App Engine vs Heroku

#1

Post by fleclerc » Wed, Sep 26, 2012, 1:03 AM UTC

Hi,

I am currently considering two options as a back-end to a CRUD type mobile application: App Engine and Heroku. While it is fairly easy to calculate the costs of the Heroku option, I do not have experience with App Engine so I don't really know what to expect if I get a decent number of hits per day. App Engine looks like the easiest option technically but is this worth having your data and app logic tied to Google's platform?

Have you used App Engine / Heroku lately? Any thoughts?

Thanks!

Re: App Engine vs Heroku

#2

Post by rbanffy » Wed, Sep 26, 2012, 1:10 AM UTC

The free tier of App Engine (I'm only familiar with the Python platform) is somewhat accommodating. If it becomes too expensive, you may choose to move your app to your own machines running Typhoonae or Appscale. Neither of those is easy to install.

Heroku runs more portable things you can easily deploy on your own boxes.

Re: App Engine vs Heroku

#3

Post by outside1234 » Wed, Sep 26, 2012, 4:52 AM UTC

App Engine is a disaster - go with Heroku and Rails or with AWS/Azure/Linode with Rails on IAAS. :)

Re: App Engine vs Heroku

#4

Post by kaipakartik » Wed, Sep 26, 2012, 6:29 AM UTC

outside1234 wrote: post #3

App Engine is a disaster - go with Heroku and Rails or with AWS/Azure/Linode with Rails on IAAS. :)

Why may I ask is appengine a disaster

Re: App Engine vs Heroku

#5

Post by bcarlson » Wed, Sep 26, 2012, 9:27 AM UTC

I've switched from app engine to heroku. Even if you can get past the vendor lock in, carefully review the limitations: file-size, collection size, etc. They may have good reasons for these, but I spent more time working/thinking around these than I expected.

I AppEngine is a great platform for getting an app off the ground, and for a POC... but beyond that I wouldn't recommend it.

-Ben

Re: App Engine vs Heroku

#6

Post by haegwankim » Wed, Sep 26, 2012, 5:10 PM UTC

After trying the both PaaS, I recommend Heroku for better deploy experience and lots of add-ons you can use later if necessary.

Re: App Engine vs Heroku

#7

Post by jamesjguthrie » Wed, Sep 26, 2012, 8:28 PM UTC

I might try Heroku later but for now I'm using App Engine - mainly with JSONengine

Re: App Engine vs Heroku

#8

Post by novaleaf » Thu, Sep 27, 2012, 1:38 AM UTC

heroku seems interesting, but if you are a "starter" (like me) i have to say GAE's "one way of doing things" is attractive.

Re: App Engine vs Heroku

#9

Post by albumedia » Thu, Sep 27, 2012, 2:47 AM UTC

App engine is great, especially for small teams. I personally like webapp2 and click to deploy.

It's important to note the various limitations(file size,writes to file system,etc).

Re: App Engine vs Heroku

#10

Post by fleclerc » Thu, Sep 27, 2012, 4:23 AM UTC

bcarlson wrote: post #5

I've switched from app engine to heroku. Even if you can get past the vendor lock in, carefully review the limitations: file-size, collection size, etc. They may have good reasons for these, but I spent more time working/thinking around these than I expected. I AppEngine is a great platform for getting an app off the ground, and for a POC... but beyond that I wouldn't recommend it. -Ben

Hi Ben,

I know I would get to beta 1 or a prototype faster on app engine but I did not know the limitations you mention would cause such headaches. I thought we had more room.

What I like of app engine is the search service but I think it could become costly - there is no price right now but the api call limits seem rather low. And I see that you can do full text search in Postgres at no additional cost than the monthly database plan.