Live data from Hacker News

Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old immune system (2014)

news.usc.edu

121–130 of 175 posts

Re: Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old immune system (2014)

#121
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Some people have a lot of "bad stuff" which will enter their bloodstream when their body breaks down adipose for fuel. [...] you'll have severe "detox" symptoms a day or two into the fast. Your body doesn't work that way. "Detoxing diets" are pure superstition – which toxins are those supposed to be anyway? From [1]: "The 'toxins' usually remain undefined, with little to no evidence of toxic accumulation in the pat…

"Toxicological Function of Adipose Tissue: Focus on Persistent Organic Pollutants" http://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/wp-content/uploads/121/2/ehp.120548... "The studies discussed here indicate that AT (Adipose tissue) plays a central role in POP (persistent organic pollutants) toxicology. This role is complex and may seem paradoxical. Indeed, there is evidence that AT is protective under conditions of acute or subacute exposu…

POPs are an entirely different type of "toxins" than the ones homeopaths talk about.

Re: Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old immune system (2014)

#122
post #90

Well, Islam gave the concept of 3 days fasting every month 1500 years ago and called "Ayyam Beez" and many Muslims have been practising it in every generation. Glad to know that science also discovered it.

If we were to take everything religion brings to the table seriously we'd be in a big mess.

Re: Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old immune system (2014)

#123
post #118

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nobody (well, nearly nobody) denies that the body contains toxic substances. The disputed claim is that various fasting methods will remove those toxins, for which there is no evidence (in typical "alternative therapy" fashion). Of course, this doesn't mean that fasting can't have other health benefits. Want to help your body shed toxins? Drink some water, and your kidneys will get rid of them. The view that fasting…

Do you have any evidence that drinking more water alone without weight loss will remove the toxins from the adipose tissue that have accumulated over the years? I'm interested in learning how that works in more detail.

I didn't say anything about toxins in adipose tissue.

Re: Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old immune system (2014)

#125
post #115

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just a personal anecdote, but I was getting colds and flu-like symptoms several times per year for years. People I knew often commented on how often I was ill. I did a 3-day fast two years ago, and haven't had much more than a scratchy throat for about two days since. It could be coincidence, but other people have noticed and commented on my healthier state. I haven't significantly changed my behavior otherwise.

It has to be a coincidence. I can't imagine what the health benefits of a single 3-day fast could be that they would be so massive as to change your entire health for years.

A change in gut bacteria could potentially do that. However, normally that is quite difficult to change long term. I seem to have a collection of gut bacteria that give me bad gas quite often without sticking to a very strict diet and I found a few months ago that a five day fast reset that as well as antibiotics. However, either way it gradually returns to the way it was (most of the way back after three months). Good to know that three days of fasting helps some people, since that is much easier than five :/.

Re: Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old immune system (2014)

#126
post #89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yea. It was fairly uneventful. The first day or two I was hungry, but it was mild. Perhaps it was easy, as my eating habits left me naturally in intermittent fasting mode (I'd eat lunch at 1pm, dinner at 8pm, then nothing else).

Do you find that you drink more water to try and "stifle" the hunger?

Huh? I've been hungry before, so it wasn't too overwhelming. I just layed around, surfed the web, etc. It was fairly straightforward, familiar, and easy to ignore. As the days went on, the hunger went away, and my desire to drink water went down as well. I had to remind myself to continue consuming water (but then not too much, as that would be bad as well).

Re: Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old immune system (2014)

#127

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ingesting anything will ruin the fast. Even brushing your teeth becomes tricky, as toothpaste can ruin everything. I ended up using a salt water solution (and an electric tooth brush) to do the job, but in hindsight, I could've used something like ToothSoap. It's extremely important to rinse the mouth thoroughly, so you don't swallow anything. It is possible to run low on vitamins (depending on how long you go). If i…

and whats wrong with eating too much - I understand that you say breaking the fast is important ... but why?

I'm not clear on the details of why, but I know if the fast isn't properly broken, then the body can react very poorly. I suppose it needs time to get back in the habit of processing food. The main thing to remember about a fast is that it will take as long as you fasted to break it (unless it's 24 hours or less). So if you water fast for 3 days, you'll need another 3 days to ramp back up to normal eating. If you juice fast, then it's 1/3rd of the time (ie, 1 day for a 3-day juice fast).

I've read about people ending up with allergic reactions, swollen joints, pain, and many other issues from improperly breaking the fast. Also, me not remembering or being clear on the details doesn't mean they aren't clearly laid out on sites/articles about this topic. That is, you can search online for a bit, and it should clear things up for you.

Re: Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old immune system (2014)

#128
post #17

I tried searching for the original article, but this is the closest I could find that had a better writeup than from the telegraph: https://news.usc.edu/63669/fasting-triggers-stem-cell-regene... This is the most relevant summary: "In both mice and a Phase 1 human clinical trial involving patients receiving chemotherapy, long periods of not eating significantly lowered white blood cell counts. In mice, fasting cycles…

> I'll pass on this intermittent fasting "fad" for now! It's amazing how people are prone to experiment with this type of things. They're willing to undergo a very unpleasant experience because it might (unlikely) give them a (slight) health improvement.

I do fasting for 36 hours, night-day-night, 3-4 times per month. I have found it is a liberating experience. I never realized before that just how much time it takes to prepare and consume food.

As for side effects the only noticeable thing is that on the second night of fast I may sleep much less, but that does not make me sleepy during the day when I break the fast.

Re: Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old immune system (2014)

#129
post #17

I tried searching for the original article, but this is the closest I could find that had a better writeup than from the telegraph: https://news.usc.edu/63669/fasting-triggers-stem-cell-regene... This is the most relevant summary: "In both mice and a Phase 1 human clinical trial involving patients receiving chemotherapy, long periods of not eating significantly lowered white blood cell counts. In mice, fasting cycles…

> I'll pass on this intermittent fasting "fad" for now! It's amazing how people are prone to experiment with this type of things. They're willing to undergo a very unpleasant experience because it might (unlikely) give them a (slight) health improvement.

Imho the biggest "but why?" for me come when such people "experiment" but gather no data whatsoever other than "I feel okay/good/bad/". And this can easily get wishful-thinking directed.

Re: Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old immune system (2014)

#130
post #118
post #84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is very annoying when people dismiss anything sounding vaguely like "alternative therapy" out of fear of quackery. I remember reading a comment on Reddit where someone denied there the body ever contains any toxins... apparently they were not familiar that the liver and kidneys have a purpose.

Nobody (well, nearly nobody) denies that the body contains toxic substances. The disputed claim is that various fasting methods will remove those toxins, for which there is no evidence (in typical "alternative therapy" fashion). Of course, this doesn't mean that fasting can't have other health benefits. Want to help your body shed toxins? Drink some water, and your kidneys will get rid of them. The view that fasting…

I didn't even go into this. When the body is in the fasted state, it begins burning up whatever it can find (in priority order-- oldest/crappiest tissues first) to fuel its processes. This includes adipose tissue. In the process of breaking down this fat, stored/trapped toxins may end up released into the bloodstream.

Is this something that can be spun around to the point that it can be claimed water fasting results in detox? I don't know, but I suppose there is all around healing and rejuvenation during this time.

It's also good to give the body a rest from constant digestion, so it can see to other things, and as cravings are reset during the fast, it's an easy transition (afterward) to whatever diet you actually want to follow.

There are many things that detox the body (liposomal vitamin C (liposomal mainly due to the high dosages needed), liposomal glutathione, ashitaba, chlorophyll, Centrophenoxine, magnesium oil spray or magnesium lotion, mercury chelators like spirulina (unless you have amalgam fillings), etc).

Post reply on HN