Live data from Hacker News

Instagram forcing users to login to browse

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 11 posts

Re: Instagram forcing users to login to browse

#5
That's weird, I haven't been able to see stuff on insta since the first time I tried clicking a link to a friend's post, several years ago. I wonder why your experience is so different -- perhaps my friends are nobodies and your favorite bands aren't?

Re: Instagram forcing users to login to browse

#6
I never quite get these comments. You are complaining because a website does not let you consume its content without having an account and, mind you, a free account.

If you were trying to buy groceries and had no interest in Instagram but you were forced to create an Instagram account to buy the groceries, that would be a problem, but this type of comments complains that they like the content but find it unacceptable to be asked to open a free account to consume it. God forbid someone asks money for a service people want to use: how dare you ask for payment for a product I want to use.

Re: Instagram forcing users to login to browse

#7
post #6

I never quite get these comments. You are complaining because a website does not let you consume its content without having an account and, mind you, a free account. If you were trying to buy groceries and had no interest in Instagram but you were forced to create an Instagram account to buy the groceries, that would be a problem, but this type of comments complains that they like the content but find it unacceptable…

To argue your point the content on Instagram is not theirs but the users who uploaded it. The billions they make on advertising is because of the users who upload content and the users who interact with it.

Yes, they built the structure but it's an empty house without the users content.

Re: Instagram forcing users to login to browse

#8
post #2

It's been like that for years, speaking as someone without an IG account. Nothing new here.

There is something new. You used to be at least able to hit someone's page, and see a few recent posts. You also could open posts in a new tab. Those actions are no longer possible - it goes straight to a login page when you hit someone's URL.

Re: Instagram forcing users to login to browse

#10
It makes sense from business perspective but I hate it.

If they don't know who you are, they can't send you hyper targeted ads and make more money from you. They probably get a lot of people to sign in by blocking content so it's worth it to lose the smaller group that gives up and leaves.

Post reply on HN