Live data from Hacker News

TP-Link begins router firmware lockdown due to FCC proposed regulation

ml.ninux.org

11–20 of 77 posts

Re: TP-Link begins router firmware lockdown due to FCC proposed regulation

#11
Why do people /ever/ take anything said by support personnel seriously?

Support personnel do not know about technical details of a product. They don't know about legal regulation of their products. They certainly don't know about specific technical details of their products due to intricacies in the regulation of their product.

Re: TP-Link begins router firmware lockdown due to FCC proposed regulation

#13
post #9

I'd be hesitant to trust what comes from a CS rep regarding a manufacturer's policy regarding the interpretation/compliance of an FCC rule. TP-Link may have just decided to lock down their devices regardless. I'm not saying this "report" isn't accurate... I'd just rather hear this from someone other than a random CS chat.

if there is any legal ambiguity whatsoever, they are going to play it safe

Re: TP-Link begins router firmware lockdown due to FCC proposed regulation

#14
post #2

Well crap... I have two C7s. IMO there might not be (or at least have been) a better mainstream router for the price.

I got an Archer C7 during the Winter Shopping Season, that was affected by this. In the current revision, I got around the lock by booting into recovery mode and uploading OpenWRT via TFTP. I expect that future models will close this hole, and then I definitely won’t be buying TP-LINK devices in the future.

I think it’s a bit extreme to say the C7 is the best. It never was the best performer, and already 802.11ac Wave 2 devices with MU-MIMO are on the market, potentially outperforming the C7. Maybe it’s coincidentally the best value for the money, but that will not last.

Every generation, I wearily observe the large number of router models. I thought the Buffalo WZR-600DHP was a pretty good value late in the 802.11n generation, but now it’s retailing for more than I paid for it. WiFi routers are a lemon market.

Re: TP-Link begins router firmware lockdown due to FCC proposed regulation

#15

So sad, I got a nice tplink for my mother and installed openwrt to gain some more control over the device. Unfortunate to see this support go away due to government.

Indeed. After much research I replaced my venerable wrt-54g with a tp-link, wrt-3600 or something like that, anyway due to the ath9k WiFi chip it's supported by Linux without any binary blobs. And of course I promptly replaced the stock firmware with openwrt. Sad if this is going away..

Re: TP-Link begins router firmware lockdown due to FCC proposed regulation

#19
post #2

Well crap... I have two C7s. IMO there might not be (or at least have been) a better mainstream router for the price.

It's not cheap, but it's badass. https://omnia.turris.cz/en/

This hardware and software spec looks really good, I'm getting one as well. Too bad my ISP can't offer anything more than 2mbps...

Re: TP-Link begins router firmware lockdown due to FCC proposed regulation

#20
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's expected other manufacturers will begin locking down their firmware. Ubiquiti, for example, already does.

Out of curiosity, why would you want to reflash an Ubiquiti AP or router? They tend to be extremely feature rich, since they target enterprise and professional customers.

Hi, as an example, we use the qmp.cat software for creating wireless mesh networks.
Post reply on HN