Live data from Hacker News

TP-Link begins router firmware lockdown due to FCC proposed regulation

ml.ninux.org

71–77 of 77 posts

Re: TP-Link begins router firmware lockdown due to FCC proposed regulation

#71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not cheap, but it's badass. https://omnia.turris.cz/en/

The page says starting at 99 and I literally couldn't find a buy button fast enough. After landing on the Indiegogo page and seeing how much it would cost for a few of the features I'm interested in- yeah, I'll pass. It sounds like a heck of a router but it got spendy fast.

There's also this. https://www.thinkpenguin.com/catalog/wireless-networking-gnu...

Re: TP-Link begins router firmware lockdown due to FCC proposed regulation

#72
I needed to put together a VPN router because of an upcoming trip. Since I didn't want to bring a "giant" 4 port router, I went looking for an OpenWRT-compatible travel router. The TP-Link TL-WR710N and D-Link DIR-505L were my two candidates. :)

I setup OpenVPN as a bridge and configured an SSID on it so when I connect to it, it'll be as if I were still at home. (Same subnet so I have access to all my printers, tv tuners, etc).

This is disappointing news. What I just did would not have been possible for $15. I've been using OpenWRT for over 10 years and can't imagine ever using a router without some sort of customizable Linux on it. I've learned so much about Linux, networking, VPNs, etc from OpenWRT.

Re: TP-Link begins router firmware lockdown due to FCC proposed regulation

#73
post #17

So are there still good, cheap 802.11ac routers that OpenWRT supports well? Now may be the right time to upgrade my 802.11n router.

There are no 802.11ac radios that are as well-supported as the ath9k 802.11n radios. All 802.11ac radios require closed-source firmware. Qualcomm-Atheros, MediaTek, and Marvell 802.11ac platforms are getting the most open-source attention. QCA chips are really popular and the drivers are pretty mature, MediaTek's firmware is flexible enough to make it one of the more hacker-friendly platforms, and Marvell's radios are often paired with their really powerful (by router standards) processors.

Unless you really need the throughput of 802.11ac or a more powerful processor to keep up with faster WAN speeds, ath9k 802.11n devices are still a pretty good choice.

Re: TP-Link begins router firmware lockdown due to FCC proposed regulation

#74
post #56
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's the gun argument

Restricting the sale of guns makes it harder for the average person, but the bad guys will always have a way.

Its also the same argument regarding the war on drugs. It never works but thats not really the point. The point is to create options to apply pressure whenever government decides it wants to.

Re: TP-Link begins router firmware lockdown due to FCC proposed regulation

#77

And this is why, in a nutshell, linux should switch to GPL3. Right now there is no issue for TP-link to "preenmptively" block their hardware. If there was, they would think twice about it.

> And this is why, in a nutshell, linux should switch to GPL3. Unfortunately, given the number of developers that would have to agree, the fact that early contributions weren't attributed and the can of worms that defining what a derivative work is opens, makes relicensing very unlikely.

Not really. Think about it. Only to remove restrictions from a license do you need permission from the existing developers. To introduce extra restrictions you don't need anyone's permission. If Linus chooses to accept a single patch that's GPLv3, the kernel is GPLv3 from that point forward.

Linus has in fact done this to quite a bit of MIT licensed code.

Of course it only applies to future versions, and you could conceivably make versions that have those patches removed.

Post reply on HN