness

#49
post #46
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Creepy ~= Gruselig/Unheimlich Awkward ~= Komisch/Unbeholfen And the concepts totally do translate to German. A lot of people would describe a "creepy guy" as "gruselig" in German. Actually we've imported the word "Freak" to describe these people. As an aside: there was a German copy of the "Beauty and the Geek" show that was far more dehumanising and called "Das Model und der Freak" where the entire concept was that…

> Creepy ~= Gruselig/Unheimlich > Awkward ~= Komisch/Unbeholfen Those translations don't really contain that additional negativity of "Creepy/Awkward". It is hard really pinpoint it though. > there was a German copy of the "Beauty and the Geek" show that was far more dehumanising and called "Das Model und der Freak" where the entire concept was that "pretty" c-list celebrity women would give a "nerdy loser" a makeove…

To me the range of negativity (from let's say "creepy Halloween decoration" to "that creepy old guy" or "a jar full of babys' fingers") is similar in both languages, and something that has to be inferred from context. "Creepy" covers the disgusting axis a bit more, but eklig/ekelhaft covers that area easily if necessary.

The fact that "creepy" is used in German language sometimes points towards that the terms are not exactly identical, but it's a tiny difference and in no way big enough to say that the concept doesn't exist. It's just a shorthand for something that otherwise might require a modifier or explanation, + using English is cool.

Re: A Theory of Creepiness

#50
post #18

Just take comfort in knowing that female attractiveness usually drops off a cliff far earlier than male attractiveness does. The same girl writing that essay will one day be 40+ and begging for any of those "genetic superiors" to give her five seconds, while the same male "uggo" with a stable income and decent hygiene will be able to take his pick of a bunch of nicer women who didn't view the whole of humanity throug…

yeah, female skin ages faster, and skin is what we see on others. this ain't fair, but we can't fool genetics (for now). unconscious behavior like this made me lose much of the respect I had for women (and I started with lots of it!). the better I knew them the worse it got. sheepish mentality, playing all kinds of weird mind games all the time, frequent need of assurance of attractiveness and constant looking in the…

> Unconscious behavior like this made me lose much of the respect I had for women.

I agree. What really gets me is that you're told to open up and talk about your emotions. They paint to bottle up as a negative trait, but women usually lose all respect for men – friends and partners – who share their own fears and worries. One time is enough to ruin your image and dismiss the good times. Empathy is replaced by disgust, since they don't want to be seen around with a weakling.

I still believe everyone is worthy of respect and dignity. But I'm not going to put my trust on women. Sensitive men are creepy.

Post reply on HN