Live data from Hacker News

“But he does good work.”

medium.com

111–120 of 289 posts

Re: “But he does good work.”

#111
post #108

Is there really a big problem with acceptable/legal behavior not being agreed upon? Isn't the problem usually that the guy claims "it was consensual?" Similarly, when police consider what a woman was wearing, isn't usually in the context of figuring out who's story they believe? In other words, the police aren't thinking "well, she wore a sexy dress and followed him to his room and therefore deserved to get raped" bu…

What someone is wearing has nothing to do with consent.

Re: “But he does good work.”

#112

Why does it seem like people working in tech have such a hard time keeping their personal and professional lives separate? I'm not just talking about incidents of poor conduct. It's also the fact people are exchanging insults and serious accusations over blog posts. It's not like the observers have the facts and evidence to make fair judgements on these matters. The whole trial by social media is really embarrassing…

i have been wondering this exact same thing too. this seems like it is isolated mostly to the tech community.

Re: “But he does good work.”

#113
post #105

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Edit: Oops, I misread the parent, and I agree that yes, seeking legal help in a case like this is much harder than with robbery, which is hard enough. ----- Robbery doesn't really make for a good comparison here: - Did you fear for your own physical safety (e.g. that the thief or their friends/etc might retaliate) in reporting the crime to the police? - Did you known the thief? Did you have friends in common, or did…

Yes, I agree, robbery doesn't make a good comparison with rape because I had every reason to make the accusation of robbery, and such allegations are made on standards of evidence that most people agree on. Even though I knew it was going to be a pain in the ass, it was something that I had to do because 1) hard to file a insurance claim without a police report 2) kind of hard to just let a gun-wielding robber run ar…

Thanks to another poster, I realized I'd misread your last paragraph as "yeah, it's hard to go to the police, but I did it, too." Sorry! I totally agree with everything you're saying here.

Re: “But he does good work.”

#114
post #48

Wow this is messed up. This guy is clearly a predator and it's pretty shocking that he was able to operate in this way for so long. As much as women can be marginalized and harassed at tech companies I can easily see how the problem could be much worse with organizations like the Tor Project or Wikileaks that don't necessarily have professional management. > These are causes, not just jobs or consulting gigs. They ar…

yea, it's strangely counterintuitive: the politics of tor are non-mainstream, but in a potentially positive way. yet, that left the door open for seriously negative sociopolitical issues. is that the tl;dr of the parent post?

anyway, i don't care what "league" this guy is in. wouldn't want to be around behavior like that.

> what about the reality where Hitler cured cancer, Morty? it's best not to think about it.

Re: “But he does good work.”

#115

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I certainly agree with your basic grounds, but there's a rape allegation needed when people are willing to spray paint "a rapist lives here" on your home.

Which I don't see anyone doing? Maybe in some other article/blog post but in the one here I see accusations of harassment and brief mentions that others are accusing of rape.

Someone literally did that.

https://contraspin.co.nz/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/mc1.png

Re: “But he does good work.”

#116
post #48

Wow this is messed up. This guy is clearly a predator and it's pretty shocking that he was able to operate in this way for so long. As much as women can be marginalized and harassed at tech companies I can easily see how the problem could be much worse with organizations like the Tor Project or Wikileaks that don't necessarily have professional management. > These are causes, not just jobs or consulting gigs. They ar…

I don't know if it is clear as I know neither of the persons involved (do you?).

What seems ever clearer to me though is that many of the organizations/movements we look up to employ and attract certain kinds of people amongst which you'd probably find quite a few psychopaths as well (maybe even more so with "causes").

Do we need to fight fire with fire?

If so, how can we keep our "beneficial" predators (?!) in check (?!?!) insofar as to steer them towards "just doing their job" by concentrating their pernicious powers on the psychopathic bodies (people, organizations, skynet..) we need to be fighting?

If not, let's all level-up and fend them off - people involved with "causes" especially - hierarchies and secrets are the breeding ground for psychopaths as per Hintjens "Power Pyramids vs. Living Systems":

http://content.psychopathcode.com/chapter2.html

http://hintjens.com/blog:_psychopaths

Re: “But he does good work.”

#117
post #64

From an older guy (and happily married) guy to the male population in tech. If you see behaviors like this and let it happen, you're complicit ... if you're in a position of authority (someone's boss) and you let it happen, you may also be criminally liable. But it's far worse ... what I hope is a small minority of bad actors are defining the definition of male in our culture. Since there's an even smaller number men…

"If you see behaviors like this and let it happen, you're complicit ... if you're in a position of authority (someone's boss) and you let it happen, you may also be criminally liable."

As another older guy, also happily married, I agree completely.

That said, as someone who hasn't observed behavior like this while in the industry and certainly doesn't practice it....God, I'm tired of being painted with a broad brush (in general, I'm not implying that smoyer did so) and told that I'm part of the problem.

The finger-waggling can get quite grating if you're just trying to do your best day-to-day without being a dick to anybody. I suspect there are quite a few guys in the same boat who don't have issues with anybody due to their gender, race, religion or sexual orientation but are dealing with "chastisement fatigue".

Edit: What, I'm the villain for agreeing with the parent post but complaining about being painted with a broad brush? What the hell is wrong with some of you?

Re: “But he does good work.”

#118
post #86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Has anyone actually put their real name on something saying they were personally attacked by him yet? Last I checked everything was just vague accusations, has this changed?

The author says: > Tor Project’s director went on to tell Wired that someone was indeed raped, that the project is working with legal, and that she “absolutely believes” the victim. The Wired story is this: https://www.wired.com/2016/06/tor-developer-jacob-appelbaum-... There's no name, but you have the potential for a legal case to be brought up. And, at the very least, you have the Tor Project's executive director,…

> Just because repeatedly telling your colleague that you'd like to fuck-them-oh-please-why-won't-you-fuck-me isn't technically rape or something that can be elevated to a criminal charge [0], that doesn't mean that it's not abuse that warrants kicking someone out of an organization.

And even though it's not criminal, it is definitely not legal in the workplace. The employer has an obligation to not allow this type of behavior to go unchecked.

Re: “But he does good work.”

#119

If a guy like this were to get a legitimate psychiatric diagnosis, what do you suppose it'd be? Not that I feel bad for the guy, mind you, rather I feel it'd be helpful to the community of people who have been affected by this kind of behavior to have an accurate name for it other than just saying the guy is a douchebag. I knew a guy in college who had some aspects of this guy's behavior and was diagnosed with narcis…

It's funny that we look for a diagnosis when something terrible happens. Why do we do it? I guess so we can work to help people that suffer from said diseases, but there are also plenty of people that do horrible things that don't fall into certain categories/diagnoses.

Re: “But he does good work.”

#120
post #64

From an older guy (and happily married) guy to the male population in tech. If you see behaviors like this and let it happen, you're complicit ... if you're in a position of authority (someone's boss) and you let it happen, you may also be criminally liable. But it's far worse ... what I hope is a small minority of bad actors are defining the definition of male in our culture. Since there's an even smaller number men…

   are you willing to step up your game? 
I'm going to step up: what are you doing concretely to stop dead false accusations?

What are you doing to counter the blatant misandry in current harassment laws? To wit, you wrote "If you're a woman being harassed ..." this is a blatantly sexist question. What if you are a man being harassed by a woman?

Post reply on HN