Live data from Hacker News

Female violinist exposes 10 years of lewd, fetishizing messages from men online

washingtonpost.com

51–58 of 58 posts

Re: Female violinist exposes 10 years of lewd, fetishizing messages from men online

#51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or perhaps creeps could try stop being creeps.

Yeah totally. And murders should stop being murders. And rapists should stop being rapists. So easy!

I wasn't quite ready to go with 'creeps should be removed from society for the good of the rest of us', but ok.

Re: Female violinist exposes 10 years of lewd, fetishizing messages from men online

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yupp. As many, including Brianna Wu, have done. Then what? The harasser could be a 21 year old man in Siberia, covering himself up with multiple layers of anonymity. I'm suggesting that the attackers will keep attacking until you leave the platform, or just shut up, and so they will have won. The means to police harassment is not yet where we expect it to be. Why should those that are being attacked be on the lookout…

I'm not going to pretend I have answer, but I'm just going to repeat what I said; that celebrities have been trying to solve this problem for a long time. They hire security, have security installed in their homes, etc. etc. Plugging our ears and saying "LALALA the bad guys need to stop being bad" won't solve anything. Because yes, people will hide behind proxies. You don't need to leave the platform. You don't need…

You know, the kinds of comments you have repeatedly made in this discussion helps create an atmosphere where creeps feel okay about doing shitty things and everyone looks the other way and says "Boys will be boys."

I get that you think you are just being pragmatic, but since you do not have an actual solution to offer, the best thing you can do is at least not help promote an atmosphere where folks think it is normal and okay for men to behave this way. Choosing to not put out the fire with gasoline is a constructive choice if you have no real solution to offer. It at least burns slower that way.

Re: Female violinist exposes 10 years of lewd, fetishizing messages from men online

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>> Perhaps people facing consistent harassment like this should try something similar? Or work under a pseudonym? Perhaps we need to get rid of pseudonyms. A lot of this behavior would stop if people had to be identifiable. Although that doesn't seem to stop them all - you see some real names and email addresses in there.

Then post your name and address.

>> Then post your name and address.

I almost do. You should be able to locate my real world postal address inside of 10 minutes. Probably 5.

I'm not saying there should be no anonymity online. I think the default should be identifiable, and sites and services can strip that info and provide locally anonymous environments. That way you can't get anonymous attacks unless you're participating in those places. It's easy to strip ID, but hard to verify it if it's not built-in.

Re: Female violinist exposes 10 years of lewd, fetishizing messages from men online

#54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Then post your name and address.

>> Then post your name and address. I almost do. You should be able to locate my real world postal address inside of 10 minutes. Probably 5. I'm not saying there should be no anonymity online. I think the default should be identifiable, and sites and services can strip that info and provide locally anonymous environments. That way you can't get anonymous attacks unless you're participating in those places. It's easy…

So you would require all online activity be done through "identity verifiers" such as Facebook? You have probably seen how many issues Facebook's Real Name policy has caused, and that doesn't even come close that level.

Re: Female violinist exposes 10 years of lewd, fetishizing messages from men online

#55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>> Then post your name and address. I almost do. You should be able to locate my real world postal address inside of 10 minutes. Probably 5. I'm not saying there should be no anonymity online. I think the default should be identifiable, and sites and services can strip that info and provide locally anonymous environments. That way you can't get anonymous attacks unless you're participating in those places. It's easy…

So you would require all online activity be done through "identity verifiers" such as Facebook? You have probably seen how many issues Facebook's Real Name policy has caused, and that doesn't even come close that level.

No. I would have at least a secure subnet that uses a slice of IPv6 address space to geolocate - encode lat/long/alt. As one example. So now if you know where a packet came from, you can walk your ass over there and knock on the door. I say a slice of the space because things mobile wouldn't work. There are issue of course, you need to be able to support multiple carriers among other things. But nobody is even trying to solve the problems around this, and they won't because nobody from corporations to government agencies wants it to exist.

Re: Female violinist exposes 10 years of lewd, fetishizing messages from men online

#56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Then post your name and address.

>> Then post your name and address. I almost do. You should be able to locate my real world postal address inside of 10 minutes. Probably 5. I'm not saying there should be no anonymity online. I think the default should be identifiable, and sites and services can strip that info and provide locally anonymous environments. That way you can't get anonymous attacks unless you're participating in those places. It's easy…

IP addresses are not people and WiFi isn't always secure.

http://www.aircrack-ng.org/doku.php?id=cracking_wpa

Re: Female violinist exposes 10 years of lewd, fetishizing messages from men online

#57
post #4

I read that (deep) learning algos can decide if a message is positive or negative. Could they learn if a message is a harassment so we could implement a automatic filter for such things? -- Edit -- I mean this is really bad and we should get these dudes to stop somehow. But it greatly reduced my anger looking into my inbox, when I stopped seeing spam in there. The spammers did never stop...

That would be a great idea if all messages were not harmful in reality.

Unfortunately, some of those threatening messages are from real world stalkers. Those need to be seen because the message might be the only clue that the person has been targeted.

Such threatening messages must not be automatically deleted, rather seen, saved, and forwarded to the appropriate authorities.

Re: Female violinist exposes 10 years of lewd, fetishizing messages from men online

#58
post #4

I read that (deep) learning algos can decide if a message is positive or negative. Could they learn if a message is a harassment so we could implement a automatic filter for such things? -- Edit -- I mean this is really bad and we should get these dudes to stop somehow. But it greatly reduced my anger looking into my inbox, when I stopped seeing spam in there. The spammers did never stop...

That would be a great idea if all messages were not harmful in reality. Unfortunately, some of those threatening messages are from real world stalkers. Those need to be seen because the message might be the only clue that the person has been targeted. Such threatening messages must not be automatically deleted, rather seen, saved, and forwarded to the appropriate authorities.

Messaging between people is a complex dynamic system. If stalkers knew their messages never got received, they'd quit sending them (and perhaps stop stalking in that way). Obsessing over the messages in sort of feeding the stalker game.
Post reply on HN