Live data from Hacker News

iPhone is a terrible Product Name

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 12 posts

Re: iPhone is a terrible Product Name

#3

But... these things we all carry around are still called phones right? And then there's the $123.9 billion in revenue they just reported last week. Seems like the name isn't that terrible...

Why are they still called phones though ? that's my point .. essentially you have a computer in your hands that happens to have an ability to make voice calls .. I was looking for stats on how people use their devices but can't find much actual data

Re: iPhone is a terrible Product Name

#4
You are suggesting that the entemology of the word fixes the meaning of the word forever. Whereas the word itself can change meaning as time passes.

Those things we carry around were called phones, because they were invented to make phone calls. They evolved into so much more, but the thing you carry around is still called a phone.

Jobs introduced it as 3 devices in one, a phone, a music player, and an internet browser. Should he have called it iBrowse or iMusic?

This morphing of meaning is part of language - Facebook is not a book, and is mostly not face's. Should it me called something else?

Re: iPhone is a terrible Product Name

#5

But... these things we all carry around are still called phones right? And then there's the $123.9 billion in revenue they just reported last week. Seems like the name isn't that terrible...

Why are they still called phones though ? that's my point .. essentially you have a computer in your hands that happens to have an ability to make voice calls .. I was looking for stats on how people use their devices but can't find much actual data

but...but... who cares what it's called man?

I mean a lot of us work from home, cook from home, and exercise from home. We don't call it the GymKitchenOffice

Re: iPhone is a terrible Product Name

#7
post #4

You are suggesting that the entemology of the word fixes the meaning of the word forever. Whereas the word itself can change meaning as time passes. Those things we carry around were called phones, because they were invented to make phone calls. They evolved into so much more, but the thing you carry around is still called a phone. Jobs introduced it as 3 devices in one, a phone, a music player, and an internet brows…

Etymology.

Entemology is the study of insects.

Re: iPhone is a terrible Product Name

#8
My primary use case for carrying it everywhere is to take phone calls, as it is for most people, otherwise we'd probably all use iPads or iPod Touches or something. It's useful because it's an internet device in your pocket, but it couldn't be that if it wasn't already in your pocket for a reason.

Re: iPhone is a terrible Product Name

#9
It's a device that connects to your local telco network. Telcos have evolved from calls to data. I'd say it still fits. It's a device that connects to your telco to serve internet access these days.
Post reply on HN