Live data from Hacker News

Snowden: Hack of an NSA server is not unprecedented, publication of the take is

twitter.com

91–100 of 240 posts

Re: Snowden: Hack of an NSA server is not unprecedented, publication of the take is

#91
post #4

>8) Circumstantial evidence and conventional wisdom indicates Russian responsibility. Here's why that is significant: Interesting that he's not afraid to point the finger at Russia while still relying on them for protection. My respect for him just went up.

If Snowden is right then Russia wants people to know extra-officially that it was them.

exactly. the DNC hack was traced by 2 agencies and 3 private firms. no one leaves behind that kind of evidence unless they want to get caught

Re: Snowden: Hack of an NSA server is not unprecedented, publication of the take is

#92

IMHO Twitter is the worst media for this kind of discussion : I would have loved to read something more substantial but being limited to 140 char forces you to omit a lot of details. Why use something like 10 tweets where a blog post lets you have as many words as necessary. You can still be concise but 140 char is too short, it's just for people that have uninteresting things to say and Snowden is certainly not one…

I'm fond of tweeting a screenshot of longer text, e.g. from the notes app.

I don't know if you care about this, but when you post screenshots of text, make sure you also provide a transcription, or you'll be excluding visually impaired users from accessing your content.

Re: Snowden: Hack of an NSA server is not unprecedented, publication of the take is

#93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It takes Russia pointing this out to make us lose trust in the U.S.? I think the U.S. has done this all on their own. Snowden was just the latest whistleblower showing the world they can't be trusted. There were others before him, but it got swept under the rug. We all know the U.S. election system is flawed to a point of being broken and thus democracy as we like to believe it's supposed to work doesn't even exist.…

> We all know rolls eyes , adjust your tinfoil hat. Look, even if you believe that dark, unseen forces control the world using the US as a conduit - it would appear that the world has been the better for it. Given a choice of world management between Russian and US in this regard, the choice is pretty straightforward. People who complain about Europe, the US and the general Western alliances management of the world a…

Whether the US is a force for good is a completely different argument than whether it's untrustworthy and/or undemocratic.

Re: Snowden: Hack of an NSA server is not unprecedented, publication of the take is

#94
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The obvious solution is to use Twitter to link to your longer article. Isn't it?

I think people fear the rather nasty experience of embedded webview when you click a link. It seems to be a bit of a barrier to entry.

What is that? On both TweetDeck and the normal Twitter page, when I click a link the target opens in a new page; nothing embedded.

Re: Snowden: Hack of an NSA server is not unprecedented, publication of the take is

#95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I know enough to say that an anonymous comment on the internet pretending to know about NSA procedures & jargon is not worth much especially when said comment is attacking someone we know for sure had access to the NSA.

Alright bud. I don't have a facebook, twitter, instagram, or any of that other stuff, so I'm not sure how to refute your claim of anonymous. I can say that anonymous hostile replies sure don't do much to further the conversation. What do they say, something about pots and kettles?

A year ago you said you don't work for the NSA or DoD but know one person who does:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9297990

Are you seriously expecting us to believe that your friend is telling you how the NSA is internally structured and how sensitive foreign operation intelligence programs work?

Plus in another comment of yours you claimed to know how General Atomics MQ-1C Gray Eagle worked behind the scenes but when asked to post more info you never did.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10954248

So you're seemingly a Linux admin, but know tons about the inner workings of both military contractors, the DoD, and NSA from your single friend? Seems uhh a stretch, let's just say that.

Re: Snowden: Hack of an NSA server is not unprecedented, publication of the take is

#96

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Does anyone on earth not have an obligation to be ethical? (Yes, I know there is no universally accepted definition of "ethical".)

Yes, I don't. Because when you say "act ethical" you mean "do what pleases me". This is why you can't put forth a definition, because if you did, it would expose your hypocrisy. And I'm not one bit interested in doing what pleases you. I'm only interested in doing what pleases ME (as is every other person on Earth, although most will never admit it out of cowardice). So no, I don't have ANY obligation at all towards…

Pretty much right, you don't need a religion or code of conduct to tell you not to be a dick. With the NSA, and many other agencies and organizations, a culture of ends justifying means is highly contagious. Human nature and our reasons for being decent moral persons and speaking the truth instead of a lie, always has some threshold defined by our world view and beliefs. When you deal with scumbags all day, those pesky rules and rights are just in the way of justice some times.

Re: Snowden: Hack of an NSA server is not unprecedented, publication of the take is

#97
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah I don't understand why people don't just blog and be done with it, without all the formatting gredue. Then, you can just post a link on your twitter and say "hey, see my new blog post".

If HN and Reddit are any indication, if you post a link to a blog post, people will respond without reading it. People don't like switching domains, especially if they are browsing from an app. (Myself included)

Also blogs often mean fancy HTML etc, something that rarely produce a good reading experience on mobile devices.

Re: Snowden: Hack of an NSA server is not unprecedented, publication of the take is

#98
post #28

Ed was a Booz Allen Hamilton employee only for a couple of months. He wasn't even out of his probation period as an employee. It's really amazing that in such a short time he was able to siphon all this information out of the NSA. I wonder what more information could he have collected if he had spent a longer time contracting for the NSA. I wonder how much more about the NSA we could know if people who have dedicated…

If you want to put on your tinfoil hat for a second, consider the fact that Snowden started his career in the military, then moved to CIA, then moved to Booz Allen. It's entirely possible that Snowden is an ongoing CIA op to discredit their rival NSA as part of a turf war.

What else could he be? Don't have the time to enumerate all the reasons but if you entertain this option then a very happy news and silver lining follows ...

> tinfoil

You mean thinking and arriving at conclusions not blared from approved media outlets?

Re: Snowden: Hack of an NSA server is not unprecedented, publication of the take is

#99

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's also entirely possible that unicorns are real.

I really don't think it's an unreasonable possibility. It's a known fact Snowden worked for CIA and even received deep cover training while working in Geneva. Much of his behavior is not that of a hapless IT admin, but someone well trained in HUMINT operations. He comes from a multigenerational military family. That's the kind of background that breeds strong loyalty to the state, and the exact kind of background fro…

The kind of person with a deep loyalty to the S̶t̶a̶t̶e̶ constitution actually sounds like the kind of person who may try and sunlight what they perceive as an unconstitutional system. Especially if they feel they will be remembered as a patriot for it.

Besides, the private sector pays a lot better than the CIA, and nobody is free from the gravitas of wealth.

Re: Snowden: Hack of an NSA server is not unprecedented, publication of the take is

#100

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thank you for summarizing that. As others have commented, I wish Snowden would simply blog about this sort of thing. Twitter is frustrating to digest for any insightful commentary that is on the longer side.

In this case Twitter at least provides a single authoritative source, which is valuable.

True, but there are ways you can do something similar on a blog. If you link to the blog post from Twitter, I think that becomes a simple confirmation that the person wrote it.

Or, given this is Snowden, he could GPG sign his blog posts and post his fingerprint to Twitter or something to verify identity.

Post reply on HN